GOP planning to campaign again on immigrant issue

4
126

Link: GOP pressing immigrant issue.

I didn’t realize that Republican strategists were actually pushing Congressional recommit votes on immigration-related language to paint Democrats as pro-immigrant. I have to say, I’m utterly delighted that they are hanging that anchor around their own necks.

I think most Americans, and especially independents, recoil at policies and political stands they see as cruel, petty, or mean. And there is little in American politics today that is meaner and slimier than the hatred wrapped in patriotism that is the hard-right GOP message on immigration. I get a little frisson of delight when I imagine the ads they are brewing up using these votes.

"Gabby Giffords didn’t vote to cut off the health care coverage of immigrant children. She didn’t vote to kick immigrant children out of public housing. She wouldn’t vote to punish public schools that enroll the children of undocumented immigrants. Gabby Giffords: she just won’t screw those immigrant children."

Yeah. That’ll work on the vast majority of Americans who aren’t eaten up with xenophobic mania.

Deadgopthumbnail
The GOP apparently didn’t learn their lesson in 2006 when their ($) candidates who made immigrant-baiting a major theme of their campaigns got their clocks cleaned across the board. If they need some more tutoring, I think we Democrats should be happy to give it to them.

We need to establish a Democratic system of values regarding the immigration debate, however. The only reason why Republicans are driving this issue is because they at least have a consistent narrative – hateful and divisive though it may be. We Democrats need  to talk about eliminating the need for illegal border crossings, saving lives and reducing the crime along the border, treating both American and Mexican laborers fairly in both countries, and the great American tradition of welcoming and assimilating new citizens.

Democrats sound soulless and stupid when we ape Republican themes of cracking down on employers, and militarizing the border, and treating immigrants as criminals and undesirables; when our Democratic politicians ‘me too’ the block-headed policy initiatives of Republicans – like building a damn wall – it simply makes the insane seem sensible.

Gopfascism
I don’t want our party to create a compromise with the sheer insanity that passes for policy among Republicans. I would prefer the status quo ante to compromises that would make life even worse for the immigrants already here, endanger the lives of those that will surely come, and entrench harmful policies in our immigration law for another generation. This is a fight that we can win if we stop accepting the Republican terms for this debate: hatred, fear, xenophobia, and prejudice.

So the GOP wants to square off and make immigration a central issue? I say bring it on, because they have nothing useful to say on the subject. The only we won’t win is if we accept that their vision of immigration of in America is in any way legitimate or useful. We have to name the prejudice and hate fueling the GOP’s obsession with the immigration issue, or they get to continue to appeal to voters anxieties and prejudices without paying the electoral price. I am sickened when I hear Democrats talking about immigration in the same fearful and divisive way that Republicans do, simply because Democratic leaders aren’t offering an alternative vocabulary of ideas.

We got lucky in 2006 that the American people are naturally resistant to demagogues, and largely resisted the GOP siren songs without much help from Democrats; we would be foolish to continue to rely on Americans’ continued self-discipline if we aren’t even offering a counter-narrative they can stop their ears with.

Previous articleMamon Comes A-Callin’
Next articleWhat Terrorists Want
Avatar
Michael founded BlogForArizona as the Howard Dean campaign blog for Arizona in 2003, and has been blogging ever since. Michael is an attorney living in Tucson with his wife Lauren Murata. In 2008, following some health issues and new time constraints, Michael stepped back from regular blogging and began remaking BlogForArizona into a collaborative project. Michael now contributes occasionally to the blog and provides editorial and publishing direction. Also if you want to keep up with the latest Arizona and National political news that Mike finds important, check out the BlogForArizona twitter feed, which he curates.

4 COMMENTS

  1. If some of you missed the Comprehensive Immigration Debate of 2007 ; The American People rose up and said NO to Open Borders: No to non Enforcement of Employer’s hiring Illegal’s and NO to Amnesty!

    This is a new ball game folks you better forget about the 2006 election which you turned into a pro-illegal immigration debate but was really about Congressional Corruption and throwing the bastards out!

    Free Trade is another piece of the puzzle of all of this pro-illegal open borders crap; and those of you who support NAFTA and CAFTA and Illegal Border Jumping are going be be in for a big surprize!

    To many American Citizens have lost there homes and there jobs because of all of this media hype of if you don’t support everyone coming to the United States Illegally from Mexico you are a racist and FREE TRADE NAFTA and CAFTA is good for you stupid American’s LIKE IT OR NOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  2. Having said that: I WARN the Pima County Government that TAXPAYERS MONEY belongs to the TAXPAYER NOT TO THE PIMA COUNTY GOVERNMENT and people who live on the TAX DOLE should beware of throwing stones at the taxpayers!

    There will come a day when every agency funded by Pima County Taxpayers will have to conform to the will of the Taxpayer including the Taxpayer funded Pima County Public Defenders Office that has been saying some pretty unpatriotic things about Legal U.S. Citizens and advocating for Illegal Mexican Nationals Rights over that of the American Citizen!

    There WILL BE a TAX REVOLT and we TAXPAYERS are taking names!

  3. Look- there is nothing racist about the taxpayers of Arizona objecting to pay the bill for illegal border jumpers-stop calling them immigrants!

    If the Mexican Government wants to pay for educating its masses in the State of Arizona and providing healthcare then I might take a second look at the invasion; but until then the taxpayer revolt against higher and higher property taxes forcing homeowners out of there homes will NOT be as simple as a Gabby is for Illegals and The Republicans are against them!

    Iam a Democratic Candidate for Congress who will remain an advocate for the Taxpayer having to foot the bills of Illegal’s who continue to break our laws!

    If Pima County or Tucson wants to become a santuary City and risk loosing Federal Funding across the Board COUNT ME OUT!

  4. I hope the majority of Americans wise up to the unsubtle racist overtones in this so-called immigration debate; at one point it may have been a real debate, a reasoned exchange of ideas and discussion of possible solutions, but when animals at the Desert Museum are getting death threats because a Mexican flag flies at the entrance, I think reason has flown out the window.

Comments are closed.