It’s the poverty (inequality), Stupid!

education_appleOne of the “factoids” buried in the analysis of Dicey Doug Ducey’s budget this week is that the cost of providing “nonclassroom spending,” which includes “student support,” is due to the high rate of poverty in Arizona — the result of years of failed GOP economic policies in Arizona.

The Arizona Daily Star expands on this salient point in an editorial opinion today critical of of Dicey Doug Ducey’s budget. Gov.’s promise of increase for schools is disingenuous:

In the fiscal year 2016 budget, released Friday, almost all — $123 million — of Ducey’s classroom spending bonanza would come from a requirement that schools spend 5 percent less on “nonclassroom spending,” which includes administration, transportation, food service, plant operations, student support and instructional support.

Ducey would require local school districts to shift 5 percent of their taxpayer money from one pot to another. It’s a forced reallocation, not an increase.

His plan has the real potential to do harm by taking an outdated and limited view of what kids, especially poor kids, need to succeed in school. The student support part of the “non-classroom” category is a prime example.

As defined by the Arizona auditor general, which puts out the report on districts’ classroom spending, “student support” covers “health, psychological services, attendance and social work, guidance and other unspecified types of student support.”

Many of these services, and their expense, are directly connected to students who live at or below the poverty level.

In Arizona, particularly in Tucson, that applies to a lot of kids. According to figures from the U.S. Census Bureau, 1 in 4 Arizona children lives in a family with an income below the poverty level, which is about $18,000 per year for a family of three.

Those students face obstacles that directly affect their academic performance — hunger, frequent moves or homelessness, nowhere quiet to do homework or sleep, unstable family situations and exposure to drug or alcohol use.

Unfortunately, they are the ones with the most to lose under the 5 percent mandatory change. The state auditor found that, on average, districts with the “highest poverty rates spent $832 per pupil on student support services, $315 more per pupil than districts with the lowest poverty rates.”

Students with special needs also account for a large part of “nonclassroom spending.” For example, in fiscal year 2013, speech, audiology and other therapies accounted for 24 percent of such spending statewide.

Instructional support costs also are considered nonclassroom spending. And the picture is more complicated than it appears. Arizona reduced per-pupil spending by $317 between fiscal years 2008 and 2013. Because of the overall funding decrease, instruction support takes up a greater portion — 6 percent — of districts’ operating budgets.

Just this week it was reported that a Majority of U.S. public school students now in poverty:

For the first time in at least 50 years, a majority of U.S. public school students come from low-income families, according to a new analysis of 2013 federal data, a statistic that has profound implications for the nation.

The Southern Education Foundation reports that 51 percent of students in pre-kindergarten through 12th grade in the 2012-2013 school year were eligible for the federal program that provides free and reduced-price lunches. The lunch program is a rough proxy for poverty, but the explosion in the number of needy children in the nation’s public classrooms is a recent phenomenon that has been gaining attention among educators, public officials and researchers.

“We’ve all known this was the trend, that we would get to a majority, but it’s here sooner rather than later,” said Michael A. Rebell of the Campaign for Educational Equity at Teachers College at Columbia University, noting that the poverty rate has been increasing even as the economy has improved. “A lot of people at the top are doing much better, but the people at the bottom are not doing better at all. Those are the people who have the most children and send their children to public school.”

The shift to a majority-poor student population means that in public schools, a growing number of children start kindergarten already trailing their more privileged peers and rarely, if ever, catch up. They are less likely to have support at home, are less frequently exposed to enriching activities outside of school, and are more likely to drop out and never attend college.

It also means that education policy, funding decisions and classroom instruction must adapt to the needy children who arrive at school each day.

Screenshot from 2015-01-18 09:21:55

The job of teacher has expanded to “counselor, therapist, doctor, parent, attorney.”

Schools, already under intense pressure to deliver better test results and meet more rigorous standards, face the doubly difficult task of trying to raise the achievement of poor children so that they approach the same level as their more affluent peers.

“This is a watershed moment when you look at that map,” said Kent McGuire, president of the Southern Education Foundation, the nation’s oldest education philanthropy, referring to a large swath of the country filled with high-poverty schools.

“The fact is, we’ve had growing inequality in the country for many years,” he said. “It didn’t happen overnight, but it’s steadily been happening. Government used to be a source of leadership and innovation around issues of economic prosperity and upward mobility. Now we’re a country disinclined to invest in our young people.”

* * *

The new report raises questions among educators and officials about whether states and the federal government are devoting enough money — and using it effectively — to meet the complex needs of poor children.

The Obama administration wants Congress to add $1 billion to the $14.4 billion it spends annually to help states educate poor children. It also wants Congress to fund preschool for those from low-income families. Collectively, the states and the federal government spend about $500 billion annually on primary and secondary schools, about $79 billion of it from Washington.

The amount spent on each student can vary wildly from state to state. States with high student-poverty rates tend to spend less per student: Of the 27 states with the highest percentages of student poverty, all but five spent less than the national average of $10,938 per student.

Republicans in Congress have been wary of new spending programs, arguing that more money is not necessarily the answer and that federal dollars could be more effective if redundant programs were streamlined and more power was given to states.

Many Republicans also think that the government ought to give tax dollars to low-income families to use as vouchers for private-school tuition, believing that is a better alternative to public schools.

GOP leaders in Congress have rebuffed President Obama’s calls to fund preschool for low-income families, although a number of Republican and Democratic governors have initiated state programs in the past several years.

The report comes as Congress begins debate about rewriting the country’s main federal education law, first passed as part of President Lyndon B. Johnson’s “War on Poverty” and designed to help states educate poor children. The most recent version of the law, known as No Child Left Behind, has emphasized accountability and outcomes, measuring whether schools met benchmarks and sanctioning them when they fell short.

* * *

“We have to think about how to give these kids a meaningful education,” Rebell said. “We have to give them quality teachers, small class sizes, up-to-date equipment. But in addition, if we’re serious, we have to do things that overcome the damages­ of poverty. We have to meet their health needs, their mental health needs, after-school programs, summer programs, parent engagement, early-childhood services. These are the so-called wraparound services. Some people think of them as add-ons. They’re not. They’re imperative.”

So much for our commitment to “I believe the children are our future, Teach them well and let them lead the way, Show them all the beauty they possess inside, Give them a sense of pride to make it easier . . .” – The Greatest Love of All.


Discover more from Blog for Arizona

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.