Arizona’s lawless legislature smacked down by the Arizona Supreme Court
September 13, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Last November, Arizona voters overwhelmingly rejected Proposition 115, a citizens initiative by the Center for Arizona Policy (CAP) that would have given the governor more say in appointing judges to the state’s appeals courts and the superior courts in its three largest counties. The CAP assault on the independence of the judiciary.
Not to be deterred, our "Sun King" Tea-Publican legislature enacted HB 2600 earlier this year to get what they and the CAP demanded, despite the will of the voters. "Screw the voters! I am the law!"
The Arizona Constitution cannot be amended by a simple legislative act, it must be amended by approval of the voters. So four members of the commission that nominates judicial candidates for the state’s appellate courts filed a special action in the Arizona Supreme Court, asking the high court to throw out the law on the grounds that it is unconstitutional. Effort targets judicial picks.
Today, the Arizona Supreme Court struck down HB 2600 as unconstitutional. The larger issue which remains is our lawless legislature's creeping encroachment on the independent judiciary on behalf of the CAP.
The full opinion is Here, Dobson et al. v. State of Arizona ex rel Appeals Court Appointments, CV-13-0225-SA.
Highlights from the opinion below the fold:
Sandra Day O’Connor: ‘Our society suffers from an alarming degree of public ignorance’
September 13, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Just in time for Constitution Day next week, retired U.S. Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O'Connor is alarmed by the shocking degree of civic ignorance among Americans. (Note to Sandra: You were the deciding vote in Bush v. Gore; see Article II, Section 1, just sayin'. "Regretting" your vote in hindsight does not absolve you of your sin. After Casting Key Fifth Vote For Bush, Justice O'Connor Now Regrets Bush v. Gore.)
In a speech in Boise, Idaho last week, Retired Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, in Boise, laments 'alarming degree of public ignorance':
Two-thirds of Americans cannot name a single Supreme Court justice, former Justice Sandra Day O'Connor told the crowd that packed into a Boise State ballroom to hear her Thursday.
About one-third can name the three branches of government. Fewer than one-fifth of high school seniors can explain how citizen participation benefits democracy.
"Less than one-third of eighth-graders can identify the historical purpose of the Declaration of Independence, and it's right there in the name," she said.
Health insurance story from healthcare.gov
September 13, 2013
by
by David Safier I hope and expect to see more stories like this one on the healthcare.gov website in the coming weeks and months. Malik is 23, which means he may be able to stay on his parents' plan until he's 26, and if not, he can choose from a number of health care … Read more
Mexico Independence Day Celebration
September 13, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie: Announcement from the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce:
This doesn’t qualify as good news
September 13, 2013
by
by David Safier Arizona is no longer Number One in the percent we've cut our spending per student since 2008. We're Number Three. Oklahoma and Alabama are now occupy the top two spots on the Education Spending Wall of Shame. Last year, we topped the list with a 21.8% in per student cuts since 2008. … Read more
Two blockbuster reports on the ‘Kochtopus’ dark money financing
September 12, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
When last we heard about the Arizona-based "Kochtopus" dark money group Center to Protect Patient Rights, founded by GOP operative Sean Noble, Peter H. Stone at The Daily Beast reported an Exclusive: California Grand Jury Probing Shadowy Money Groups:
A grand jury is now involved in a high-stakes California probe that is looking into whether a PAC and three so-called dark-money groups—including one with ties to the billionaire brothers Charles and David Koch—broke a campaign disclosure law by funneling $11 million from secret sources to influence ballot initiatives in the state’s 2012 election, The Daily Beast has learned.
* * *
One of the three groups that allegedly channeled the funds to California was the Arizona-based Center to Protect Patient Rights, founded in 2009 by Koch operative Sean Noble, who has emerged in recent cycles as a big player in conservative political and fundraising circles. Noble has spoken at least twice at the billionaire brothers’ biannual conferences aimed at tapping other wealthy conservatives for their favorite projects, and he has been a key strategist at small Washington meetings with other GOP allied groups such as the Karl Rove-founded American Crossroads.
“Sean is the wizard behind the screen” for the Kochs and their network of wealthy donors, said one GOP operative familiar with Noble’s political work.
(Update) The Initiative to Bankrupt the City of Tucson (Prop. 201) has been struck by the Court of Appeals
September 12, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Baseball sage Yogi Berra was right! "It ain't over 'til it's over."
The Plaintiffs challenging the petitions of the Initiative to Bankrupt the City of Tucson (Prop. 201) filed an appeal from Pima County Superior Court Judge James Marner's order on September 3, 2013. (2 CA-CV 2013-0120).
On September 12, the Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the plaintiffs/appellants, rejected the cross-appeal by counsel for the initiative committee, and remanded the case back to Pima County Superior Court Judge James Marner with instructions to grant the injunctive relief requested by plaintiffs to prevent Prop. 201 from being printed on ballots:
Having considered the briefs filed by the parties and the oral arguments before this court in this expedited election appeal, see Ariz. R. Civ. App. P. 8.1, this court has determined that the trial court erred in rejecting the plaintiffs/appellants/cross-appellees’ challenge as to the validity of certain signatures obtained by circulators of City of Tucson Initiative Petition 2013-1004. We further conclude the cross-appeal raises no issues warranting relief. Accordingly, it is ORDERED: The judgment of the trial court is reversed and the case is remanded to the trial court which is directed by 2:00 p.m., September 12, 2013, to enter judgment in favor of plaintiffs/appellants/cross-appellees and to enter an injunction pursuant to A.R.S. § 19-122(C). A written opinion will follow.
That mandate for injunction does not yet appear on the Pima County Superior Court docket for this case.
Has Brewer officially joined the sane (or saner) wing of the Republican Party?
September 12, 2013
by
by David Safier As BlueMeanie noted, the [Fools]Goldwater Institute is launching a suit against Brewer's Medicaid (AHCCCS) restoration plan, mainly because Team Antenori failed to gather enough signatures for its referendum drive to block the legislation. Antenori, meanwhile, is crowing about his victory, saying he's got the signatures of 80,000 people who will work to … Read more




