Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Tea Party darlin', former Senator Jim DeMint (R-SC), now pulling down big bucks for his conservative demagoguery at the Heritage Foundation, has an op-ed in the Washington Post (where else) this afternoon, What amnesty for illegal immigrants will cost America (note the code language to the nativist base) claiming that:
An exhaustive study by the Heritage Foundation
has found that after amnesty, current unlawful immigrants would receive
$9.4 trillion in government benefits and services and pay more than $3
trillion in taxes over their lifetimes. That leaves a net fiscal deficit
(benefits minus taxes) of $6.3 trillion. That deficit would have to be financed by increasing the government debt or raising taxes on U.S. citizens.
* * *
Given the U.S. debt of $17 trillion, the fiscal effects detailed in our
study should be at the forefront of legislators’ minds as they consider
Ummm, sorry, but no. By now any rational intelligent human being should know that one does not give any credence to anything produced by the Heritage Foundation. Ever. Especially now that a demagogue like Jim DeMint is at its helm.
Greg Sargent writes in The right’s last stand against immigration reform?:
The Heritage Foundation has just released its long awaited report
supposedly documenting that the path to citizenship in the Gang of
Eight immigration reform compromise will sock the taxpayer with a
multi-trillion-dollar bill. You cannot overstate how much opponents of
reform have staked on the hope that this report will be the magic bullet
to kill the proposal. This is the report that’s supposed to send House
conservatives running away, never to return.
My Post colleague Jennifer Rubin has a long post detailing the substantive pre-buttals of the Heritage study that are coming from other Republicans and conservatives who favor reform and argue Heritage’s methodology is flawed:
The Cato Institute has already come up with a detailed pre-rebuttal of Heritage’s work. And, ironically, even the Congressional Budget Office
can figure out that with dynamic scoring of the type pioneered by
Heritage (when it was an intellectual trailblazer for conservatives),
the country and the Treasury come out ahead.
In a sense, though, the substance here is beside the point. What’s
remarkable about this whole spectacle is that no one is even bothering
to pretend that the Heritage study isn’t simply a last ditch
effort to kill the bill. That’s widely, publicly, explicitly
acknowledged to be the case. Indeed, a Heritage study back during the
last immigration reform battle is widely credited
with giving the right the ammo they needed to scuttle that proposal,
and opponents are openly discussing today’s study as providing the
chance of a rerun of that glorious moment.
In this case, though, the response from Republicans to the study has
been swift and aggressive. Reporters were sent a whole list of
Republican Congressional aides and conservative think tank types who are
prepared to push back on the study — a measure of just how much the GOP
establishment wants reform to pass this time.
Ultimately, the prospects for immigration reform have always turned
on whether enough Republicans are willing to swallow hard, cross the
citizenship Rubicon, and accept the consequences for the right. This
report doesn’t change that basic dynamic. It will give an army of talk
show hosts and bloggers opposed to reform plenty of ammunition to kick
up a whole lot of noise against the proposal, to be sure.
But it’s just as true today as it was last week that reform is only
going to happen if enough Republicans ignore all that noise and decide
that short term pain from the base is well worth dealing with in order
to give the party a chance to at least begin repairing relations with
Latinos, at a time when demographic realities are looking extremely
daunting over the long term. And make no mistake — it’s only the far
right who opposes a path to citizenship; polls show solid majorities
overall, and even substantial numbers of Republicans.
If far right Republicans in the House kill reform, that would be the worst possible political outcome for the GOP.
Jim DeMint, the Heritage Foundation and their teabagger allies want the GOP to commit political suicide. Have it your way. You guys are on the highway to political irrelevance.
Dylan Matthews at Ezra Klein's Wonkblog explains, Heritage says immigration reform will cost $5.3 trillion. Here’s why that’s wrong.
UPDATE: Bwahahaha! Even Grover Norquist says Jim DeMint and the Heritage Foundation are full-o'-crap. Americans For Tax Reform: Heritage Immigration Study ‘Flawed’.