Federal voter registration form preempts Arizona’s Prop. 200 proof of citizenship requirement

June 17, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

The U.S. Surpeme Court issued five opinions this morning, but one opinion comes from Arizona, the Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc. challenge to Arizona's Prop. 200 (2004) requirement of proof of citizenship. The federal voter registration form only requires the voter to attest to citizenship status.

In a 7-2 decision, the U.S. Supreme Court held in Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc. that Arizona's proof of citizenship requirement is preempted by the federal law requiring that states use the federal voter registration form. Justices Thomas and Alito both filed dissenting opinions.

Here is a copy of the opinion. Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc.

Disgraced recalled Senator Russell Pearce and Governor Jan Brewer (who was Secretary of State at the time) are going to have a cow today over the Court's opinion.

I will have more when I have time to read through the 51 page opinion.

UPDATE: Today's win for the Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc. will be short-lived, because Justice Antonin Scalia's majority opinion lays out the administrative path for Arizona to follow to have the proof of citizenship requirements of Prop. 200 included in the federal voter registration form, and possible future litigation.

Here are highlights from Justice Scalia's majority opinion:

Gun violence: It’s a health crisis. Treat it that way.

June 16, 2013

By Craig McDermott, cross-posted from Random Musings

 

This has been a tough post to write.  Not because there is nothing to say, but because there is so much to say, it's been difficult to keep it down to a readable length.  However, since there have been more than 5000 gun deaths since the mass shooting in Newtown, Connecticut, and nothing has been done…

In the wake of December's mass shooting in Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut, there were a number of ideas floated to stem the epidemic of gun violence sweeping the country – reinstituting the assault weapons ban, closing the gun show loophole in background check laws, and banning ammunition magazines/ammo clips that are larger than a certain size, among many others – all of which have been strenuously opposed by the gun industry's lobbying group, the NRA, and most of which won't become law.

Witness Sen. Jeff Flake (R-AZ) and 44 of his colleagues banding together to block a proposal to close the "gun show loophole" in the federal law requiring background checks for firearms purchases.

Even though 90% of Americans, across all demographics – Ds, Rs, gun owners, liberals, conservatives, whatever – supported the common-sense move, 45% of US Senators were cravenly swayed by the NRA's campaign contributions.

SCOTUS Watch: Two weeks, 19 opinions

June 16, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

And the suspense builds . . .

According to the stats kept by Scotusblog.com, the U.S. Supreme Court has heard 75 merit cases this term, and issued opinions in 56 of those cases.

This leaves 19 opinions to be announced over the next two weeks before the end of June. Mondays are orders and opinions days, and the court has added Thursday opinion days. Unless the court adds an additional opinion day, this leaves four opinion days.

There are several cases I am following for decisions that could be issued on any of these four opinion days. One never knows, the U.S. Supreme Court does not announce opinions in advance, and the court does not leak to the media.

There are two voting rights cases. The first is Arizona v. The Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc., (12-71), which involves the question whether the National Voter Registration Act preempts Arizona's Prop. 200 (2004) that requires persons who are registering to vote to show proof of citizenship to register to vote. The federal law requires only an attestation of citizenship, subject to prosecution for false attestation. This is a federal preemption issue.

The "big one" that everyone is waiting for is Shelby County v. Holder, (12-96), which involves the question whether Congress’ decision in 2006 to reauthorize Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act under the pre-existing coverage formula of Section 4(b) of the Voting Rights Act exceeded its authority.

New Jersey special election challenge goes to state Supreme Court

June 16, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

This special election challenge is moving quickly through the New Jersey court system. The New Jersey Supreme Court will hear the case later this week. Bloomberg News reports Christie's Special Election Plan Heads NJ Supreme Court:

New Jersey’s Supreme Court will weigh in on Governor Chris Christie’s decision to hold a special election Oct. 16 to replace deceased U.S. Senator Frank Lautenberg.

The justices put the case on a fast track today, ordering briefs by June 17 and final responses by June 18, acting state courts administrative director Judge Glenn Grant said in a statement. The move follows a lower appeals court decision yesterday that there’s no legal obstacle to holding the vote 20 days before the general election, when Christie’s on the ballot seeking a second term.

“They obviously think this is a matter of great public interest and they want to weigh in,” Peg Schaffer, chairwoman of the Somerset County Democratic Committee and the driving force behind the challenge to the special election, said in a phone interview.

* * *

Schaffer filed an emergency challenge to the special election date on June 7 as a four-way battle for the Democratic nomination for Senate began.

Thoughts on the TUSD Superintendent candidate

June 16, 2013

by David Safier

John Denker has a post below basically slammming H.T. Sanchez, the only finalist for the TUSD Superintendent position. It deserves a counter post. I come not to praise Sanchez, nor to bury him, but to give some perspective.

In my 30-plus years of teaching, I had about a half dozen superintendents. I never loved any of them (except maybe for one old guy who came to meetings in overalls and was an alcohol-is-sin Christian in his younger days, but by the time I knew him was making homemade wine. He was an alright superintendent, I guess, but I loved the fact a guy like that existed). I despised a few, liked a few and was neutral about some of the others, but I never loved the job any superintendent did, and I doubt I ever will. If Sanchez takes the helm at TUSD, I don't expect to love him either.

So the question is, will Sanchez be good enough to move TUSD in a generally positive direction? My answer is, I think he's likely to do as much good as any new superintendent and will probably succeed better than most.

Not Qualified to be TUSD Superintendent

June 16, 2013

As of 11 June 2013, H.T. Sánchez is the sole finalist in the search for a new Superintendent of TUSD. The Governing Board is soliciting comments. Executive Summary: Dr. Sánchez is nowhere near qualified to be superintendent. He would make a fine cheerleader, but we should not trust him with the job of quarterback. The … Read more

School Supply Giveaway – Tucson

June 16, 2013

Posted  by AzBlueMeanie: The new school year begins in mid-August for most Tucson area school districts, and this school supplies giveaway is the kind of positive community activism this community should encourage. Please make a $25 contribution at School Supply Giveaway (www.wepay.com) on Facebook. Information In response to the offensive and irresponsible effort to give … Read more

Democratic Women in Action August Luncheon

June 16, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie: Announcement from the Democratic Women In Action:

Voted Arizona’s Best Political Blog
by the Washington Post and Google’s FeedSpot

Arizona Insight Podcast

latest Event from thedgt.ORG

Upcoming community Events

Bluesky