Featured Stories
School surveys of TUSD principals on the nonrenewal list
April 10, 2013
by
by David Safier
On Monday, TUSD indicated it had slated 4 principals for removal because their schools had D grades from the state two years in a row. At last night's Board meeting, 3 of the 4 principals' contracts were not renewed, though if they receive a C or better rating from the state this year, they could be reinstated. The fourth principal, I was told by Pedicone's office, was taken off the nonrenewal list, though I wasn't told why.
I wanted to find a way of evaluating the 4 principals' effectiveness using something other than students' scores on the state test which are used to calculate the school's grade, so I spent some time compiling data from the districts' yearly School Quality Survey Summaries. The surveys, spanning 2007 to 2013, are completed by staff, parents and students. They are a series of statements which can be marked Strongly Agree, Agree, Disagree, Strongly Disagree or N.A./Don't Know. I checked to see if there was a significant change in the evaluations from before and after the current principals began at that school and if there were any significant trends during their tenure.
Here's a summary of my findings:
- Rex Scott, Catalina Magnet High: Scott's evaluations are markedly better than those of his predecessor and on a par with or better than the district-wide evaluations.
- Heidi Aranda, Ochoa Magnet Elementary: Aranda has been with the school since 2002, so I couldn't compare her with her predecessor. Her evaluations vary considerably from year to year, with the high points being 2008, 2012 and 2013, all of which are significantly stronger than 2009-2011.
- Mark Alvarez, Manzo Elementary: Alvarez's evaluations are comparable to, though a bit lower than, the principal he replaced beginning in 2010. Both principals have reasonably high evaluations with very few negatives.
- Cindy Shepard-Mady, Utterback Magnet Middle: Shepard-Mady took over as principal in 2011. Her short, two year tenure may be the reason she was taken off the nonrenewal list. However, her evaluations are the only ones with a serious red flag. Her first year's evaluation is a bit lower than that of her predecessor, but her most recent evaluation took a sharp dip, with the staff giving her significantly lower marks than they did her first year.
To the extent these evaluations reflect the job the principals are doing, Rex Scott is doing an exceptional job, Heidi Aranda and Mark Alvarez appear to be competent principals who should be observed more carefully before a decision is made not to renew their contracts, and Cindy Shepard-Mady appears to have lost the confidence of her staff, which may indicate that she isn't an effective principal. Ironically, Shepard-Mady is the only principal in the group with serious red flags in her evaluations, yet she is the only one guaranteed for renewal.
Read further to learn about my findings in a bit more depth.
Back-door assault on Citizens Clean Elections goes to the Governor – tell her to veto the bill
April 10, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Our lawless legislature is disregarding sound legal advice and passing unconstitutional legislation again, pissing away your tax dollars on the litigation which is certain to follow.
This time it is the Tea-Publican back-door assault on Citizens Clean Elections. Arizona Legislature OKs higher election-donor caps:
The Senate approved higher contribution limits Tuesday, as a grass-roots group lobbied state lawmakers to reject the measure and critics warned the bill is unconstitutional. Even before House Bill 2593 gets to the governor’s desk, critics are asking Brewer to veto it.
Supporters said the increase in how much individuals and political-action committees can give to campaigns is needed to combat the rising influence of independent-expenditure committees, effectively fighting the committees’ financial firepower with beefed-up finances from candidates themselves. It would apply to all elections under state control, from the gubernatorial race to school-board seats.
[Bullshit Alert: No candidate can hope to outspend an independent-expenditure committee with unlimited resources from undisclosed donors. All this does is make elections so expensive that it freezes out qualified candidates from running for office who are not independently wealthy or have a lot of rich friends and relatives. This is another step towards a wealthy elite plutocracy.]
Arizona legislature fails to consider real solutions to the problems with our elections
April 10, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
The Arizona Capitol Times has an important report on an Arizona Center for Investigative Reporting analysis of the problems experienced in the 2012 eelction in Arizona. What the report makes clear is that the Arizona legislature is failing to consider real solutions to the problems with our elections, while pursuing bills to place additional burdens on the right to voters. Rejected ballots reflect continuing problems in Arizona’s elections:
Tens of thousands of ballots cast in
Arizona’s 2012 election were rejected by elections officials, indicating
continued communication and voter education problems in the state,
according to an analysis by the Arizona Center for Investigative Reporting.
Nearly 46,000 of the more than 2.3 million ballots cast in Arizona’s 2012 election – or about 2 percent – were rejected. That rate is down from 2.2 percent in 2008, when Arizona led the nation in rejected provisional ballots.
The analysis was based on a review of rejected ballots and interviews with experts and legislators.
The rejected votes consist of early voting or provisional ballots in which voters went through the voting process but later had their ballots thrown out after review by elections officials. The most common reasons were that voters weren’t registered in time for the election, voted in the wrong precincts or didn’t sign their ballots.
* * *
Election experts say rejected ballot rates – and the reasons for rejection – can point to either poor voter education about Arizona’s election process or inefficiencies in the state’s election administration efforts. [Bingo!]
Of the 33,000 provisional ballots that were rejected in 2012, 38 percent were because the voter wasn’t registered in the state and 33 percent because the voter submitted a ballot in the wrong precinct.
Election officials said voters who weren’t registered might have missed the state’s registration cut-off date, which was 29 days before Election Day. Voters who register after that date are not eligible to vote in that election.
Obama’s 3-pronged assault on the Party of No
April 10, 2013
by
by David Safier
Intentionally or not, Obama and the Democrats are putting the squeeze on Republicans in Congress, breaking down the GOP's united wall of resistance to everything a Democrat might support. Some not-too-crazy Republicans who are sick of being bullied by their batshit-crazy right wing are being peeled off with gun and immigration legislation. The next assault on the GOP's united front will likely be the confirmation fight over Sri Srinivasan who the Obama administration hopes will fill an open slot on the DC Circuit Court of Appeals. That's three battles the obstructionists have to fight simultaneously, fragmenting their efforts and diluting their message. Chances are, they're going to lose on some or all of the issues.
It's too early to say for sure, but it looks like the filibuster promised on any gun legislation by a bloc of Republican senators is going down. Enough Republicans are planning to join Democrats to get over the 60 vote mark. Meanwhile, immigration legislation is being pushed by Republicans who are — gasp! — working together with Democrats like Chuck Schumer to forge a bipartisan bill. Just the fact that Republicans are taking contrary positions on those two pieces of legislation is exposing cracks in the GOP wall of resistance. If legislation is voted on in the House and the Senate, Republicans will be forced to make public declarations of their positions on the issues which could sink their hopes of attracting voters in the middle who are for gun control legislation and comprehensive immigration reform. Whatever bills come to the floor will probably be far short of what we want — they may even be voted down — but Republicans are going to be weakened simply by allowing a vote.
The Septegenarian Ninja Turtle’s conspiracy theory does not hold water
April 10, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
The Septegenarian Ninja Turtle, Mitch McConnell (R-KY), wants to run against the mean "librul" media rather than on his dismal record, a tried and true tactic of conservative demagogues running in red states.
Our boy Mitch is claiming that his campaign office was illegally bugged by lefty "librul" media out to get him — the McConnell campaign has not offered any evidence the recording was the result of an illegal bug — and has asked the FBI and U.S. Attorney in Kentucky to investigate. McConnell's campaign offices were swept by a private security detail, which did not find a bug. Mitch McConnell seeks FBI investigation.
Something about this seems all too familiar. Is this possibly a Karl Rove operation? Karl Rove – Wikipedia:
In 1986, just before a crucial debate in campaign, Rove claimed that his office had been bugged by Democrats. The police and FBI investigated and discovered that the bug's battery was so small that it needed to be changed every few hours, and the investigation was dropped. Critics, including other Republican operatives, suspected Rove had bugged his own office to garner sympathy votes in the close governor's race.
Bipartisan compromise bill reached on background checks
April 10, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
"Half a loaf is better than no bread." – Thomas Jefferson, paraphrasing an ancient proverb
Political compromise used to be defined by this ancient proverb. Or as a Democratic senator once told me, progress is made through incremental change — we'll take the half loaf today and come back next year to try again for the other half. When you demand "all or nothing" you usually get nothing.
There is not a whole lot of this "long game" patience and perseverance in today's politics. As I have said before, I blame the instant gratification society that modern technology has created. Everybody wants everything right now!
So there is bound to be disappointment for some over the bipartisan compromise bill on background checks announced today. Senators: Bipartisan deal reached on expanding gun background checks:
A bipartisan group of senators has struck a deal to expand gun background checks to all commercial sales — whether at gun shows, via the Internet or in any circumstance involving paid advertising, according to Senate aides familiar with the talks.
The amendment to the guns legislation already proposed in the Senate would not cover private transactions between individuals, unless there was advertising or an online service involved.
Ronstadt Transit Center: City, Developers Ponder Proverbial Political Football (video)
April 10, 2013
Anyone who has lived in Tucson long enough knows that the vitality of downtown has ebbed and flowed with the winds of politics and the fortunes of capitalism.
Thanks to infrastructure investments, tax breaks, land deals, and the promise of Rio Nuevo college students with Daddy's credit cards, downtown is again on the upswing– with swanky bars, over-priced restaurants, micro-breweries, maxi-dorms, and a modern street car to deliver college students to the main gate of the university.
With the smell of money in the air, capitalists are ready to play "let's make a deal" with Tucson's Mayor and Council. One city property that developers have been trying to score for years is the Ronstadt Transit Center, on Congress. Once surrounded by seedy bars, funky diners, and shoe-string art galleries, the Ronstadt Center is now in the thick of downtown's rebirth as Mill Ave South.
Anyone who was around in 2009-2010 when developers lobbied for a land swap deal that would include ~40% of the Ronstadt Center for commercial development should pay attention to what's happening now. Details and video after the jump.
Intellectual Dishonesty Bi-Partisan Style
April 9, 2013
by
Posted by Bob Lord
If you're sick and tired of partisan bickering in Congress, you may want to reconsider.
You see, one month ago, the "freshman bi-partisan caucus," or "United Solutions" gang, as they're calling themselves, led by 29 year-old Democrat Patrick Murphy of Florida, issued their manifesto, in the form of a statement to President Obama and House leaders in both parties, outlining their supposed bi-partisan solutions. You can find the entire letter here. According to this bi-partisan caucus, which by my count numbers 36 including 13 Democrats, their statement outlines areas of "common ground." My own assessment is that the supposedly common ground bullet points in the statement either are taken straight from the Republican playbook or are proposals with which nobody could conceivably take issue, like "aggressively pursuing Medicare fraud." Wow, that's thinking outside the box.
But the real gem in the United Solutions manifesto is the second bullet point, which reads in full:




