SCOTUS declines Wisconsin voter ID case

U.S. Supreme Court observers believed that the Court would grant review in the voter ID case from Wisconsin, Frank v. Walker (14-803), because it presented the case for which the Court left the door open in its decision in Crawford v. Marion County Election Board:

VotersIssue: (1) Whether a state’s voter ID law violates the Equal Protection Clause where, unlike in Crawford v. Marion County Election Board, the evidentiary record establishes that the law substantially burdens the voting rights of hundreds of thousands of the state’s voters, and that the law does not advance a legitimate state interest; and (2) whether a state’s voter ID law violates Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act where the law disproportionately burdens and abridges the voting rights of African-American and Latino voters compared to White voters.

This morning the Court disappointed many election law attorneys by denying review in this case. Supreme Court turns away challenge to Wisconsin’s voter ID law:

The Supreme Court on Monday turned down a challenge to Wisconsin’s voter ID law, which it had previously kept from going into effect before November’s elections.

In October, the justices said the Wisconsin law could not take effect before the Nov. 4 midterm elections. At the time, civil rights groups told the court that there was no time to meet the law’s requirements because a lower court had previously suspended the measure.

[The Court applied the Purcell principle: the idea that you don’t change election rules in the period just before the election.]

* * *

The court’s decision not to review a federal appeals court ruling that upheld the law is a victory for Gov. Scott Walker (R) and perhaps other states that have tightened voting procedures to require additional identification.

Rick Hasen at Election Law Blog says this may be A Blessing in Disguise? The Supreme Court’s Refusal to Hear Wisconsin Voter ID Case:

This morning the Supreme Court without comment refused to take up Frank v. Walker, the Wisconsin voter id case. Taking the case to the Supreme Court divided the civil rights community.

As I noted last week, those who hoped the Supreme Court would hear the case were betting that Chief Justice Roberts or Justice Kennedy were going to have the same kind of epiphany that Judge Posner of the 7th Circuit had.

Judge Posner had voted to uphold Indiana’s voter ID law back in the mid-2000s when it was challenged. Judge Posner saw the requirement as no big deal. But by last year, Judge Posner was writing that such laws have now been generally recognized as a means of suppressing likely Democratic votes than as a means of fraud prevention. (The evidence that such laws deter any significant amount of impersonation voter fraud is thin indeed.)

But it is not clear that Kennedy and Roberts, the conservative Justices likely in the middle of the Court on this issue have had a similar religious conversion on the issue. The four liberals could have forced a hearing in this case (by voting to grant cert) but they must not have been confident of the religious conversion either.

Similarly, DOJ has done very little to support this case. They are betting on Texas (and to some extent North Carolina), hoping those cases will be better vehicles for getting voter ID laws struck down.

But relying on Texas to ultimately help Wisconsin is risky. In the Texas voter ID case, now pending before the 5th Circuit, we have a holding that Texas’s passage of the voter ID law was the product of intentional racial discrimination. That’s a finding which should be very hard to reverse on appeal. it provides an easier constitutional path for the Supreme Court to strike down Texas’s voter id law.

The upside of that would be a Supreme Court decision striking down a voter ID law on constitutional grounds. The downside is that other cases, like Wisconsin, do not involve intentional discrimination and so a Texas holding might not help very much outside of Texas. It would be an outer bound of what’s allowed and forbidden.

Had the Court agreed to hear the Wisconsin case, it is possible it would have read Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act even more narrowly in cases of vote denial, as well as make bad law on the scope of the equal protection clause. In this way, the Court’s refusal to hear Wisconsin’s voter id case may be a blessing in disguise.

As I’ve long argued, the best way for liberals to cut their losses is to stay out of the Supreme Court when possible. Things could have been worse if the Court took Wisconsin than if they didn’t.  And if you trust Justice Ginsburg, trust her in not voting to grant cert in this case.

I think it is probably a fair assessment that the Court’s conservative majority, which upheld voter ID in Marion County despite the lack of any evidence presented by the state of Indiana to support a legitimate state interest, probably still does not care whether voter suppression occurs even when the substantial weight of the evidence in the record of Frank v. Walker does “establish that the law substantially burdens the voting rights of hundreds of thousands of the state’s voters, and that the law does not advance a legitimate state interest.” For the “Felonious Five,” voter ID and other election law cases are a political decision they are making, and to hell with applying the rule of law. And that is a dangerous destructive path the Court is on.


Discover more from Blog for Arizona

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

11 thoughts on “SCOTUS declines Wisconsin voter ID case”

  1. ”For the “Felonious Five,” voter ID and other election law cases are a political decision they are making, and to hell with applying the rule of law.”

    Why is it that the Court is “applying the law” ONLY when they agree with liberal interpretations of it? If they favor a conservative slant on the law, then you declare them illegitimate and utterly wrong. Does it ever occur to you that you might just be wrong? Sorry, no…of course it doesn’t.

    ”. And that is a dangerous destructive path the Court is on.”

    The Courts at all levels have been vigorously legislating from the bench since “Bussing” started back in the 1960s. When it was a liberal court, I am certain you had no problem with the wisdom of these elder statesmen. But when the Court took on a more conservative tone, they suddenly became ill informed cretins with a political agenda. Not much of a surprise there.

    My Grandson won a very competitive slot among high school students (only 2 students from each state were selected) to go to Washington, D.C., and get special “meet and greet” tours behind the scenes of government. He met the President as well as several Department and Bureau Heads/Chiefs. The SCOTUS member that addressed them was Justice Souter. In his speech, he summed up the philosophy of the liberal Court (which I suspect is your philosophy) in stating, “The purpose of the Court is to apply the Constitution in light of today’s society, not based on the Founder’s original intent.”

    To me, that is the same as having NO Constitution. If the basis of your interpretation is whatever is happening right now, then the Constitution has no weight or precedence upon which you can base a consistent and reliable decision. Instead you are left with the whim and whimsy of whatever modern life demands.

    And please don’t come at with the smug response “isn’t it wonderful we do that because we stopped slavery and demanded suffrage from the original Founders.” Of course the Constitution needs updated from time to time to reflect positive changes in our Society, but there is a whole range of changes the liberal Courts effected there are of questionable Constitutionality. Now that the arching philosophy of the Court is conservative, YOU are the one questioning it’s reach. That would actually be somewhat amusing, if it weren’t so serious.

    • Dude, the Supreme Court, as did the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals, is ignoring the substantial body of evidence and testimony presented at trial in this case that many thousands of Wisconsinites are in fact disenfranchised of their right to vote with this law. When the Court: (1) disregards all evidence presented at trial and (2) elects not to enforce Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, the court is by definition ignoring the rule of law. They chose not to apply the law at all.

      This is not a question of “living Constitution” interpretation versus “original intent” interpretation. There’s an actual goddamn law, the Voting Rights Act of 1965, the single most important law of the 20th Century. The Supreme Court applied the law without question for 48 years until the Roberts Court came along and decided to gut the law, and now refuses to apply those provisions that are still effective controlling law.

      Congratulations to your grandson. I hope that he is more enlightened than you are.

      • The “evidence” provided in support of disenfranchisement – the great bugaboo of the Democrat Party – is largely anecdotal, suppositional and based on studies where the findings were determined before the study was started. Your personal opinion notwithstanding, as far as Part 2 of the Voting Rights Act is concerned, it is only violated IF the Supreme Court determines that it was violated. If SCOTUS determines that these various pieces of legislation do not violate the law, and allows them to stand, that is a de facto ruling on their Constitutionality.

        Every legal scholar can hold an opinion, but it is just an opinion until the Supreme Court makes a determination by it’s action whether it is the law of the land or not. Despite your assertion that huge amounts of evidence were submitted demonstrating disenfranchisement, there was equally important evidence demonstrating that was poppycock and there was no undue burden placed on anyone. Apparently, it was enough to sway the 6th Circuit and SCOTUS. I don’t know what the Supreme Court will finally decide, and I may be sorely disappointed in them, but I am convinced that anyone who says they are disenfranchised by having to prove who they are, and that they can legally vote, is either an idiot, or someone trying to scam the system.

        Thank you for your congratulations to my Grandson on his accomplishment. That was very kind of you. I don’t know if he is more enlightened than I am, but at his age he certainly is more accomplished than I was at the same age. He has received offers of several full ride scholarships to a number of prestigious Universities. He is a good kid who thinks for himself.

        • “Your personal opinion notwithstanding, as far as Part 2 of the Voting Rights Act is concerned, it is only violated IF the Supreme Court determines that it was violated. If SCOTUS determines that these various pieces of legislation do not violate the law, and allows them to stand, that is a de facto ruling on their Constitutionality.”

          You really should not practice law without a license — or clearly a legal education. A one line denial of certiorari by the Supreme Court without an opinion is in not “a de facto ruling on their Constitutionality.” This is probably the single most ignorant thing you have ever posted, and God knows, you have been trying hard to set a world record for ignorant troll posts. A denial of certiorari only means that the court will not hear this appeal, not because they agree with the lower court — for which the court would have affirmed the decision — but because the court does not believe that this is the right case to decide the constitutional question presented, the point that Rick Hasen made in the post above.

          And a law is “violated” only if the U.S. Supreme Court says so? This the province of trial courts and a jury, which in this case found Wisconsin violated the law. It was overturned by the 7th Circuit relying on the Supreme Court decision which the plaintiffs in this case wanted to get back in front of the Supreme Court for reconsideration in light of the evidentiary record in the trial court.

          You really outdid yourself in the ignorance effort on this one.

          • I’ve never claimed to be a legal scholar. I just look at the practical effects of the actions taken by the Supreme Court. The law, as written, remains in effect. It is a “de facto” decision because it still stands. You may have a convoluted legal explanation for why leaving the law in place does not mean the Court left the law in place, but to someone just standing aside watching, it certainly looks like the law is still in place.

            The Court may well change their collective minds in the future and your opinion will prevail, but for the current time it is in question, and by it’s action (or rather, it’s inaction) the Court has a dealt a blow to your cause. You can put as much as much lipstick on that pig as you want, it is still a pig.

            Yes, the initial place for ruling on the legality (constitutionality) of a law starts with the lower courts and juries. HOWEVER, through the appeal process, the final ruling can go all the way to the Supreme Court that can reverse every decision made by the lower courts. So, by it’s action or inaction, all laws are decided upon by the Supreme Court. That is why no decision ever made in a lower level court is comsidered final as long as the plaintiff or the defendent has the funds available to appeal it to a higher court.

            No, I’m not a legal scholar, but anyone who cares to watch can see the obvious workings of the Court system in the United States. There are subtlties that often confound people, but it’s basic workings are rather simple.

          • I have neither the time nor the inclination to provide you with a legal education, especially for free. Suffice it to say that your rant is fundamentally in error in every respect. If you want to believe that you understand something simply because you stayed at a Holiday Inn last night, as the commercial goes. It only amplifies your proud ignorance and unwillingness to learn.

          • That is a little bit of a copout, AZ Blue Meanie, and I am a little disappointed that you would take this path. I have learned a lot from you over the months I have been following this blog. We do disagree on most things, but you have changed my mind on others. Regardless, I always read your postings because they are very informative and give me a glimpse into opinions I likely disagree with, but need to be aware of. What I am saying is I hope you will continue to verbally spar with me in the future when the opportunity arises.

  2. Voter id laws make it harder to register and vote. The democratic party and voter rights groups now must work harder to register and get people out to vote. We must demand of our candidates especially rich old white men that they spend some of their campaign money on voter registration and getting voters ids for those who do not have them. They can spend the rest of their money on their igo trip telling the voters why they are jesus and their opponent is hitler. By the way my screenplay on the undocumented children’s plight in arizona is about to go up on my website. I will let you know when it is up so you can read stand tell me what you think.

    • How, Captain, do Voter ID Laws make it harder to register and vote.

      I look forward to reading your screeplay.

      • Steve I remember 90 year old world war 2 veteran who only had his va id as he no longer drove who wanted to vote in republican primary and was turned down. Also many people don’t have their birth certificate some because they were born before they were made mandatory many poor people no longer have them so they can’t register. Over 300,000 people wanting to register in arizona were stopped from registering. Ed montini was given the only case of in person voter fraud they could find and prosecute a republican woman who voted for romney twice in nevada and arizona.

        • 300,000 people were stopped from registering in Arizona? And not one word ever showed up in the news anywhere? Nor did that information show up in any challenge against the law? It doesn’t oass the common sense test, Captain. Sorry.

Comments are closed.