Manzo Elementary: worth seeing, worth saving

by David Safier
I’m not easily blown away by a school. But I have to say, I was blown away during my tour of Manzo Elementary School in  Barrio Hollywood this morning.

I’ll admit, when a lovely, confident, knowledgeable fifth grader escorts me through the school, talking about the place with the proud sense of ownership of someone who’s showing me her home, I get a little weak-kneed. But I grew even more impressed when I talked with the principal, Mark Alvarez, and the school counselor who’s the driving force behind the school’s ecology project, Moses Thompson. They, along with the rest of the staff and the students, have created a place that should be a model for how a school can be transformed into something extraordinary.

I went to the school tour this morning not knowing what to expect. I just wanted to see why so many people are trying to protect Manzo from being closed. As Marissa (I hope I got her name right) Melissa led me around the school, I began to wonder why TUSD is keeping the place a secret. It’s a showcase for how a creative, visionary staff can transform a school into a place where students are involved and active participants, where learning is going on inside and outside the classroom.

I was told the two Board members in favor of closing the school, Miguel Cuevas and Alexandre Sugiyama, haven’t paid a visit, at least not recently. They shouldn’t say another word about the school until they see it for themselves. (Mark Stegeman also hasn’t paid a recent visit. He has suggested the school might be closed, then opened as a district-run charter school.)

Below the fold, you can look at a few pics I took this morning, but first, here’s a brief description. Manzo is one of those classic old brick elementary schools with classrooms ringing large open spaces. The area in the top photo is a traditional grass-and-picnic-table affair, though the large rain water cistern in the foreground is a bit unusual. The back space has been completely transformed. It’s a vegetable garden, a chicken coup, a composting space and, most recently, a greenhouse that will house a hydroponic area for tilapia which is currently inside one of the classrooms — and there’s more in various states of completion.

The students are involved in every phase of the project, from planning to building to implementation (Many of them were at school on a Saturday, proudly leading tours of interested adults). Marissa Melissa was able to describe it all to me in depth, but her special area is composting. She’s one of the students who gather leftovers from the cafeteria at lunch time, which is added to the compost heap and will eventually be used to nurture the soil. (I was told by a staff member that the cafeteria waste is weighed and charted daily to try and understand why some days produce more compostable material than others.) All around the school, cisterns are hooked to roof downspouts, and they supply the project’s water. In front of the chicken coop are two charts, one numerical, one a bar chart, tallying the number and kind of eggs the chickens lay. The eggs are collected and sold.

Principal Alvarez told me the ecology project is funded by a variety of small grants. The school has interns from UA helping at the school. I met one, a PhD candidate in microbiology, shovel in hand, who sounded like he was absolutely committed to the students and the school’s mission.

Manzo has over 85% Hispanic students, and over 92% of its students are on free or reduced lunch. It’s on the school closure list because it’s underenrolled and its test scores, especially in math, are low. The staff, however, is working hard to bring up the math scores, and the fifth grade reading and writing scores are high, a very encouraging sign. The ecological project is young — it began about 4 years ago — and it’s already attracting students from outside the neighborhood. My sense is, if this school is given time to develop its mix of traditional classroom learning and desert-friendly ecological education, along with the opportunity to build the number of staff members who are committed to its innovative model, it will continue to improve, maybe even provide a model for TUSD and some much needed positive publicity for the District’s efforts to provide a variety of opportunities for its students.

Manzo_6

The garden (with rock paths between the rows of vegetables) and the cisterns that supply its water.

Manzo_5

The newly erected greenhouse which will be dedicated Friday (more about the dedication in a later post).

Manzo_4

The compost piles being pecked at by chickens, whose coop is in the background.

Manzo_2

The principal, Mark Alvarez, who attended TUSD, later taught at many of the schools he attended, and has been principal at Manzo for 3 years. Over his left shoulder is Moses Thompson, the school counselor who guided the ecology project from the beginning.

0 responses to “Manzo Elementary: worth seeing, worth saving

  1. It is tremendously uplifting to read the comments here. I visited Manzo a couple of years ago with a group of university teachers from around the country and we all experienced what David has described so well here. This school, and their program are jewels to be shared around the country to show how engaged students and teachers should be when you create the right kind of learning environment. I have often told teachers I know in the midwest to go visit Manzo to learn how your school can become become a project people want to be part of.I plan to send an email again to the school board members who may have not had David’s tour of Manzo yet.

    Howard Lamson
    Professor of Spanish and Hispanic Studies

  2. Nicole Ramirez

    Thank you David for this amazing article. Melissa is my fifth grade student, I’m so proud of her and all my Bobcats. When Melissa found out that Manzo was on the closure list she wrote a letter to the TUSD School board in hopes to influence their decision. The students are the heart of the school and make it worth all the efforts to save it. David as Mr. Alvarez would say, once you visit Manzo your familia, so welcome to the family.

  3. I agree that Manzo is the heart and soul of Barrio Hollywood. I recently worked at Manzo as a substitute teacher and was amazed how beautiful my childhood school looked. I was excited to see all the good and wonderful teaching and learning that was taking place there. The atmosphere was warm and so inviting that I came home bragging about our school to family and friends who had also attended Manzo. We have to fight to keep Manzo open.

  4. This school is the heart and soul of Barrio Hollywood. I live across the street and buy my eggs, brown & green, and other veggies here. Manzo has a farmers market every Wednesday afternoon and many neighbors support this.

    Regarding TUSD budget woes; I would recommend closing Menlo Park since they need a Community Center and bringing those students to Manzo, or creating a “Green” Magnet school that would bring students outside our boundary.

    It is a travesty that Tucson High School recently hired 6 new Admin since August 2012. Tucson High now has a Dean of Students, 3 new Assistant Principals and 2 new Advisors. These are positions that pay more than 2x a Teacher. Talk about taking money out of the classroom and building a bureaucracy.

  5. Francine Shacter

    When a school is thought to be not succeeding, you hear about it in infinite detail – but the school described in this article is a secret unless an enterprising soul – David Safir – goes out and sees it and writes about it. I have a great idea: Let’s each of us make it a personal matter to visit and advertise a good or a great school!!!! Celebrate success. I have a specific school in mind – get back to you later!

  6. Oops. Sorry Melissa, I crossed out my mistake and corrected your name (and remember what I told you about studying hard!)

  7. Quick correction; David’s tour guide’s name is Melissa. Glad to hear she did a nice job. Thanks so much David for coming out and the kind words! It was great to meet you and we hope to see you December 7th for our fiesta.

    For anyone interested in writing in support of Manzo, governing board member email addresses can be found here:
    http://tusd1.org/contents/govboard/govboard.html