Featured Stories
Fun with Brewer’s Performance Funding model
February 23, 2013
by
by David Safier
Jan Brewer has given us a new toy, a K-12 Performance Funding Calculator. Plug in a school's current state grade score, then plug in what you think the score will be the next year, and out comes the school's Performance Funding for the next year.
It's important to know as I run through a few examples, the bill, SB1444, has the Performance Funding ramping up over 5 years, so the first year schools will only get 20% of what should come from the model. That's why all the numbers are lower than I indicated in the series of posts I wrote about Performance Funding. The following year schools will get 40%, then 60% and so on.
So, let's look at Catalina Foothills High, a school with affluent students (6% are on free/reduced lunch) that earned an A grade with a score of 157 (140 or higher is an A). If the school shows no improvement, it will get $44.64 extra per student. Once the full funding model kicks in after 5 years, that number will be $223.20 extra per student.
Now let's look at TUSD's Pueblo High, a school where 89% of the students are Hispanic and 79% are on free/reduced lunch. It got a D grade with a score of 99, one point below a C. If it shows no improvement, it will actually lose $17.26 per student (that would be an $86.30 loss under full funding), because a D school gets no performance funding, and $17.26 is taken from every school's budget and put into the Performance Funding pot.
(Update) States consider liability insurance for guns
February 23, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
In this continuing series, the New York Times reports Buying a Gun? States Consider Insurance Rule:
Both sides in a nation sharply divided over guns seem to agree on at least one thing: a bigger role for the insurance industry in a heavily armed society. But just what that role should be, and whether insurers will choose to accept it, are much in dispute.
Lawmakers in at least half a dozen states, including California, Connecticut, Maryland, Massachusetts, New York and Pennsylvania, have proposed legislation this year that would require gun owners to buy liability insurance — much as car owners are required to buy auto insurance. Doing so would give a financial incentive for safe behavior, they hope, as people with less dangerous weapons or safety locks could qualify for lower rates.
“I believe that if we get the private sector and insurance companies involved in gun safety, we can help prevent a number of gun tragedies every year,” said David P. Linsky, a Democratic state representative in Massachusetts who wants to require gun owners to buy insurance. He believes it will encourage more responsible behavior and therefore reduce accidental shootings. “Insurance companies are very good at evaluating risk factors and setting their premiums appropriately,” he added.
No U Turn?
February 22, 2013
by
by David Safier
I pulled out of the Park Place Mall earlier today, turned right onto Broadway, went to the next left turn lane and made a U Turn. Half a block later, a policeman pulled me over for making an illegal turn. He told me that turn lane is only for turning into the Best Buy parking lot. There are two "No U Turn" signs posted that I didn't see.
Officer Lyons was a polite young man. When he returned with my ticket, I said, equally politely, "I'm not contesting the ticket, but I have a question. In what way is a U turn more dangerous in that spot than a left turn into the parking lot? They both involve crossing oncoming traffic."
He said he didn't know that one was more dangerous than the other. But he said there's a similar No U Turn posting heading west on a left turn lane that takes you into the Park Place parking lot. In fact, he said, he had ticketed someone there earlier today. I commented that it may have more to do with getting customers into the store parking lots than with traffic safety. He smiled and shrugged.
Citizens United 2.0 – U.S. Supreme Court to lift aggregate limits to campaign contributions?
February 22, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
On Tuesday, the U.S. Supreme Court granted certiorari in McCutcheon v. Federal Election Commission (docket 12-536), a case in which the U.S. Supreme Court could open the door to even more money in politics than it did in its disastrous 2010 decision, Citizens United v FEC. If the court sides with the challengers in McCutcheon v FEC, political power and influence in America will further be concentrated in the hands of wealthy elite plutocrats.
Lyle Denniston at Scotusblog.com provides a brief summary, Campaign donation issue reopened:
Giving itself the option of changing its mind on government power to limit campaign contributions, the Supreme Court on Tuesday set the stage for review of the constitutionality of a specific donation ceiling set by federal law, but a larger issue looms in the background. Since the Court’s landmark opinion in 1976 in Buckley v. Valeo, it has always given government more leeway to control contributions to candidates or political organizations than over spending by candidates or by independent political activists. That differing constitutional treatment potentially is at stake in the new case, McCutcheon v. Federal Election Commission (docket 12-536).
The biggest threat to the Voting Rights Act is the U.S. Supreme Court
February 22, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
On Wednesday, February 27, The U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Shelby County v. Holder, a constitutional challenge to Section 5 preclearance under the Voting Rights Act of 1965 (as amended). Andrew Cohen at The Atlantic has a beautifully written history of the Voting Rights Act and the case before the U.S. Supreme Court. After 50 Years, the Voting Rights Act's Biggest Threat: The Supreme Court (excerpts):
At 10 a.m. next Wednesday, the justices of the United States Supreme Court will hear oral argument in a case styled Shelby County v. Holder, one of the most anticipated of the current Term. Agreeing to review an argument made by an Alabama county that it ought finally to be free from one of the key requirements of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, the justices will have an opportunity both to lead and to follow the nation as it roils anew in political and legal battle over the rights of the poor, the ill, the young, the car-less, the black, the Hispanic, and the Native American to vote.
Nearing its 50th birthday, the act has become a part of our national lore. One of the crowning achievements of the civil rights movement (and of the Johnson Administration), it was designed by its creators to finally give meaningful legal remedies to minority citizens — blacks, mostly, but not exclusively — who for generations had been precluded from voting (or from having their votes fairly counted) by a dizzying flurry of discriminatory state practices. The act didn't just expand the scope of existing federal civil rights laws. It completely changed the dynamic between voters and state and local governments. And the results are indisputable: There is far less discrimination in voting today than there was half a century ago — and many millions more minority voters.
Annual St. Patrick’s Day Fundraiser
February 22, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie: Announcement from LD 9 and LD 10:
The GOP war on the unemployed in the Arizona Lege
February 22, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Unemployment benefits are provided by state unemployment insurance programs within guidelines established by Federal law. Eligibility for unemployment insurance, benefit amounts and the length of time benefits are available are determined by state law (approved under federal guidelines).
Arizona's unemployment law is based on the public policy that involuntary employment "is a serious menace to health, morals and welfare of the people of this state." A.R.S. §23-601. The law has always contained a public policy preference that workers are entitled to receive unemployment insurance compensation unless otherwise disqualified.
Disqualification from benefits typically involves (a) a voluntary resignation (there are exceptions for justifiable resignations for compelling personal reaons), and (b) discharge for misconduct in connection with the work (this is a legal term of art defined by regulations and case law).
Under Arizona law, the burden of proof has always been on the employer to establish disqualification from unemployment insurance benefits. The public policy reason for this is that the employer enjoys control over employment records (proprietary information). Employees are not entitled to records in their employee file (several bills to give employees a right to documents in their employee file have failed in the Arizona legislature).
Gun violence discussed at Foothills Democratic Forum
February 22, 2013
by
by David Safier
Thursday evening, the Foothills Democratic Forum held its second session discussing gun violence. The speakers were Pam Simon, former Community Outreach Coordinator for Gabby Giffords who was injured in the January 8 shooting, City Council member Steve Kozachik and State Representative Victoria Steele.
Since Simon was shot, she has retired and is now working full time as an advocate for sensible gun legislation. She spoke briefly about the shooting but mostly talked about her experiences meeting with elected officials from the White House to the local level as well as other people who were shooting victims or family members of people who were shot. She spoke about the committed network of people and organizations pushing for education and legislation to curb gun violence. Her passionate activism has a kind, caring tone to it, echoing her years as a teacher.
Steve Kozachik brought a harder edge to his talk than Simon, as we have come to expect from Steve, but his genuine passion for the issue was clear. He began by holding up one of the gun locks his office is giving out free of charge. Here in Tucson, we usually think of the modest gun buyback event he created as a local issue, but Kozachik said it's gotten national and international coverage, including a Japanese news team that followed him around to get a story. Google "Tucson + gun + buyback," and you get 153,000 results. Tucson as a progressive city in right wing Arizona and the site of one of the prominent recent shootings has a more important place in the gun violence controversy than we locals sometimes realize.
Victoria Steele, a first-time state rep, spoke of her attempts to get a hearing for her bills relating to gun violence. Her attempt to create a Home Rule bill that would allow cities and counties to pass their own gun laws went nowhere, of course. But another bill, HB2570, is still alive, though just barely. It would allocate more funding for Mental Health First Aid training. This is a non-controversial proposal to hold trainings for people across the state that would help them recognize mental health problems and educate them about ways they, as non-professionals, can offer help. The bill is short enough, I can quote it in full:




