Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
There are two ways to evaluate a debate. The first is what is often referred to as the "optics" or "atmospherics" of a debate, i.e., a subjective evaluation of who won based upon such things as demeanor, body language, a memorable line, etc., an emotional response. This is what the media villagers focus on exclusively.
The second is a substantive evaluation or objective evaluation of policy positions based upon the facts. The media villagers rarely do this, and even the so-called fact checkers insert their subjective opinions into supposedly objective fact checking.
The first presidential debate was Wednesday night. The parlor game is "who won?"
On the optics or atmospherics, Willard "Mittens" Romney clearly won on a subjective evaluation of demeanor and body language. He was well prepared and appropriately aggressive. For all their denials to the contrary, Americans love a fighter. They instinctively will rate the more aggressive candidate the winner of a debate. Team Obama should be aware of this.
President Obama was far too passive and passed up numerous opportunities to correct Romney's falsehoods and to advance themes his campaign has been making in ads and in speeches for months: Bain Capital, offshore banks accounts, Romney's failure to disclose his tax returns, economic patriotism, Romney's contempt for the 47%, the success of the auto rescue, 30 months of private sector job growth, Romney's dismal Massachusetts jobs record, the benefits people have already received from ObamaCare and will lose if it is repealed. Worst of all, Obama did not constantly hammer away on the radical Ryan budget/Medicare vouchers and GOP obstruction in Congress — "give me a Democratic Congress." It was almost as if Obama took a dive in this fight. If there is a strategy here, I don't see it.
On a substantive or objective evaluation, President Obama held his own and a case can be made that he was the winner. Why? Because "Mittens" Romney doubled-down on his "big lie" GOPropaganda campaign themes and even added a couple of new lies, i.e., that he will not give tax cuts to the rich and that he supports government regulations, which is completely at odds with Tea-Publican orthodoxy. One should not score points for lying. Romney lied with a disconcerting ease, but he looked good doing it, so instead of calling him out for his lies, the media villagers declared him the winner for being such an effective liar. It's the optics. And you wonder what is wrong with our politics today.
There is one issue that I have a bone to pick with the President. At the end of his two minute opening statement, "Mittens" Romney stated:
The president has a view very similar to the view he had when he ran four years, that a bigger government, spending more, taxing more, regulating more — if you will, trickle-down government — would work. That's not the right answer for America. I'll restore the vitality that gets America working again. Thank you.
The moderator, Jim Lehrer, then asked:
Mr. President, please respond directly to what the governor just said about trickle-down — his trick-down approach, as he said yours is.
When I heard this my eyes lit up. This was a hanging fastball that I have been waiting on to drive into the center field seats. This was the opportunity to lay waste to 30 years of disproved and discredited GOP economic policies that have destroyed the economic foundation of this country, then bring it back back around to economists — and President Bill Clinton – who have described Romney's economic plan as George W. Bush's economic plan on steroids, and finish with "we are not going back to these failed policies, we are moving forward" (the Obama campaign theme).
What did President Obama do with this hanging fast ball in the sweet spot? He talked about his education policies. Dude! Were you not listening to the question? Your answer should have accomplished two things: lay waste to the disproved and discredited faith based supply side "trickle down" GOP economics, and then dismiss Romney's (Frank Luntz's) attempt to confuse low information voters by injecting a new made-up term, "trickle down government," into the debate. Obama let this sneering plutocrat get away with this crap from Luntz.
Mr. President, you are a Harvard educated lawyer. I expect far better than this. When your opponent hangs a fast ball, swing for the fences!
Discover more from Blog for Arizona
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
My assessment of the debatek for what it’s worthk is that the audience was the biggest looser. Romney’s first remarks to Jim lehrer displayed a wise-ass manner – he will eliminate funding for NPR – and how will that help the economy. I was reminded of the prep school bully (Romney) who pinned a classmate to the floor and cut off his hair – we can’t let him do that to the America we love!!! And Lehrer failed to moderate. he didn’t have a bell, a gavel, a will and a voice to say “time up” and that lack of a disciplined structure gave the whole debate a kick in the teeth. The loosers? Those who watched the performance – a debate it was not!