[Cross-posted from Inequality.org]
Billionaire Bill Gates believes the charitable giving of the rich will alleviate inequality. Is he correct?
In a blog post not too long ago, Bill Gates criticized Thomas Piketty for not focusing enough on the role of philanthropy in alleviating inequality.
Noted Gates:
Philanthropy also can be an important part of the solution set. It’s too bad that Piketty devotes so little space to it. A century and a quarter ago, Andrew Carnegie was a lonely voice encouraging his wealthy peers to give back substantial portions of their wealth. Today, a growing number of very wealthy people are pledging to do just that. Philanthropy done well not only produces direct benefits for society, it also reduces dynastic wealth.
Gates — now the world’s wealthiest or second wealthiest person, depending on the week — has committed to leave the bulk of his wealth to charity.
It’s not clear exactly what Gates felt Piketty should have said. That we should address inequality by relying on the altruism of those who have accumulated — and continue to hold — wealth far beyond their conceivable needs and the conceivable needs of their next five generations of descendants? For all his widely acclaimed generosity, Gates himself still is sitting on over $80 billion in wealth.
Does the Bill Gates argument that philanthropy can save us from inequality have any merit? In a word: no. A recent Family Wealth Transfers Report from researchers at Wealth-X, a Singapore-based consultancy, and the NFP financial services company suggests just how misplaced Gates’ faith in the generosity of his peers happens to be.
The world’s ultra-wealthy — those with fortunes of $30 million or more — will pass $16 trillion in wealth at death over the next three decades, this new report projects. Only $300 billion of the total, less than 2 percent, will flow to charities. And a sizeable portion of those relatively stingy charitable transfers will undoubtedly flow to family foundations, from which the children of the ultra-wealthy will draw handsome salaries for deciding how to dribble out the income of those foundations to real charities.
The takeaways from this? First, philanthropy is not and never will be a solution to inequality. Second, we should be highly skeptical when a member of the plutocracy tells us how to address inequality.
Note to readers: The website inequality.org, where I previously posted full-length articles from time to time, has been reformatted to included a blog, where my colleagues at Institute for Policy Studies and I post shorter pieces, like this one. For those interested, I encourage you to check it out.
Discover more from Blog for Arizona
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Peter Buffet, a son of Warren and himself a philanthropist, wrote an OpEd about philanthropy relative to the solution to social problems. He titled it the “Charitable-Industrial Complex”. Here are some snips.
Philanthropy has become the “it” vehicle to level the playing field and has generated a growing number of gatherings, workshops and affinity groups.
As more lives and communities are destroyed by the system that creates vast amounts of wealth for the few, the more heroic it sounds to “give back.” It’s what I would call “conscience laundering” — feeling better about accumulating more than any one person could possibly need to live on by sprinkling a little around as an act of charity. …
But this just keeps the existing structure of inequality in place. The rich sleep better at night, while others get just enough to keep the pot from boiling over. Nearly every time someone feels better by doing good, on the other side of the world (or street), someone else is further locked into a system that will not allow the true flourishing of his or her nature or the opportunity to live a joyful and fulfilled life. …
And with more business-minded folks getting into the act, business principles are trumpeted as an important element to add to the philanthropic sector. I now hear people ask, “what’s the R.O.I.?” when it comes to alleviating human suffering, as if return on investment were the only measure of success. Microlending and financial literacy (now I’m going to upset people who are wonderful folks and a few dear friends) — what is this really about? People will certainly learn how to integrate into our system of debt and repayment with interest. People will rise above making $2 a day to enter our world of goods and services so they can buy more. But doesn’t all this just feed the beast? …
I’m really not calling for an end to capitalism; I’m calling for humanism.
Often I hear people say, “if only they had what we have” (clean water, access to health products and free markets, better education, safer living conditions). Yes, these are all important. But no “charitable” (I hate that word) intervention can solve any of these issues. It can only kick the can down the road.
Money should be spent trying out concepts that shatter current structures and systems that have turned much of the world into one vast market. Is progress really Wi-Fi on every street corner? No. It’s when no 13-year-old girl on the planet gets sold for sex. But as long as most folks are patting themselves on the back for charitable acts, we’ve got a perpetual poverty machine. Philanthropy has become the “it” vehicle to level the playing field and has generated a growing number of gatherings, workshops and affinity groups.
As more lives and communities are destroyed by the system that creates vast amounts of wealth for the few, the more heroic it sounds to “give back.” It’s what I would call “conscience laundering” — feeling better about accumulating more than any one person could possibly need to live on by sprinkling a little around as an act of charity.
But this just keeps the existing structure of inequality in place. The rich sleep better at night, while others get just enough to keep the pot from boiling over. Nearly every time someone feels better by doing good, on the other side of the world (or street), someone else is further locked into a system that will not allow the true flourishing of his or her nature or the opportunity to live a joyful and fulfilled life.
And with more business-minded folks getting into the act, business principles are trumpeted as an important element to add to the philanthropic sector. I now hear people ask, “what’s the R.O.I.?” when it comes to alleviating human suffering, as if return on investment were the only measure of success. Microlending and financial literacy (now I’m going to upset people who are wonderful folks and a few dear friends) — what is this really about? People will certainly learn how to integrate into our system of debt and repayment with interest. People will rise above making $2 a day to enter our world of goods and services so they can buy more. But doesn’t all this just feed the beast?
I’m really not calling for an end to capitalism; I’m calling for humanism.
Often I hear people say, “if only they had what we have” (clean water, access to health products and free markets, better education, safer living conditions). Yes, these are all important. But no “charitable” (I hate that word) intervention can solve any of these issues. It can only kick the can down the road.
Money should be spent trying out concepts that shatter current structures and systems that have turned much of the world into one vast market. Is progress really Wi-Fi on every street corner? No. It’s when no 13-year-old girl on the planet gets sold for sex. But as long as most folks are patting themselves on the back for charitable acts, we’ve got a perpetual poverty machine. (http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/27/opinion/the-charitable-industrial-complex.html)
I encourage readers of this blog to click on the link that Bob provided and read Bill Gates’ blog post yourselves. It is more nuanced than you might think. Bill Gates does not say that philanthropy is the answer to inequality, but he puts it into the positive column.
Bill Gates writes that he very much agrees with Thomas Piketty that:
◦High levels of inequality are a problem—messing up economic incentives, tilting democracies in favor of powerful interests, and undercutting the ideal that all people are created equal.
◦Capitalism does not self-correct toward greater equality—that is, excess wealth concentration can have a snowball effect if left unchecked.
◦Governments can play a constructive role in offsetting the snowballing tendencies if and when they choose to do so.
Bill Gates has traveled to China and India to meet with wealthy individuals to encourage them to pledge their fortunes to philanthropic causes. These are countries whose cultures don’t have strong philanthropic sectors.
Bill and Melinda Gates have pledged most of their estate to global aid for diseases and education. You will see in his post that Bill Gates supports taxing the estates of the wealthy.
Inequality is a central issue of our time. But what is wrong with seeing that philanthropy can be one part of the solution, though far from the entire solution.
I’ll try write a follow-up post. The reliance on philanthropy was not the only thing Gates got wrong.