This is what has Rep. Martha McSally hiding in the chicken bunker

This is what has Rep. Martha McSally hiding in the chicken bunker:

Rep. Jason Chaffetz (R-Utah) represents one of the reddest districts of a deep-red state. As chairman of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, he promised to continue his years-long witch hunt of Hillary Clinton if she was elected president, but now says he will not investigate President Trump‘s multiple conflicts of interests or tax returns (for possible violations of the Emoluments Clause of the Constitution). Chaffetz Won’t Investigate Trump Because He Only Cares About Investigating Democrats.

Chaffetz got a frosty reception in his home state on Feb. 9, at a town hall (video).

Angry constituents packed a high school auditorium, grilled the congressman with questions and peppered him with boos and chants while protesters amassed outside. “Do Your Job!” Hundreds of People Shout Down Jason Chaffetz Over Lack of Trump Probe:

At a town hall meeting on Thursday night held by Rep. Jason Chaffetz (R-Utah), the chair of the House Oversight Committee, the mood got rough, when hundreds of people demanded answers from Chaffetz regarding a host of controversies: his unwillingness to investigate President Donald Trump’s conflicts of interest, his support for Obamacare repeal, a proposal to sell off public lands, and more.

“You’re really not going to like this part,” Chaffetz said at one point. “The president under the law is exempt from the conflict of interests laws.”

That remark—and many of his other comments—was met with jeers, as people chanted, “Do your job!” and “We want to get rid of you!” The raucous event came amid complaints from Democrats on the committee that Chaffetz won’t investigate the Trump administration’s various global entanglements and possible ethics violations.

The angry crowd also blasted Chaffetz for a bill he introduced in January to sell off public lands and for his efforts to defund Planned Parenthood.

During a meeting with Trump in the Oval Office Tuesday, Chaffetz afterward said the president had instructed him not to raise the topic of “oversight”—to which he had replied “fair enough.” Some town hall attendees expressed anger over Chaffetz’s failure to confront the president on this point. Others threatened his current term would be his last.

The town hall meeting reportedly ended 40 minutes early, with Chaffetz refusing to take questions from the press as he departed.

As the Washington Post’s conservative blogger Jennifer Rubin says, “If Chaffetz wants to block and tackle for an administration that shows no respect for formal or informal ethical rules, the remedy is with the voters — and not just those in Utah’s 3rd Congressional District.” Jason Chaffetz is a walking advertisement for divided government.

Remember, this is a supposedly “safe” Tea-Publican from a “safe” red district. (Rep. McSally is from a “swing” district with a Democratic voter registration edge that voted for Hillary Clinton in November). The video above is not of Democratic activists hoping to “trap people in a political ambush for political theater” as Rep. McSally recently whined to the Arizona Daily Star, those are GOP constituents who voted for Chaffetz.

McSally almost certainly has angered a number of her GOP constituents as well as her Democratic constituents.

Tucson Weekly Editor Mari Herreras asks, McSally, remember when you were a lion?

I recall sitting in the Sabino High School auditorium about six years ago, listening to four Republican candidates explain why they were the best choice to fill the CD 8 seat left vacant by Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords.

The event, organized by the Sabino Teen-Age Republicans, included former state Sen. Frank Antenori, Marine veteran Jesse Kelly, Dave Sitton and retired Air Force Col. Martha McSally. The fun Republican kids asked each candidate what kind of animal would they be.

McSally, who didn’t win that race, told the crowd that she once took a personality test that compares people to animals, and she came out a lion. McSally said that’s “for people who are warriors and are leaders and want to get things done.”

According to this week’s The Skinny column by Jim Nintzel, McSally is avoiding—and has been for weeks now—a request by constituents to have an open town hall to hear what they have to say and hear what their congresswoman has to say in return:

McSally spokesman Patrick Ptak denies that there’s an effort to avoid having a town hall, but told The Skinny that McSally has been busy with work in Washington since Trump was sworn into office.

“We regularly hold town halls and are in the process of scheduling more in the weeks ahead,” Ptak said. “More announcements will come as we get those scheduled.”

Ptak pointed to a list of more than three dozen town halls McSally hosted in her first term after winning office in 2014. Of those, about 20 were at businesses, ranging from IBM and Raytheon to the American Red Cross and the Art Institute of Tucson. Another nine were at senior centers and five were tele-town halls, conducted as conference calls to a wide audience.

Another tele-town hall was scheduled for this week[.]

McSally has always described herself as a warrior, but ignoring calls to meet with constituents and have a town hall meeting isn’t, well, very warrior like, is it?

Folks from her office say it will happen, we just don’t know when or if it will be the kind of town hall people are asking for. If McSally really is on the fence, I guess I just want to remind her that she is a lion, after all, and unless she is of the cowardly variety, a town hall meeting should be easy.

David Safier at The Range blog of The Weekly makes the point that what this cowardly lion needs is courage, like her Democratic predecessors, Rep. Ron Barber and Rep. Gabrielle Giffords. Rep. Martha McSally, Former Rep. Ron Barber, and Courage:

McSally held a tele-townhall, a quiet event where people ask questions from their home phones and she answers from the safety of her office. One questioner asked why she hasn’t scheduled any recent face-to-face town halls. McSally defended herself by saying Democratic activists just want to use those events as political theater to ambush Republicans. And you know, she’s not wrong. Democrats do hope to score political points by holding her feet to the fire and making her as uncomfortable as they can. I admit, it takes courage to schedule an event knowing you’re going to be attacked verbally, to stand up in front of a group of constituents, many of them hostile to your ideas, and do your best to hold your own. But for someone who puts her 26 years in the Air Force at the top of her official biography, touting her courageous combat missions flying the A-10 Warthog in Iraq and her refusal to wear Muslim garb when she travelled off-base in Saudi Arabia, McSally is showing a distinct lack of courage under political fire.

By way of contrast, let me note an example of courage from her predecessor, Rep. Ron Barber. When Rep. Gabrielle Giffords was shot during her Congress on Your Corner event January 8, 2011, Barber was among 18 others shot at the event. Barber went on to win the congressional seat in 2012. He didn’t have to continue Gabby’s Congress on Your Corner tradition, but he chose to anyway, standing in the public square and taking questions and comments from constituents. Given his experience two years earlier, that had to be far more terrifying than facing a roomful of people at a town hall. His first of several Congress on Your Corner events was held four days after he was sworn in, a frightening echo of Gabby’s January 8 event which was held four days after she began her third term.

It’s also worth noting that Rep. Giffords stood in front of raucous, rowdy crowds during three town halls she held when the Tea Party was in full-on attack mode over the proposed Affordable Care Act. I attended one of them held in a packed high school auditorium. Republican activists were bussed in from around the Tucson area to disrupt the event. They stood and booed everyone who spoke in favor of the proposed health law, drowning out their comments. They cheered with equal fervor when someone spoke on their side, though they interrupted their cheering long enough to allow the speaker to be heard. Gabby stood her ground throughout the event.

The Arizona Daily Star’s Time Steller echoes Safier’s post today in his Political Notebook adding:

I visited a demonstration of about 125 people outside her office Tuesday morning and talked to many attendees. They are Democrats, for the most part, and they are angry, in large measure at President Trump and his actions. But their demand is sincere: What they want is to face McSally and tell her how they feel.

Then-Rep. Gabrielle Giffords faced similar demands in 2010 from tea-party members, and she held three real town-hall meetings — live ones that anyone could attend — anyway.

“Gabby faced it,” said Ron Barber, who was Giffords’ district director and successor till McSally beat him in 2014. “It was ugly — and I thought dangerous at one point. The point I’m making is that she was not afraid, even in the face of a screaming mob, to let her constituents talk to her.”

“Courage” is not defined by McSally’s  press flak or campaign materials, but by her actions. As we have pointed out at this blog for years, McSally has consistently avoided answering questions from her constituents, strictly controlled her public events before friendly audiences, and has even  controlled and limited the number of debates in which she will participate. She has spent a lot of time hiding in the chicken bunker.

19 Responses to This is what has Rep. Martha McSally hiding in the chicken bunker

  1. Has everyone seen this tool developed by 538 to help you track when your representative and senators in Congress are voting with or against Trump?

    Note that to date Martha the Lion, McCain the Maverick, and Flake have 100 % scores voting with Trump.

    Such independent thinkers. Such lions and mavericks. Such representatives of their constituencies. NOT.

    https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/congress-trump-score/

  2. John Huppenthal

    How silly. You have paid protesters, paid intruders and paid thugs waiting to disrupt her town halls.

    Why in the world would she take that bait?

    The stock market is up another 250 billion today to an time record of 24.3 trillion. Sunny days are here again for our young adults needing jobs. McSally is doing her job.

    • Wait a minute. Aren’t you the guy who while in office as AZ State Superintendent compared Margaret Sanger to a Nazi? And called folks who needed public assistance lazy pigs? Well, I just want to tell you McSally is not doing her job if she is not willing to meet and listen to her constituents. People who are protesting her unwillingness to listen to their concerns most certainly are not paid or intruders. They are ordinary Arizona patriots who want answers from their elected officials.

      • John Huppenthal

        Margaret Sanger was an white supremacist who was a leader in the Eugenics movement.

        That is the historical record. One that university/research/liberal culture would rather we forgot.

        And, I have a different vision than you for my black and brown brothers and sisters – CEO’s, Architects, Surgeons, Scientists and Engineers, not a life of dependency.

    • I happen to know many of McSally’s constituents, I am one, and I assure you that no one is being paid. That’s just another alternative fact you pulled out of your ass.

      BTW, the stock market has little to do with the economy and job creation, it is the investor class and the banksters, the 1% and their money changers, who are making money in the stock market (paper value at least). That Appalachian coal miner who has been unemployed for 20 years and is addicted to hillbilly heroine that you pretend to care about is no closer to finding a “good paying job” today than when he lost his job due to the technology revolution. The stock market means nothing to him and millions like him. Corporation stopped sharing productivity gains with their employees decades ago.

    • For Sure Not Tom

      Who’s paying these people Falcon9? Because I see hundreds of thousands of them in the streets, millions worldwide, and if you do the math, you’re talking about hundreds of millions, billions of dollars in payroll.

      Conservative fairy tales.

      Prove your statements or climb back under your racist little rock.

      • John Huppenthal

        We are about to prove that reducing tax rates hugely increases economic results, even the anticipation of it has improved results.

        All these morons are on the street because they believe that tripe that Picketty and Sanders were selling, that higher tax rates will improve job creation.

        If Trump cranks out 4 million jobs this year and next, the case will be closed and democrats are likely to be toast in the next election.

        McSally can avoid your thugs by answering the phone and providing great constituent service.

        It was absolutely documented that democrats were putting thugs inside of Trump rallies. One of those thugs was in the White House over a hundred times.

        • > It was absolutely documented that democrats were putting thugs inside of Trump rallies. One of those thugs was in the White House over a hundred times.

          I think the burden of proof falls upon the individual making such a claim to provide the evidence which supports it.

    • John, please provide proof of your claim that these are paid protesters. I do not believe you have such proof. I do recall Rep. Giffords facing down some angry crowds. No one accused them of being paid protesters. So provide your proof.

    • > The stock market is up another 250 billion today to an time record of 24.3 trillion. Sunny days are here again for our young adults needing jobs. McSally is doing her job.

      A president who is pushing policies which ensure a greater share of national income accrues as corporate profits, and less flows to the bottom half, which hasn’t seen a marked increase in real income since Ronnie ‘Union-Buster’ Reagan took office, is going to lead to people valuing ownership of corporations more highly.

      I am less optimistic that we will see any sort of tangible benefits flowing to people of more modest means.

  3. I suspect that Martha the Lion Warrior and her GOP cohorts in the House figure that this Trump resistance will pass. They are hoping that most of the protesters and activists will get worn out soon enough and this will be mostly forgotten by 2018. Martha the Lion can then go back to pretending she is a legislator and do what GOP representatives do best, absolutely nothing except vote as they are instructed by their leaders.

    • For Sure Not Tom

      I suspect you are correct. I also suspect the protest fatigue they’re hoping for is actually going to be momentum.

      President Bannon’s hoping to stay in the dark, but his finger prints are all over little Donny’s homework, and not a day goes by when we don’t have some new horror from the White House crew.

      Martha and the GOP own this.

      • Yeah, his three executive orders yesterday supposedly dealing with “crime and immigration” appear to have come straight from Bannon. But Trump has his own racist “law and order” credentials as evidenced by his self appointed role in the Central Park Five incident.

        This Trump Administration is a hot mess. I can’t see the protesters and activists going away any time soon. It isn’t 1940, these people are very different. Their ideals about freedom and justice are not going to succumb to an authoritarian form of government because a seventy year old billionaire and his jolly band of democracy hating white supremacists want to elongate their last gasp before they are gone forever.