We have already achieved the border security metrics of the 2007 bill
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Suzy Khimm at Ezra Klein's Wonkblog has a response to the hysterical anti-immigrant nativists like Governor Jan Brewer: Want tighter border security? You’re already getting it.
Legislators have failed to pass a sweeping immigration overhaul for more
than five years. But there’s one piece of the 2007 immigration reform
bill that they’ve managed to accomplish: pouring hundreds of millions of
dollars into border security.
Under the Senate’s new blueprint
for reform, the legalization of undocumented immigrants would only
happen if the government “finally commit[s] the resources needed to
secure the border,” as well as strict visa enforcement for legal
immigrants. It’s a provision that’s similar to Bush’s 2007 immigration
bill, which also made legalization contingent on beefed-up border
security.
The Senate’s language suggests that the government has held back from
devoting money, equipment and personnel to border security. In fact,
even though the 2007 immigration bill ultimately failed, we’ve
nevertheless hit nearly all of the targets that it established for
increased border security—except for achieving absolute “operational
control” of the border and mandatory detention of all border-crossers
who’ve been apprehended.