Past and Present Political Polarization


By Karl Reiner

Last month, President Obama began his second term in office under conditions somewhat improved from four years ago. Back then, the economy was contracting at 5% per year and 600,000 to 800,000 people per month were being dumped into the ranks of the unemployed.

The effects of the Great Recession show how imperfect the tools available to policymakers are.  After
White Housecomplex Wall Street products helped feed the sub-prime housing mess, the resulting crisis had to be met by costly Federal Reserve and Treasury actions that stemmed the slide into depression.  The remedies are unpopular because in saving the  economy, the government had to help a banking sector that contributed mightily to the collapse.

Although the economy has slowly improved, the nation is burdened with a $16 trillion debt.  It was aggravated by the recession's impact and the stimulus plans improvised to fight it.  Unemployment remains around 7.8%.  There are now 134 million Americans in the labor force, about 4 million less than when the recession began. 

The troublesome specter of income inequality is growing due to the shifting of resources to finance, globalization and the fact that computers and robots are eliminating jobs.  The baby-boomers are retiring, the workforce is aging.  Spending on pensions and health care costs could hinder plans to reduce the deficit.

The hangover effects of the Bush era tax cuts, the unfunded wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and the American people's emphasis on rights over obligations are substantial. The argument for undefined small government by conservatives and their tea party allies limits options. The resulting political gridlock forces the White House and Congress to come to agreement only at the last minute. 

There are a host of festering international problems.  Iran is developing a nuclear threat, Russia is antagonistic, Europe wallows in recession, the Middle East roils and Iraq's democracy is shaky.  Al-Qaeda has proved to be durable; it is so active in Mali the French have intervened. Afghanistan remains unstable and Pakistan is of little help. The Mexican border has security and drug issues. 

Some parts of the world are changing for the better. Nearly a billion Indians and Chinese have climbed into the middle class during the previous few years.  The value of exports moving between developing countries now exceeds the value of their shipments to the developed world. In the last 20 years, the developing countries share of world trade has increased from 16% to 32%.

President Lincoln also faced problems 150 years ago. The average life expectancy in America back then was 55 years. At the start of the Civil War, cotton was the nation's largest export.  The value of slaves in the South was equal to the value of the nation's railroads, banks and factories.  As a wartime measure, the Emancipation Proclamation became effective in January 1863.

In May 1861, the Union army occupied the high ridge across the Potomac River in Virginia.  Beginning in Virginia and running around the District of Columbia line, the Corps of Engineers constructed a system
Batteries-in-Fort-No-2-Fort-Whippleof fortifications, making Washington the most heavily fortified city in North America. The defenses would eventually consist of 161 forts and batteries with emplacements for approximately 1,000 cannon.

The danger was real for a time.  After their victory at the first battle of Manassas (Bull Run) in July 1861, the Confederates controlled a 58 mile front running from Leesburg, Virginia through Centreville to the south bank of the Occoquan River where it entered the Potomac. Confederate batteries along the Potomac shore closed the river to shipping, blockading Washington's river supply line.

The Confederates are long gone from their headquarters and fortifications in Centreville.  Not far from the site of one of the Confederate forts, the Honey Pig restaurant serves a clientele of Korean expatriates, veterans and government workers.  Many are discussing the consequences of the coming funding sequester. It is sign that the nation is virtually as polarized today as it was during the Civil War era.         


Previous articleBest Super Bowl ad: Chrysler Corp. scores again
Next articleBuying guns on
AZ BlueMeanie
The Blue Meanie is an Arizona citizen who wishes, for professional reasons, to remain anonymous when blogging about politics. Armed with a deep knowledge of the law, politics and public policy, as well as pen filled with all the colors stolen from Pepperland, the Blue Meanie’s mission is to pursue and prosecute the hypocrites, liars, and fools of politics and the media – which, in practical terms, is nearly all of them. Don’t even try to unmask him or he’ll seal you in a music-proof bubble and rendition you to Pepperland for a good face-stomping. Read blog posts by the infamous and prolific AZ Blue Meanie here.


  1. “It is sign that the nation is virtually as polarized today as it was during the Civil War era.”

    Um, no. In 1861 each side was shooting at each other, with CANNONS! We were in a REAL Civil War, dead bodies littering the landscape. What we’re in today doesn’t come CLOSE.

    It is pure ‘both sides do it’ anti-democratic ‘pox on both their houses’ cynicism-mongering to even suggest this; and they key phrase is “omigod pensions and social security will hinder reducing the deficit!!”

    Just another Pete Peterson 1%-er sadist centrist corporatadem.

    The Great Recession does NOT show “how imperfect the tools available to policy makers are”. What it shows is what tools our policy makers are. There are relatively simple things we could do to fix the economy; we KNOW they work because WE’VE DONE THEM BEFORE. But when most of our elected officials cling to Randian dogma about austerity and the Confidence Fairy, the Great Recession was made that way by their refusal to use the tools available to them.

    Our leaders are savagely, brutally grinding enormous numbers of people into abject poverty because of their refusal to acknowledge reality.