I have been catching up on the numerous election law case briefs moving through the federal courts recently. I finally had time to review the 7th Circuit Court 5-5 split denying en banc review of Wisconsin’s voter ID law, which the U.S. Supreme Court has since stayed for this election.
I don’t recall this receiving national news media attention at the time, but it should have: conservative icon Judge Richard Posner, the author of the appellate court opinion in Crawford v. Marion County Election Board upholding Indiana’s voter ID law, has made an 180 degree turnabout and wrote a blistering dissent against Wisconsin’s voter ID law. Judge Posner asked for the en banc review vote himself, and wrote a 28 page dissent to the refusal of the 7th Circuit to take up the case en banc.
The Wisconsin Journal-Sentinel reported, Appeals court dissenters blister state’s voter I.D. law:
Just 14 hours after the U.S. Supreme Court blocked Wisconsin’s voter ID law for the Nov. 4 election, five appeals court judges Friday issued a blistering opinion calling allegations of voter impersonation fraud “a mere fig leaf for efforts to disenfranchise voters likely to vote for the political party that does not control the state government.”
“Some of the ‘evidence’ of voter-impersonation fraud is downright goofy, if not paranoid, such as the nonexistent buses that according to the ‘True the Vote’ movement transport foreigners and reservation Indians to polling places,” wrote Judge Richard A. Posner of the 7th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals.


