Conflating Inequality and Unemployment
Posted by Bob Lord
I told my friend Thucky I'd address his arguments about tax rates and "welfare," their impact on the employment rate, and their connection to inequality in America. As you'll see, there are a lot of topics that feed in to this discussion, so sorry about the length.
Thucky's central point is that unemployment in America has been driven by high tax rates and welfare policies that are "too comfortable." Address this problem and he believes inequality will take care of itself. Thucky relies on studies by Edward Prescott and others to support his belief that higher tax rates and comfortable welfare policies increase unemployment. Although I think Thucky allows himself to be too easily seduced by the credentials of those who write the papers upon which he relies, his reading of the studies is basically sound. Hopefully, he thought a bit more critically when reading the Reinhart and Rogoff study and their conclusion.
I actually don't differ with Thucky regarding the relationship of tax rates, welfare and employment. It's when Thucky uses that relationship to explain away inequality in America that I think his logic breaks down.