This was hilarious, sort of, if it weren’t depressing. I met one of the one percenters who sees himself as a victim.
I was at a party Friday night, and probably the only progressive there. This guy starts railing at me after I let it be known I think Obama is too far to the right. I don’t know a lot about the guy, but I’d heard from enough people how well he does that his membership in the top one percent was a safe assumption. He easily could be in the top point one percent.
His chief complaint? The “top one percent pay 47% of the income tax in America.”
So, I asked him: “What percent of the income flows to the top one percent?” After an uncomfortable five seconds or so, another person chimed in with what he thought was the answer. The few seconds of silence, however, was long enough to make clear what I suspected. He had worked himself into a lather over the share of the income tax paid by the top one percent, without even knowing their income share. My guess is that he heard the statistic on Fox News, from an anchor who expressed anger similar to his own. It’s one of their favorite talking points.
Of course, his anger made as much sense as being angry at your kid for getting a 50 on her math test before bothering to find out that there only were 50 points possible and the kid with the second highest grade scored a 44.
I didn’t have enough control of the discussion to do so then, but here’s what I hoped to explain to this angry one percenter, who clearly felt victimized by Obama:


