U.S. and international testing, Part 3: The cases of Finland and Singapore
January 9, 2013
by
by David Safier
This is the third in a series of posts about the latest international test scores for reading, math and science. Here are the first and second posts.
The U.S. is in the top 6 to 10 countries in the world in reading, math and science, based on the most recent international tests. That's a pretty impressive performance for a large, multicultural country like ours with large pockets of poverty. If you pulled out the scores from students in the Northeast, for instance, we would fare much better, while students in most southern states fare much worse.
Interestingly, the darling of the previous round of tests, Finland, slipped a bit this testing cycle. It was number one across the board last time, and everyone was rushing to study an education system that topped most Asian countries but is reasonably laid back and has virtually no standardized testing. This time, Finland ended up in 3rd place in reading and science and came in at a surprisingly low 8th in math, statistically equal to the U.S. which was just 2 notches below.
What went wrong? Probably nothing. The recent math test, the TIMSS, had a different emphasis than the earlier PISA, which played into Finland's strengths. And the previous scores may simply represent the kind of deviation that happens from test to test. But as usual, people overreacted to Finland's earlier test performance. Their students still did very well — though it's hard to separate schooling from other societal factors — but they no longer retain their best-in-the-world status.
That honor goes to Singapore this year, which has the world's highest overall scores. So should we flock to Singapore and try to duplicate their educational success? Probably not. Singapore has the third highest per capita income in the world, about 2% unemployment, the largest percentage of millionaire households in the world — a mind-blowing 1 in 6 — and very little acute poverty. Singapore reports only about 10% of its schools have a majority of disadvantaged students. The U.S. estimate is over 50%. If the U.S. only tested the portion of our population that matched Singapore's, our scores would look a whole lot better.
Krugman: Rage Against the Coin
January 9, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Paul Krugman nails it again in his most recent blog post, Rage Against the Coin:
Well, the trillion-dollar-coin thing — deal with the debt ceiling by exploiting a legal loophole to have the Treasury mint one or more large-denomination coins, deposit them at the Fed, and use the cash in the new account to pay bills — has really taken off. Last month I spoke with a senior Fed official who had never heard of the idea; these days it’s all over.
There seem to be two kinds of objections. One is that it would be undignified. Here’s how to think about that: we have a situation in which a terrorist may be about to walk into a crowded room and threaten to blow up a bomb he’s holding. It turns out, however, that the Secret Service has figured out a way to disarm this maniac — a way that for some reason will require that the Secretary of the Treasury briefly wear a clown suit. (My fictional plotting skills have let me down, but there has to be some way to work this in). And the response of the nervous Nellies is, “My god, we can’t dress the secretary up as a clown!” Even when it will make him a hero who saves the day?
Diane Sawyer interview of Gabrielle Giffords and Mark Kelly
January 9, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
ABC News anchor Diane Sawyer interviewed former Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords and her husband Mark Kelly on the second anniversary of the tragredy in Tucson in which 19 people were shot and 6 killed by a madman with a gun.
Video below the fold.
Roxanna Green ad for demandaplan.org
January 9, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Roxanna Green's nine year-old daughter Christina-Taylor was killed at the Tucson shooting.
Watch her personal message asking leaders in Washington to offer a plan to end gun violence, and join her by signing our petition.
www.demandaplan.org (Mayors Against Illegal Guns)
Video below the fold.
What could possibly go wrong?
January 9, 2013
by
by David Safier Joe Arpaio wants to create a gun toting volunteer posse to hang out on the perimeters of school grounds and protect students from harm. Imagine the people who would answer Arpaio's call: wild-eyed or squinty-eyed wingnuts with their guns at the ready waiting for — hoping for — something to happen. They'll … Read more
The $1 trillion dollar coin solution to the federal debt ceiling crisis
January 8, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
"For every complex problem, there's a solution that is simple, neat, and wrong." – H.L. Mencken
Ronald Reagan epitomized the modern conservative movement's fixation with "simple solutions to complex problems." If it fit on a bumper sticker, all the better.
So it is only fitting that Ronald Reagan's image should appear on the $1 trillion dollar platinum coin that some are proposing as a simple solution to the Tea-Publican economic terrorists taking this country hostage over the federal debt ceiling and defaulting on the U.S. debt, in violation of the 14th Amendment to the Constitution, and causing another economic catastrophe.
Tea-Publicans have always wanted a Reagan coin. This would f#%king serve them right! (h/t graphic democratic underground.com)
Former Congressman Michael Castle accidentally enabled the weirdest possible solution to the debt ceiling. Michael Castle: Unsuspecting godfather of the $1 trillion coin solution:
As Brad Plumer explained last month, the Treasury secretary has the authority to mint platinum coins of any quantity and denomination. So, hypothetically, Tim Geithner could mint a $2 trillion coin, deposit it in the Treasury’s account at the Federal Reserve, and use that money in lieu of additional borrowing. Suddenly, no one needs to worry if Congress refuses to raise the debt ceiling.
U.S. and international testing, Part 2: “Countries” in U.S. perform very well
January 8, 2013
by
by David Safier
This is the second in a series of posts about the latest international test scores for reading, math and science. You can read the first post here.
The U.S. is a big, diverse country. Creating a national test score by averaging the results from 50 states doesn't tell the whole story. When we disaggregate the data by looking at states that have populations similar to small countries, we find that some of them do considerably better than the U.S. average, meaning others do considerably worse.
Massachusetts, Florida, North Carolina, Minnesota and a few other states agreed to have a large enough sample of students take some of the international tests that they could be scored as participating countries. Some of them did exceptionally well.
Massachusetts, for instance, participated separately in the 8th grade science exam and came in 2nd in the world, behind 1st place Singapore, scoring 42 points higher than the U.S. average.
In 4th grade reading, Florida came in 2nd, just 2 points behind 1st place Hong Kong and 14 points ahead of 6th place U.S. (It needs to be said that, since Florida holds back 3rd graders with low reading scores, its 4th grade average is probably a bit inflated.)
In 4th grade math, North Carolina came in 7th, 13 points above the 11th place U.S. In 8th grade math, Massachusetts came in 6th, scoring 52 points higher than the 9th place U.S., and Minnesota came in right behind Massachusetts, edging out the U.S. by 36 points.
Rep. Ron Barber statement on 2nd anniversary of the tragedy in Tucson
January 8, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie: Rep. Ron Barber (D-AZ), on the second anniversary of the tragedy in Tucson, issued this statement: Barber's full statement: We will never forget what happened on January 8th, 2011 – but I also know that our community was not then and will not now be defined by that act of violence. Tucson … Read more




