No, that’s not a typo. There really is a book titled “The Son Also Rises.” The author Gregory Clark, is an econ prof at UC Davis.
This book won’t be confused with Hemingway’s masterpiece of almost the same name. In The Son Also Rises, Clark shows how social mobility does not occur at anywhere near the rate we’ve come to believe. Rather, Clark demonstrates, it takes 10 or more generations, over 300 years, for an exceptional group to become average within a larger population.
I really enjoyed this one, but I wouldn’t go so far as to say it’s a great read. In all likelihood, you need to be a statistics geek like me to like this one.
But you have to admire Clark’s methodology.
What he was able to do is isolate on rare surnames as a way of measuring social mobility. For example, he counted the number of physicians in a country with a rare surname who outperformed (or underperformed) the general population. He would do this in 30 year intervals (the length of a generation) and compare, for each generation, the ratio of the frequency of physicians with that surname, to the frequency of the surname in the general population.
The results are startling, and amazingly consistent across time and cultures. And social policy seems to have little influence. Clark shows that there actually was as much or more mobility in medieval England as there is today in Sweden.
So, if Clark is correct, what then, in terms of policy? Essentially, Clark blows away the argument that we should focus on mobility rather than equality. Clark’s point is that there’s nothing much that can be done to influence mobility, and it takes a really long time for it to happen. Thus, the fairest approach is to focus on inequality. Makes sense. If those at the bottom really don’t have that much of a chance of moving to the top, the gap between the bottom and top needs to shrink.
I love it when smart people agree with me.
Discover more from Blog for Arizona
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
How does the measure of economic mobility figure into this? If we went from #3 in the world to #71 today doesn’t mobility matter?
The point is that mobility is mis-measured. What you basically have is two components to mobility from one generation to the next: an inherent component, and a random component. The random component can be very significant in the short-term, but over time it averages to zero. So, what you see is that if you look at mobility over multiple generations, there is the same inherent level of mobility, whether you’re looking at Sweden, the US, or China. If you’re interested, you should read the book. The research is fascinating.
Thanks. I’ll order it. I’m currently working through Pickett’s book Capitalism