Why most opinion polls are crap: abstractions v. specifics

March 18, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

As someone trained in political science who has spent my entire adult life reading opinion polls and studies about polls, this report comes as no surprise to me. What I find hard to believe is how the media villagers waste so much time talking about their polls but never discuss the reason why their polls are crap: they test abstractions, not specifics.

Could it be because discussing this would undermine the Beltway media villager "conventional wisdom" that this is a center-right country? Abstractions produce the desired result for their "conventional wisdom." But specifics (reality) undermines their so-called "conventional wisdom."

Practice tip: one can always produce the desired result by how one frames the questions and limits options. This is how the media and their pollsters manipulate public opinion.

WaPo Editorial: Arizona voter ID law should be overturned

March 18, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

The Washington Post has an editorial opinion this morning on Arizona's Prop. 200 voter registration case before the U.S. Supreme Court this morning. Arizona voter ID law should be overturned:

COMPARED WITH WHAT some Americans have to tolerate on Election Day, registering to vote is relatively painless. That’s partly thanks to the National Voter Registration Act, a 1993 law at the root of a case the Supreme Court will hear on Monday. The state of Arizona argues that it should be allowed to subvert the law’s obvious purpose. The court shouldn’t let it.

In 1993, Congress looked at the “complicated maze” of often confusing and sometimes discriminatory state election rules, and it found that “unfair registration laws and procedures can have a direct and damaging effect on voter participation in elections for federal office.” So lawmakers established national standards. Americans could register to vote when getting driver’s licenses, which gave the act its unofficial name: the “motor voter” law. Congress also required every state to accept a simple, common, mail-in registration form drafted by the U.S. Election Assistance Commission. The record indicates that Congress meant these to be among the “procedures that will increase the number of eligible citizens who register to vote in elections for federal office.”

Supreme Court argument recap in Arizona v. The Inter Tribal Council of Arizona

March 18, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

Lyle Denniston has a recap of oral argument before the U.S. Supreme Court this morning of Arizona's Prop. 200 voter registration case. Argument recap: Does “may only” mean “shall only”?

Anyone entering the Supreme Court’s chamber Monday morning expecting constitutional drama over the right to vote had to come away quite disappointed.  It took all of fifty minutes of a one-hour argument to get to any constitutional issue, most of the Justices wanted to focus on what “may only” means in a federal law, and one Justice pronounced the current federal-state voter registration regime “a crazy system.”  In an era when very heated debates over curbing voters’ rights regularly occur in political circles, there was none of that as the Court heard Arizona v. The Inter Tribal Council of Arizona (12-71).

At the center of the case is an Arizona law, approved by the state’s voters nine years ago, that requires a would-be voter seeking to register to show proof of U.S. citizenship as an additional requirement besides submitting a federal form which includes a question — enforced by possible perjury prosecution — asking whether or not one is a citizen.

Rick Hasen on Arizona’s Prop. 200 voter registration case before the U.S. Supreme Court

March 18, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

Rick Hasen at Election Law Blog posted a summary of Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council, the Prop. 200 voter registration case argued before the U.S. Supreme Court this morning. Sleeper Case of the Year?:

In brief, the question is whether Arizona can refuse to accept a simple federal form for voter registration (which Congress in the 1993 National Voter Registration Act required states to accept), on grounds Congress has exceeded its constitutional power under the Elections Clause  to “make or alter” state rules for congressional voting.

I’ll be writing more about the case after I read the transcript, but at this point I can say the following: This is one of those cases where if the Supreme Court affirms the result in this case (that Arizona must accept the federal form), it will be no big deal, but if the Court reverses it would mark a major change in U.S. election law.

Just say no to online Internet voting: Cyberattack on Florida election is first known case in US

March 18, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

SB 1387, a bill sponsored by Sen. Bob Worsley (R-Mesa), the founder of retail catalog giant SkyMall, seeks to establish an online voting pilot program in time for the 2014 primary election. The Arizona Capitol Times (subscription required) reported earlier this month, Senator proposes online voting for 2014.

I posted about this election scandal out of Miami not being reported anywhere outside of Florida. The case of the phantom ballots: an electoral whodunit – Miamia Herald:

It had all the appearances of a political dirty trick, a high-tech effort by an unknown hacker to sway three key Aug. 14 primary elections, a Miami Herald investigation has found.

The plot failed. The elections department’s software flagged the requests as suspicious. The ballots weren’t sent out.

But who was behind it? And next time, would a more skilled hacker be able to rig an election?

Six months and a grand-jury probe later, there still are few answers about the phantom requests, which targeted Democratic voters in a congressional district and Republican voters in two Florida House districts.

NBC News today has a follow-up to this story. Cyberattack on Florida election is first known case in US, experts say:

An attempt to illegally obtain absentee ballots in Florida last year is the first known case in the U.S. of a cyberattack against an online election system, according to computer scientists and lawyers working to safeguard voting security.

Another look at the runup to the Iraq War

March 18, 2013

by David Safier

This week marks the 10 year anniversary of the War in Iraq. I'm guessing the media commentary we hear will have a "We screwed up" tone this time, unlike during the runup to war when doubters were pushed aside for the front page headlines about WMDs and Saddam's close relationship with Al Qaeda.

Remember the piece of nuclear hardware buried under a rose bush, which was a clear indication that Saddam had buried pieces of his nuclear capabilities in gardens around Iraq? Remember the aluminum tubes that were the wrong diameter to be used in centrifuges that were clear indications Saddam was adding centrifuges so he could build up his nuclear arsenal? Remember how Saddam was planning to attack the U.S. with low-range missiles by shipping them close to our shores and firing them at our coastlines?

Remember how the media reported those "facts" and others with a straight face?

Arizona Legislature: The coming week

March 17, 2013

By Craig McDermott, crossposted from Random Musings

 

 

As usual, all committee agendas, floor calendars, and event schedules are  subject to change without notice. Call ahead to confirm plans before travelling  to the Capitol based on an agenda, calendar, or schedule cited  here.

Notes:

If an agenda is summarized with "looks harmless so  far" that only means that nothing on the agenda set off "bat-shit crazy" alarm  bells; if the committee in question covers an area of interest to you, check out  the full agenda yourself. And if I missed something significant, please leave a  comment letting me know.

A hearing room designation of "SHR" means it is  a hearing room in the Senate building; "HHR" means that the hearing room is in  the House building.

Lastly, this summary is not, nor is it intended to  be, comprehensive. Many bills have been covered, but not all of them. Again, if  a committee covers an area of interest to you, please check out the full agenda  yourself.

 

Great philosopher face-off

March 17, 2013

by David Safier Who said it: SpongeBob or Nietzsche? Fifteen quotes. Fifteen chances to feel like an idiot. Just click on the pic below each quote for immediate feedback.

Voted Arizona’s Best Political Blog
by the Washington Post and Google’s FeedSpot

Arizona Insight Podcast

latest Event from thedgt.ORG

Upcoming community Events

Bluesky