Two (more) reasons Mark Stegeman is wrong for TUSD

by David Safier

As any regular BfA reader knows, I hope Mark Stegeman gets voted off the TUSD Board. My choices for the three slots, in order of preference, are: (1) Cam Juarez; (2) Kristel Foster; (3) Betts Putnam-Hidalgo; with a close fourth place going to Ralph Ellinwood. But now I have two new, troubling reasons why I think Stegeman is the wrong choice for any moderate-to-progressive voter and a bad bet for TUSD.

Reason number one: Mark is the only Democrat listed on the Candidates Page of the Pima County Republican Party. Count them: 31 Republicans listed on the page, including the likes of Al Melvin, Ally Miller, Frank Antenori, Gabby Saucedo Mercer and the rest of the right wing gang; and one Democrat, Mark Stegeman, sharing the TUSD list with John Hunnicutt and Alexandre Sugiyama.

True, Mark didn't put himself there. But he attended and spoke at Republican events, and what he said must have made them sit up and take note. Mark says this is a nonpartisan race. True enough. But if your views on education are acceptable to the wacko Pima County Republican Party, that should be troubling to any Democrat or moderate-to-progressive Independent.

Reason number two: At a DGT (Democrats of Greater Tucson) event Monday, Mark shared the stage with Cam, Kristel and Betts. Mark said lots of things I didn't like, but what really concerned me was when he gave out a conservative education dog whistle which, I think, most people missed. Because of the time I spend on education issues, I heard it loud and clear. Later he restated his position taking out the dog whistle, but that conservative-tinged statement was his first instinct.

I don't have a transcript of the forum, so this is a paraphrase. Mark said we can't use students' income or ethnicity as an excuse to say they can't achieve. [And here his voice got that determined, "I'm going for the applause line" tone] Every student can achieve if he's given a good teacher and a strong curriculum.

It's a perfectly reasonable sounding statement, but here's the dog whistle — and the reason it always gets applause in front of a conservative audience (I'll bet Mark has gotten a hand for that line at Republican events). Behind that line is the idea that being poor and/or Hispanic and/or Native American and/or African American has nothing to do with how you achieve in school. So you bleeding heart liberals should stop crying and you parents in low socioeconomic groups, stop whining already and make your kids work harder!

The Goldwater Institute has pushed the "poor kids can make it too, so it's the schools, teachers and union's fault" notion of education for years. The conservative "education reform" and "school choice" movement have used it to trash public (non charter) schools. And now Mark, the guy who thinks the sociological, psychological and possibly academic boost students got in Mexican American Studies program wasn't reason enough to save the program, is using it to.

I think Mark, who's a smart guy, realized later in the forum that he'd used the wrong phrasing for the Democratic audience, so he restated his position to say we have to get rid of the culture of low expectations that lets the schools off the hook. (I don't have the transcript in front of me, only my notes, but if Mark actually used the phrase, "culture of low expectations" that I wrote down, he's paraphrasing the Bush line about the "soft bigotry of low expectations.") He continued, we have to acknowledge the school-related problems that come with low socioeconomic status but do our best to overcome them. That's a very reasonable line, but the acknowledgement of the importance of class and ethnicity in education isn't something conservatives want to hear, which is why I think it was missing from Mark's original statement on the subject.

My sense is, Mark's first instinct on that topic is the best representation of his views. He likes to say he's still a good Democrat. Maybe so, maybe no. But when it comes to education, Mark is shifting further and further toward the Republican camp.


Discover more from Blog for Arizona

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

6 thoughts on “Two (more) reasons Mark Stegeman is wrong for TUSD”

  1. That is unfortunate. Get the DVD. For those who have been decision makers or close to them, there is no excuse not to see it.

  2. Actually, Jana, we escorted Mark to the opening of Precious Knowledge. MAS supporters had theoretically reserved seats for us. Key MAS people KNEW we were outside trying to get in because I was on the cell phone with them. We were NOT allowed into the Fox Theater the night of the premier.

  3. The problem with Stegeman’s message that every student can achieve if he’s given a good teacher and a strong curriculum, in addition to David’s recognition of the conservative dog whistle, is that Stegeman has no idea what a good K-12 teacher looks like. Building teacher-student relationships is central to a successful K-12 education and CRITICAL to struggling students. But Stegeman doesn’t understand this at all. At the hearing against TUSD’s MAS program, Huppenthal used Stegeman’s personal notes from his visit to Curtis Acosta’s class as evidence. The comments that reveal how clueless Stegeman is about what a great teacher looks like were, “He [Acosta] is mostly relating to kids, not educating them” and “He is cool, being the kids’ buddy.” This is a window into Stegeman’s mind and heart. The notes were personal and he had no idea at the time that Huppenthal would subpoena them. Mark, watch “Precious Knowledge” and listen to Curtis explain how he uses humor and the ability to make students laugh to reach some of the kids who are the toughest to turn around. Your denigration of his relationship with his students reveals your ignorance. You have no idea what a great teacher looks like and you have no business governing a K-12 school district.

  4. I heard the dog whistle, Mark. It was loud and clear.

    This is the style of argument (an economist’s version of the playground taunt, “Oh, yeah? Prove it!”) you often use to make people back down. Sorry. Doesn’t work here. This wasn’t a conclusion I made in recollection, after the fact. I recognized the phrasing as it came out of your mouth.

  5. “Behind that line is the idea that being poor and/or Hispanic and/or Native American and/or African American has nothing to do with how you achieve in school.”

    That is baloney, David. I’ve never said that and don’t believe it and there is no economist in the country who does (that I know of). If you had a convincing line of argument then you would not have to knock down straw men. Most of your argument is based on things I might have said but you can’t remember exactly or things I might have said somewhere else or things I might be thinking or things that other people might be thinking about things I might have said, etc.

    And at the risk of engaging in my own such speculation: I think you meant “too”.

Comments are closed.