Research data proves the Supreme Court is wrong

June 27, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

This reporting by Morgan Kousser at Reuters blows away the disingenuous sophistry of Chief Justice John Roberts in Shelby County v. Holder (and echoed by every pundit in the conservative media entertainment complex right-wing noise machine). Gutting the landmark civil rights legislation:

The Supreme Court’s Shelby County v. Holder decision on Tuesday essentially cast aside the key component of the nation’s most important civil rights legislation.

The five “conservative” justices castigated Congress for putting too much emphasis on history by failing to update the “coverage formula” in Section 4 of the landmark Voting Rights Act of 1965.

Section 4 specifies which states and local jurisdictions must “pre-clear” with the Justice Department or the Washington district court all changes in election laws – anything from adding voter ID regulations to redistricting. Areas now subject to this federal oversight have had a substantial history of voter discrimination.

Chief Justice John Roberts, in writing for the 5-4 majority, conceded that the Voting Rights Act is largely responsible for a decline in blatant voting racial discrimination efforts. Yet he declared the federal oversight program “unconstitutional” on the grounds that it did not reflect “current conditions.” Instead, he invited this most dysfunctional of Congresses to “draft another formula.”

But the chief justice is wrong.

Fallout from Shelby County v. Holder decision

June 27, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

If you were upset with the U.S. Supreme Court for its ruling in Citizens United v. FEC, you should be outraged at the court's decision in Shelby County v. Holder, crippling the landmark Voting Rights Act of 1965. The "Felonious Five" conservative activist Justices of the Court demonstrated in orders today just how far they intend to go in applying this decision — it is now open season for GOP voter suppression and gerrymandered redistricting.

Lyle Denniston at SCOTUSblog explains:

The Supreme Court, acting swiftly to promote further review of voting rights under federal law, told lower courts on Thursday to take a new look at two Texas cases involving a photo ID law for voters and a new set of redistricting plans for the state’s delegation in Congress and for members of the two houses of its state legislature.

In both cases, the Justices wiped out lower court rulings that had refused to give legal clearance to the photo ID law and the new election districting plans. The lower courts are now to apply the Supreme Court’s ruling on Tuesday in Shelby County v. Holder, (docket 12-96), striking down one key part of the Voting Rights Act of 1965.  Because the Supreme Court’s actions did not resolve the cases finally, the two Texas laws at issue will now remain in legal limbo, at least for a few weeks.

Supreme Court denies appeal in Brewer v. Diaz (same-sex domestic partner benefits)

June 27, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

EqualThursday’s orders by the Supreme Court came in the final round of actions it planned to take in the 2012-13 Term. Orders List (.pdf).

One day after issuing two historic rulings on same-sex marriages, the Court denied review of two cases from Arizona and Nevada that posed tests of state laws that treat gays and lesbians less favorably than straight couples.

Lyle Denniston at SCOTUSblog explains:

The Arizona case (Brewer v. Diaz, 12-23) was a plea by state officials for permission to enforce a law enacted by its legislature in 2009, taking away health benefits for same-sex state employees who were not married but were legally “domestic partners.” The law accomplished that result by defining “dependent” for purposes of the benefits as “a spouse,” meaning a legally married wife or husband.

Since a voter-approved amendment to the state constitution limits marriage to “one man and one woman,” same-sex couples are not eligible to marry in Arizona, so the redefinition of “spouse” to exclude domestic partners shut out couples who were not eligible to marry.  The Ninth Circuit Court barred enforcement of that law, and the state had appealed, arguing that its law was actually neutral, and thus should satisfy constitutional demands for legal equality.

The Ninth Circuit Court ruling stands, barring enforcement of the Arizona law.

Gov. Jan Brewer: Racial discrimination doesn’t ‘take place any longer’

June 27, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

Tea-Publicans truly live in an alternate universe reality. Governor Jan Brewer actually asserted with a straight face that racial discrimination is no longer a problem in this state.

This is the woman who used the racially divisive SB 1070 to get elected to the governor's office (SB 1070 was later struck down by the U.S. Supreme Court as unconstitutional).

This is the state where crazy Uncle Joe Arpaio was just recently found by the federal court to have engaged in a policy of unlawful racial profiling (he is appealing).

This is the state where nativist anti-immigrant politicians like J.D. Hayworth, Russell Pearce, and Andrew Thomas are celebrated as heroes by conservatives in the GOP.

This is the state where Tom "banned for life by the SEC" Horne and John Huppenthal, and editor and columnist Doug MacEachern at The Arizona Republic, have engaged in unhinged demonization (criminalization) of Latino students in Tucson for ethnic studies programs at TUSD.

Jan Brewer is delusional.

RAW Story reports, Arizona governor: Racial discrimination doesn't 'take place any longer':

Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer (R) on Tuesday said the Voting Rights Act had “hampered” the state and was pleased to see a key provision of the civil rights law struck down.

* * *

When asked why Arizona shouldn’t be required to have its voting laws precleared, Brewer said racial discrimination was no longer a problem in the state.

Republican State Sen. Rich Crandall taking job in Wyoming

June 26, 2013

By Craig McDermott, cross-posted from Random Musings

 

From KPHO.com (Phoenix Channel 5), written by Phil Benson –

An Arizona state senator has been chosen to run the Wyoming Education Department. 

Wyoming Gov. Matt Mead late Wednesday afternoon announced his choice of Richard Crandall, of Mesa, who co-owns two nutritional service companies.

 This isn't exactly breaking news – it's been common knowledge for months that Crandall was leaving to "pursue other opportunities".

In my previous post covering this topic, I predicted that Crandall would catch on with a (potential) Jeb Bush presidential campaign.  This would seem to show that prediction to be incorrect, however, the job in Wyoming may be a temp job.

From the KPHO article –

Mead and the Legislature enacted a new law this past winter removing the statewide elected superintendent of public instruction as head of the Education Department. Instead, the department will be administered by a director appointed by the governor.

The change occurred in the middle of Superintendent Cindy Hill's four-year term. Hill is challenging the constitutionality of the change.

The press release from Wyoming's governor is here.

So far as I can tell, Crandall has yet to submit his resignation from the state senate.  Once he does, however, the fun will start.

Supreme Court Majority: Tilting the Playing Field To Their Own Side

June 26, 2013

Posted by Bob Lord

E.J. Dionne's piece at Truthdig today, The Third Political Branch, captures the reality of this week's Supreme Court rulings and the true agenda of the Supreme Court's majority. Yes, the decisions in today's cases striking down DOMA and California's Proposition 8 were victories. They were victories over all the neanderthals who seek to deny fundamental rights to gay and lesbian couples. But make no mistake, they were not victories over the Court majority's political and economic agenda. Dionne explains:

Liberals will still win occasional and sometimes partial victories, as they did Wednesday on same-sex marriage. But on issues directly related to political and economic influence, the court’s conservative majority is operating as a political faction, determined to shape a future in which progressives will find themselves at a disadvantage.

Can you think of a Supreme Court decision during Roberts' term in which the majority has acted in the interests of economic justice? Has opposed corporate power? Remember, corporate America doesn't have a dog in the fight over same sex marriage. 

Dionne:

Texas: The People’s Filibuster derails The Great Texas Screwjob…for now, anyway…

June 26, 2013

By Craig McDermott, cross-posted from Random Musings

 

By now, most people who care about this sort of thing are aware that in Texas, State Sen. Wendy Davis filibustered their SB5 yesterday.  SB5 would have all but completely banned abortion services in Texas.

The Republicans in the Texas lege tried and failed to pass the provisions of the bill during the regular session of the legislature.  Upset by that failure, they called a special session to railroad through all of the provisions in one measure.

However, under the rules governing specials sessions in Texas, they have a limited amount of time to pass bills and once that time is gone, any unpassed bills die.

Davis was attempting to hold the floor until the time for the special session expired.

The Republicans in the Texas state senate pulled out all the stops in their attempts to break the filibuster.  They used hyper-technical interpretations of the rules of the Senate, openly ignoring those rules, and just plain cheating.

They forced her off of the floor but the other Democrats in her caucus took up the fight, mostly using points of parliamentary inquiry to run out the clock.  Call it "legislative stall ball".

And when it looked like that the Rs we just going to ride roughshod over democracy and women in TX, hundreds of citizens in the Senate gallery just started cheering.

Loudly enough to drown out the Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst, the conductor of the railroad chair of the Texas State Senate.

And long enough to finish running out the clock on the special session.

From the Dallas Morning News, written by Christy Hoppe and Claire Z. Cardona –

Justice Scalia tells a funny (I’m not laughing)

June 26, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

In reading this morning's opinions, I could not believe my eyes when i read this line from Justice Antonin Scalia's dissent (.pdf) in U.S. v. Windsor:

"This case is about power in several respects. It is about the power of our people to govern themselves, and the power of this Court to pronounce the law. Today's opinion aggrandizes the latter, with the predictable consequence of diminishing the former. We have no power to decide this case. And even if we did, we have no power under the Constitution to invalidate this democratically adopted legislation. The Court’s errors on both points spring forth from the same diseased root: an exalted conception of the role of this institution in America.”"

Scaliagesture03302006Seriously? 24 hours earlier, Scalia did not hesitate to gut the singular most important piece of civil rights legislation in U.S. history, the capstone of the Civil Rights Movement, the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Scalia did not hesitate to stab "a dagger in the heart" of this "democratically adopted legislation," approved by the elected representatives of Americans who are able to "govern themselves."

Following 21 days of testimony at hearings and thousands of pages of documentary evidence, Congress passed the 2006 Reauthorization by a vote of 98-0 in the Senate, and 390-33 in the House.  It did so based on statutory findings that “without the continuation of [the Act’s] protections, racial and language minority citizens will be deprived of the opportunity to exercise their right to vote, or will have their votes diluted, undermining the significant gains made by minorities in the last 40 years.” Among other findings, Congress relied on the existence of so-called “second generation” discriminatory practices in covered jurisdictions, including at-large elections and racial gerrymandering, which have the effect of diluting minority voting power. (h/t Brennan Center for Justice).

Voted Arizona’s Best Political Blog
by the Washington Post and Google’s FeedSpot

Arizona Insight Podcast

latest Event from thedgt.ORG

Upcoming community Events

Bluesky