Conservative icon Judge Richard Posner blasts voter ID laws he once approved

I have been catching up on the numerous election law case briefs moving through the federal courts recently. I finally had time to review the 7th Circuit Court 5-5 split denying en banc review of Wisconsin’s voter ID law, which the U.S. Supreme Court has since stayed for this election.

Voting-RightsI don’t recall this receiving national news media attention at the time, but it should have:  conservative icon Judge Richard Posner, the author of the appellate court opinion in Crawford v. Marion County Election Board upholding Indiana’s voter ID law, has made an 180 degree turnabout and wrote a blistering dissent against Wisconsin’s voter ID law. Judge Posner asked for the en banc review vote himself, and wrote a 28 page dissent to the refusal of the 7th Circuit to take up the case en banc.

The Wisconsin Journal-Sentinel reported, Appeals court dissenters blister state’s voter I.D. law:

Just 14 hours after the U.S. Supreme Court blocked Wisconsin’s voter ID law for the Nov. 4 election, five appeals court judges Friday issued a blistering opinion calling allegations of voter impersonation fraud “a mere fig leaf for efforts to disenfranchise voters likely to vote for the political party that does not control the state government.”

“Some of the ‘evidence’ of voter-impersonation fraud is downright goofy, if not paranoid, such as the nonexistent buses that according to the ‘True the Vote’ movement transport foreigners and reservation Indians to polling places,” wrote Judge Richard A. Posner of the 7th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals.

Read more

Arizona same-sex marriage appeals: briefs due Thursday, October 16

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals same-sex marriage opinion this week, once finalized next week, is binding precedent for other states within the Ninth Circuit, which includes Arizona.

AzEqualIn recognition of this fact, U.S. District Court Judge John Sedwick has ordered the parties in the Arizona same-sex marriage cases before him in the U.S. District Court for Arizona to submit their briefs by next Thursday, October 16.

The order Judge Sedwick will issue is not in doubt. The only question is whether the state of Arizona will abandon its defense of state-sanctioned discrimination against same-sex couples, as other states have done, or will it continue with a fruitless appeal at taxpayer expense solely for purposes of delay.

The Arizona Republic reports, Judge: Ariz. has 1 week to respond to gay-marriage ruling:

The fate of Arizona’s marriage law could be decided in a week.

U.S. District Judge John Sedwick issued an order Thursday night stating that he believes this week’s appellate court ruling that declared Idaho and Nevada’s marriage restrictions unconstitutional applies to Arizona, as well.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said Tuesday that Idaho’s and Nevada’s laws preventing same-sex couples from marrying violated their right to equal protection under the 14th Amendment.

Sedwick, an Alaska judge who often helps pick up Arizona cases, gave the parties in two lawsuits challenging Arizona’s law until next Thursday to file briefs arguing how the 9th Circuit decision does or does not apply. Arizona is part of the San Francisco-based circuit.

Read more

Lewis Black: Voter Suppression? Not on My Watch!

Comedian Lewis Black is ACLU spokesperson against voter suppression.
Comedian Lewis Black is ACLU spokesperson against voter suppression.

Acerbic political comedian Lewis Black backs the American Civil Liberties Union’s (ACLU) fight against voter suppression. Check out the video after the jump.

From the ACLU…

At a photo shoot with ACLU’s Voting Rights Project Director Dale Ho, ACLU voting rights ambassador Lewis Black gets so f#%!in’ tired of politicians trying to deny people the right to vote. 

The ACLU is fighting against bad voter suppression laws across the country.

The rules of voting are still in flux in many states, so to make sure you know your rights when you vote, go to https://www.aclu.org/letmevote

Read more

SCOTUS lifts stay of 9th Circuit Court ruling on same-sex marriage in Idaho

Lyle Denniston at SCOTUSblog reports, No delay on Idaho same-sex marriages :

Pride-Flag-Thumbnail-Friday-3x2-256x171Without explanation, the Supreme Court late Friday afternoon rejected a request by state officials in Idaho to postpone a lower court ruling that had nullified the ban on same-sex marriage there.  The two-sentence order also lifted an earlier order by Justice Anthony M. Kennedy temporarily delaying that decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

There were no noted dissents from the Court’s new order.  Although it gave no reasons, the Court’s action was a further indication that the Justices are unwilling to be drawn into the constitutional controversy at this point, leaving it to lower courts to continue to explore it.  Idaho officials had tried to convince the Court that their case was different from the ones that the Court had bypassed on Monday.

[T]he Ninth Circuit Court is expected to act shortly to put its decision back into full effect, clearing the way for gay and lesbian couples in Idaho to seek marriage licenses.

Read more

Federal Courts grant a temporary reprieve from voter ID laws in Wisconsin and Texas

VotersThe U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday evening enjoined the state of Wisconsin from implementing its new voter ID laws after the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals had given its approval, based upon what Rick Hasen at Election Law Blog calls the Purcell principle, i.e., not changing the rules just before the election, and not because it believes Wisconsin is likely to succeed on the merits. Early vote-by-mail ballots had already been mailed to voters and votes cast without any requirement for voter ID.

Lyle Denniston at SCOTUSblog reports, Wisconsin voter ID law blocked (UPDATED) :

[T]he Supreme Court on Thursday night barred Wisconsin from enforcing a requirement that voters must produce a photo identification before voting, by absentee ballot or in person.  The Court majority’s one-paragraph order gave no reason, but the fact that this year’s election is less than a month away may have been the key factor.

Read more