(Update) New Jersey Court rules in favor of marriage equality


Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

EqualJudge Mary Jacobson, who last month ordered the state
to allow same sex marriages because she said gay couples are being
denied equal rights "every day," Thursday wrote that delaying the start
date would prolong "violations of their constitutional rights." Christie to appeal judge's ruling allowing same-sex marriage:

[Judge Mary Jacobson] refused to delay the Oct. 21 start date she set to begin same-sex
marriages in New Jersey, rejecting the Christie administration’s
contention that no gay weddings should be peformed while the case is
still being fought in the courts.

* * *

It’s possible the Oct. 21 start date could still be put on hold. The
Christie administration quickly responded Thursday by requesting the
state Appellate Division grant the delay instead. The appeals court
could consider the motion as soon as next week, according to filing
deadlines it set for both sides to make their case.

Gay rights advocates applauded Jacobson’s decision.

In her ruling last month, Jacobson said same-sex couples in New
Jersey were being denied equal rights and must be allowed to marry
beginning Oct. 21 to receive the full range of federal benefits that
heterosexual couples receive.

Christie’s administration is seeking to appeal directly to the state
Supreme Court to prevent the marriages. In the meantime, it asked Jacobson to delay marriages until the appeals process is through.

But in her 17-page decision Thursday, Jacobson said allowing
marriages to move forward would cause no harm to the state and the
administration was unlikely to succeed on appeal.

"The ‘harm’ (the state) alleges simply cannot justify depriving
plaintiffs and other same-sex couples of equality in the form of access
to important federal marital benefits," Jacobson wrote.

The decision came the same day a new Quinnipiac University poll showed 61 percent of likely New Jersey voters think Christie should drop the appeal.

* * *

Democrats in the Legislature, who are trying to muster enough votes
to override Christie’s veto of their gay marriage bill, called on the
governor to drop his fight following Thursday's decisison.

"Gov. Christie needs to finally get the message and stop doing
everything he can to stand in the way of civil rights," Assembly Speaker
Sheila Oliver (D-Essex) said in a statement. "Enough is enough,
governor. Do the right thing."

Democratic gubernatorial candidate Barabara Buono said Christie "remains firmly on the wrong side of history."

As I previously posted:

The decision follows a New Jersey Supreme Court decision that required
same-sex couples to have access to all the same benefits of opposite-sex
couples, except the word marriage. The state legislature chose instead
to extend civil unions, but the federal benefits that have been offered
since the U.S. Supreme Court overturned DOMA have not applied to civil unions, which are not accounted for in federal statutes.

Based upon this New Jersey Supreme Court precedent, it would appear that court is not inclined to side with Governor Christie on appeal. The court was signaling that if the appropriate plaintiff brought the appropriate claim, it was ready to move beyond the limitation in its prior order (which predates the U.S. Supreme Court decisions on DOMA). The U.S. Supreme Court decisions give the court impetus to move forward.

UPDATE: The New Mexico Supreme Court will hear arguments on October 23 in a case which may determine the right to marry for same-sex couples in the state.

A special session in the Hawaii Legislature to move forward a bill that would legalize gay marriage is scheduled to begin October 28.

Previous articleBook Review: With Liberty and Justice For Some
Next articleGOP government shutdown strategy damages the GOP
AZ BlueMeanie
The Blue Meanie is an Arizona citizen who wishes, for professional reasons, to remain anonymous when blogging about politics. Armed with a deep knowledge of the law, politics and public policy, as well as pen filled with all the colors stolen from Pepperland, the Blue Meanie’s mission is to pursue and prosecute the hypocrites, liars, and fools of politics and the media – which, in practical terms, is nearly all of them. Don’t even try to unmask him or he’ll seal you in a music-proof bubble and rendition you to Pepperland for a good face-stomping. Read blog posts by the infamous and prolific AZ Blue Meanie here.


  1. There is no good reason to deny that we must keep evolving until an adult, regardless of gender, sexual orientation, monogamy or polyamory, race, or religion is free to marry any and all consenting adults. The limited same-gender freedom to marry is a great and historic step, but is NOT full marriage equality, because equality “just for some” is not equality. Let’s stand up for EVERY ADULT’S right to marry the person(s) they love. Get on the right side of history!

Comments are closed.