Featured Stories
(Update) The ‘less-than-do-nothing’ Tea-Publican 112th Congress: Worst. Congress. Ever.
November 30, 2012
Posted by AzBlueMeanie: In this ongoing series, The 'less-than-do-nothing' Tea-Publican 112th Congress: Worst. Congress. Ever., here is the latest from Steve Benen. Making the 'Do-Nothing Congress' look great by comparison: In his second term, President Harry Truman condemned the snail's pace at which lawmakers actually got some work done, labeling it a "Do-Nothing" Congress. After … Read more
Carpe Diem: The dog ate my test scores
November 30, 2012
by
by David Safier
Students are notorious for having an excuse for missing assignments ("The dog ate my homework") and low test scores ("I left my book on the bus"). And when they're accused of cheating, there's always a logical explanation that leaves the student blameless. But shouldn't we expect more from the founder of Carpe Diem, the "blended learning" charter school in Yuma that's praised to the sky by conservative "education reform" advocates and is starting to franchise into other states?
Carpe Diem students spend a great deal of the school day in the computer lab using online curriculum instead of spending all their time in the classroom — hence the term "blended learning." The student-to-teacher ratio is about 50-to-1, twice the usual ratio. In Yuma, four teachers serve the school's 200+ students. The "proof" of the success of the blended learning model is the students' AIMS scores, which shot up from 2007 to 2009.
The problem is, the school's scores have slipped significantly since their 2009 high. Here's the graph of Carpe Diem's AIMS scores for 2010, 2011 and 2012 from the AZ Dept of Ed website:
Why the drop? It's probable the earlier scores were inflated by teacher or administrative-level cheating. From the Republic's Anne Ryman in 2011:
In spring 2010, the company that administers the AIMS test, Pearson Education, flagged Carpe Diem's sophomore AIMS reading test for having a higher-than-average number of erasure marks. Flagging means the state gets an alert. Pearson's report said a group of 27 Carpe Diem students who took the AIMS reading test had a total number of wrong-to-right erasure marks seven times as high as the state average.
High school drug raids and private prisons
November 30, 2012
by
by David Safier
Hat tip to Vince Rabago for pointing out this AlterNet article about a drug raid at Vista Grande High School in Casa Grande. The article focuses on the use of CCA, Corrections Corporation of American — a private, for-profit prison corporation — in the raid. But let me start by looking at the raid itself.
The school's principal, Tim Hamilton, requested the raid. The school was put on "lock down." No one could go in or out. Students were lined up against the walls of their classrooms while drug sniffing dogs checked for drugs on the students or in their bags.
This is a prison-style procedure where every student is treated like a suspect, a potential criminal. It wasn't in response to a bomb threat or a student who was suspected of having a weapon. The purpose of the raid was simply to find illegal drugs.
Was the raid because of an epidemic of drug use and sales at the school? Not according to the principal, who said, "We wanted to send a message to kids that we don't want that stuff on our campus." And not according to the results. Three students were arrested in the raid: one for .1 grams of marijuana, one for .5 grams of marijuana, and one, a 17-year-old female, who had 10 ounces of marijuana which was packaged for sale. That's it. Three people, one of whom was apparently dealing a drug whose illegal status is being questioned by legislators and law enforcement leaders across the country.
As someone who spent over 30 years teaching high school, I see this as incredibly destructive to the atmosphere of a school. Schools, by definition, have to create codes of discipline while they promote education, but when the disciplinary measures become this heavy-handed, the balance is tipped toward fear and repression. How long does it take for a teacher to recreate a positive learning atmosphere in class? How long does it take for students to get the raid out of their heads and focus on their studies?
Obama 2.0 makes his opening bid
November 30, 2012
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
I have frequently been a critic of President Obama's negotiation tactics over the past four years. For a Harvard trained lawyer, I was most unimpressed. Obama was far too concerned about that "post partisan" conciliator image he tried to foster during the 2008 campaign. His opening negotiating bids always tried to meet the Tea-Publicans half-way in the mistaken belief that this would encourage them to be reasonable and conciliatory and to negotiate in good faith. Instead, it only emboldened them to demand even more, conciliation was a sign of weakness to them.
Obama either did not understand or did not want to accept that Tea-Publicans are an insurrection who want to destroy the government and who have taken this country hostage. Tea-Publicans believe in win at all costs, even if it means killing the hostage, as they almost did last year with a default on the U.S. debt (they settled for wounding the hostage with a downgrade in our credit rating). "Good faith" simply does not exist.
Sean Noble and the Center to Protect Patients Rights a major funder of Grover Norquist
November 29, 2012
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
The Center for Patients Rights, a Koch Brothers funded front group run by GOP consultant Sean Noble, is back in the news again.
Just a few weeks ago, Center for Patients Rights was in the middle of the "dark money" campaign funds money laundering scandal in California. Controversial Arizona nonprofit releases name of contributors — more nonprofits – latimes.com:
In a stunning reversal, an obscure Arizona nonprofit at the center of a legal battle over secret political contributions released on Monday morning the identity of its contributors, which it had been fighting tooth and nail to keep secret.
But the disclosure did little to shed light on who was behind the $11-million donation to a California campaign fund. The Arizona group, Americans for Responsible Leadership, identified its contributors only as other nonprofits.
The money was passed from Americans for Job Security to the Center to Protect Patient Rights to Americans for Responsible Leadership, according to state authorities. From there, the money was sent to a California campaign committee fighting Gov. Jerry Brown's tax-hike plan, Proposition 30, and pushing a separate ballot measure to curb unions' political influence, Proposition 32.
California described this as illegal "money laundering." Something at which they are experienced.
MAS teachers file a response to the Unitary (deseg) Plan
November 29, 2012
by
by David Safier The Special Master in charge of putting together the new Unitary (desegregation) Plan for TUSD has requested oral and written comments on the current version of the plan before it's finalized. A group of students wrote a long, detailed document, Declaration of Intellectual Warriors. Now the former MAS teachers have added their … Read more
The ‘irrelevancy’ of Jon Kyl
November 29, 2012
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Arizona Republic(an) columnist E.J. Montini nailed it in this post about Senator Obstruction, Jon Kyl, and his bogus ACHIEVE Act. Kyl's irrelevant final act:
What good is introducing a piece of legislation that you KNOW isn’t going to pass while you’re in office?
Because it’s for show.
It makes you look conciliatory. It makes you look statesmanlike.
All the things you should have been doing all those years when you were in office and NOT about to retire.
But that’s how politics works. Not exactly a profile in courage.
Arizona’s retiring Sen. Jon Kyl and Texas’s retiring Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison introduced a meaningless piece of legislation that is an alternative to the Dream Act. Their proposal would offer kids brought illegally into the country by their parents a chance to remain here, but without a path to citizenship.
"We need to have a discussion that is sensible, that is calm," Sen. Kyl is quoted as saying. "This particular piece of immigration reform seemed a logical place to begin."
That’s true. We should have a calm, sensible conversation about the Dream Act kids.
We should have had it years ago.
A move to shut down bad charter schools
November 29, 2012
by
by David Safier The National Association of Charter School Authorizers (NACSA) wants to shut down underperforming charter schools around the country, as many as one in five charters. This isn't a new idea. The Arizona Charter School Association has been pushing for some charter school housecleaning for years. The NACSA makes it sound like lots … Read more




