Matt Yglesias writing at Vox.com makes an argument that I have been making for years: Americans don’t have a constitutional right to vote — it’s time for that to change (excerpt);
When the Constitution was enacted, it did not include a right to vote for the simple reason that the Founders didn’t think most people should vote. Voting laws, at the time, mostly favored white, male property-holders, and the rules varied sharply from state to state. But in the first half of the nineteenth century, the idea of popular democracy took root across the land. Property qualifications were universally abolished and the franchise became the key marker of white male political equality. Subsequent activists sought to further expand the franchise by barring discrimination on the basis of race (the 15th Amendment) and gender (the 19th Amendment) — establishing the norm that all citizens should have the right to vote.
But this norm is just a norm. There is no actual constitutional provision stating that all citizens have the right to vote, only that voting rights cannot be dispensed on the basis of race or gender discrimination. A law requiring you to cut your hair short before voting, or to dye it blue, or to say “pretty please let me vote,” all might pass muster. And so might a voter ID requirement.
The legality of these kinds of laws hinge on whether they violate the Constitution’s protections against race and gender discrimination, not on whether they prevent citizens from voting. As Harvard Law professor Lani Guinier has written, this “leaves one of the fundamental elements of democratic citizenship tethered to the whims of local officials.”
The solution, both to America’s voting access problem and to alleviating public concerns about fraud, is to establish an affirmative right to vote.
America prohibits racial and gender discrimination in voting rights because of a clear belief in the importance of voting to equal citizenship. The best way to vindicate this right would be through something like the language of a proposed constitutional amendment introduced last year by Reps. Mark Pocan and Keith Ellison, which states that “every citizen of the United States, who is of legal voting age, shall have the fundamental right to vote in any public election held in the jurisdiction in which the citizen resides.”
A constitutional right to vote would instantly flip the script on anti-fraud efforts. States would retain a strong interest in developing rules and procedures that make it hard for ineligible voters to vote, but those efforts would be bounded by an ironclad constitutional guarantee that legitimate citizens’ votes must be counted. A state that wanted to require possession of a certain ID card to vote, for example, would have to take affirmative steps to ensure that everyone has that ID card, or that there’s a process for an ID-less citizen to cast a ballot and have it counted later upon verification of citizenship.
* * *
But beyond the politics, it’s a good idea on the merits. It would enshrine in our Constitution a principle that we already believe: that the right to vote is an inherent attribute of citizenship and a cornerstone of civic equality.
Steve Benen comments in Adding the right to vote to the Constitution:
The Pocan/Ellison proposal would stipulate that “every citizen of the United States, who is of legal voting age, shall have the fundamental right to vote in any public election held in the jurisdiction in which the citizen resides.”
The proposed amendment did not exactly catch fire on Capitol Hill: after its introduction, the proposal picked up 25 Democratic co-sponsors; en route to being entirely ignored by the political establishment and the House Republican leadership. There’s still no companion bill in the Senate.
I would assume that Pocan and Ellison aren’t surprised by the reception, but as the “war on voting” intensifies, and the Supreme Court’s support for voting rights wanes further, it’s not hard to imagine the demand for their measure growing.
Indeed, a year ago, Norm Ornstein, one of the Beltway’s most respected political scientists, made the case for precisely this kind of constitutional amendment.
We need a modernized voter-registration system, weekend elections, and a host of other practices to make voting easier. But we also need to focus on an even more audacious and broader effort – a constitutional amendment protecting the right to vote…. [T]he lack of an explicit right opens the door to the courts’ ratifying the sweeping kinds of voter-restrictions and voter-suppression tactics that are becoming depressingly common.
An explicit constitutional right to vote would give traction to individual Americans who are facing these tactics, and to legal cases challenging restrictive laws. The courts have up to now said that the concern about voter fraud – largely manufactured and exaggerated – provides an opening for severe restrictions on voting by many groups of Americans. That balance would have to shift in the face of an explicit right to vote. Finally, a major national debate on this issue would alert and educate voters to the twin realities: There is no right to vote in the Constitution, and many political actors are trying to take away what should be that right from many millions of Americans.
* * *
I’m generally skeptical of proposed changes to the Constitution, but that skepticism wanes in the face of a sweeping voter-suppression campaign, unlike anything in my lifetime, that shows no signs of abating.
Don’t be surprised if, in the near future, candidates for Congress and the White House are confronted with a simple question: is it time to add the right to vote to the Constitution?
While Amending the U.S. Constitution may be a bridge too far in the current politically polarized climate, amending the Arizona Constitution, by citizen initiative if necessary, is much more doable. And since elections are run by the states, this fundamental constitutional right in the Arizona Constitution would afford more protection. It’s time to put this amendment on the 2016 ballot.
Discover more from Blog for Arizona
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Canada explicitly added the right to vote to their Constitution in 1982. The United States should do the same. I’d like to see this introduced in the House, the Senate, and every state legislature in the nation, and then just see who votes against it, so they can be soundly ridiculed.
(The wording in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, section 3, is “Every citizen of Canada has the right to vote in an election of members of the House of Commons or of a legislative assembly [of a province or territory] and to be qualified for membership therein.”)
What this did, specifically, was to strip the power of voting regulation from the individual Provinces. I suppose that is a good idea for Canadians, but I wouldn’t want to see it here.
Uhhh, no, it didn’t. I have no idea to what you’re referring. I don’t know the entire history, but certainly for decades before the 1982 Constitution, voting eligibility was either identical between the provinces, territories, and federal elections, or was damn close. Right now, and since certainly the 1970s, it’s Canadian citizen, 18 years of age or older, period. Changed from 21, not sure when, probably around the same time as the US changed. Used to be that “British subjects resident in Canada” could vote; I knew a guy who was from one of the West Indies countries that were part of the Commonwealth, but lived in Canada, and he was able to vote for a while, until they got rid of that provision. Other than that, the most recent “big” change in voting eligibility was in 1940 when Quebec FINALLY gave women the vote (most of the rest of the country had done so by 1925 or so).
Good luck with a Constitutional Amendment! There are only two ways to do it: (1) If requested by 2/3 positive vote of the individual States, Congress must form a Constitutional Convention to draw up an Amendment, or (2) Have Congress pass, by a 2/3 positive vote of both Houses, an Amendment. By either method, the Amendment is then sent to the individual State Legislatures for a yes/no vote. If 3/4 of the states approve the Amendment the Constitution is amended.
Neither one has a chance of occurring, especially for a right to vote as defined by Democrats. It’s fun to talk about, but it is a dream to expect it.
Exactly what is a right to vote as defined by Democrats, defined as?
Oh Cheri, do we really have to play this game? I will base my answer strictly on what I have read here over the last three months.
The right to vote as defined by Democrats means that a person can present his or her self to vote without ever proving they are who they say they are. No proof of identity is necessary. No questions are ever asked and no suspicions are entertained. The only thing that counts is showing up to vote.
Oh yes..as opposed to this?
http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/political-animal-a/2014_10/suppressing_votes_just_a_day_a052596.php
Honest to god…pull off the blinders.
That is one interpretation of what Christie said. There is another, more likely, interpretation: If Democrat Governors control the process, cheating at the polls is very likely to occur. Democrats have a long history of cheating in elections and there is no reason to assume that won’t continue. Remember, the phrase “Vote early, vote often” is of Democrat origin.
Apart from the obvious problem of “what do you do about people who vote by mail?”, I’m tempted to say we should use a system that’s used in many less-developed countries during their elections, and that is to have every voter dip their thumb into indelible ink when they vote. If your thumb is purple, you’ve already voted, you can’t vote again.
Also, the US should consider what Canada’s done for voter registration. Used to be in Canada that every few years before an expected election, you’d have a bunch of people going door-to-door, just like a census, to register voters. In the 1990s, they took the most recent list and used it to create the National Register of Electors. Now, whenever you get or renew a driver’s licence or official provincial/territorial ID, or whenever you file your income taxes, or when someone is naturalized as a Canadian citizen, you’re asked if you want the information sent on to Elections Canada to update the register. Most people tick the tickybox, obviously. They also get death records from provincial/territorial Vital Statistics agencies, for example. Well over 90% of Canadian are registered to vote, and there have never been any serious founded allegations of voter fraud in I-don’t-know-how-long. Damn shame that so many Americans (esp. Republicans lately) seem so hell-bent on making it as hard for some people to register and vote as possible.
I don’t see mail in ballots as a problem because you must prove you are who you say you are before you can sign up for them. I would like to see some sort of mechanism in force so that if a person dies, their name is expunged from the voter rolls within 90 days of filing their “end of life” tax forms.
The idea of dipping your finger in ink is an effective way to prevent double voting, but Americans would never stand for it.
The Canadian system of voter registration and control is pretty decent except for one thing: It strips power away from the individuals states. If our Constitution was amended in accordance with Article V, to emulate the Canadian method, I would have to live with it. I wouldn’t be happy about it because it would strip power from the states, but it would be the law of the land.
As an aside, the Confederation of Canada also allows individual Provinces to withdraw from the Confederation by a simple majority vote, something we can’t do here. The Civil War settled that issue rather effectively. In this case, Canada allows it’s Provinces the ultimate power, and our central Goverment stripped that away more than century ago.
Anyway, thank you for a thoughtful and well written posting.
First of all, Christie is wrong — it is secretaries of state who control the “voting mechanism” in most states. Governors do not. Second of all, your ready assumption that if a Democrat is in charge there is cheating going on is unsupported by anything but your partisan bias. Citing something from a century ago does not support your argument. All of the problems with voting in the 21st Century have been with Republican secretaries of state, from Katherine Harris (Florida), to Ken Blackwell (Ohio), to Jon Husted (Ohio), etc. In more than 20 years of handling election law matters, I have never seen anything that can compare to the systematic attempt to limit the right to vote by the GOP, your fantasies notwithstanding.
I know, it’s such a radical concept to understand (for Republicans). If you’re a US citizen, you have the right to vote. Just think of how that could be manipulated by evildoers!
I agree with you completely! A U.S. citizen has the right to vote. The difference is that I think they have an obligation to prove they are who they say they are. A picture ID is easy to get. Show the picture ID and vote. It’s that simple…
A picture ID could well work like a poll tax and limit the ability to vote, if only because some people would have major barriers to cross to get picture ID. Typically those who are going to have barriers to obtaining ID will also be those at the bottom of the socioeconomic ladder.
Ultimately, there have to be other methods to control ballot stuffing that wouldn’t lead to the possibility of disenfranchisement. Perhaps an ID card that was valid only for voting and not tied to state ID or a drivers license?