Will Montana’s challenge to Citizens United v. FEC get a hearing before SCOTUS?
February 17, 2012
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Update to Montana Supreme Court takes a defiant stand against Citizens United v. FEC :
[B]y a 5-2 margin, Montana’s high court determined that the state law survived “strict scrutiny” because Montana’s unique context and history justified the ban in ways not contemplated by Citizens United. In his majority opinion, Chief Justice Mike McGrath dove deep into that history, ranging back over the “tumultuous years … marked by rough contests for political and economic domination primarily in the mining center of Butte, between mining and industrial enterprises controlled by foreign trusts or corporations.” Noting that, back in the last Gilded Age, Montana's wealthy "Copper Kings" bought judges and senators, picked the location of the capital, and owned the media, McGrath pointed to Montana’s vast size, sparse population, low-cost elections, and long history of having its resources plundered by foreign corporate interests to emphasize that the state has a compelling interest in maintaining its ban.
McGrath lays it out this way: “The question then, is when in the last 99 years did Montana lose the power or interest sufficient to support the statute, if it ever did. If the statute has worked to preserve a degree of political and social autonomy is the State required to throw away its protections?” The majority went out of its way to note that unlimited campaign spending on judicial elections is also having a profoundly damaging effect on judicial integrity all around the country.
Three corporations have now filed a petition to the U.S. Supreme Court asking it to strike down, without further briefing and oral argument, the state law on the premise that the Montana Supreme Court in upholding it simply failed to follow the Court’s 2010 ruling in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, freeing corporations (and labor unions) to spend their own money as they wished on political campaigns.
Justice Anthony M. Kennedy has the petition. He has the authority to act on his own on the stay issue, but would have to share with his colleagues any consideration of summarily overturning the state court’s decision; that would take five votes.
Reminder: Raúl Grijalva Campaign Kickoff on Sunday
February 17, 2012
Posted by AzBlueMeanie: Announcement from the Raúl Grijalva for Congress campaign: A WHOLE LOT OF PEOPLE FOR GRIJALVA PRESENT 2012 CAMPAIGN KICKOFF Live Music by Los Gallegos Sunday, February 19, 2012 5:30 pm – 8:30 pm El Casino Ballroom 437 East 26th Street Tucson, AZ 85713 Please RSVP Today Raúl needs you to stand with … Read more
Arizona Democratic Presidential Preference Caucus
February 17, 2012
Posted by AzBlueMeanie: Announcement from the Arizona Democratic Party: On March 31, 2012, Democrats will gather to initiate Arizona's first step in a presidential election. The Arizona Democratic Presidential Preference Caucus will be held for each congressional district in locations outlined below. Each state that's had either a primary or caucus to date has used … Read more
Paul Ryan forces staff to read works of Russian atheist
February 17, 2012
by
by David Safier Frankly, I am shocked to hear that Congressman Paul Ryan, who calls himself a conservative Republican and is the author of the Republican House budget plan, makes his staff read books by Alisa Zinov'yevna Rosenbaum. She was born in Russia, then came to this country and used fiction to twist people's minds … Read more
Yet another destructive bill from the Goldwater Institute
February 17, 2012
Posted by AzBlueMeanie: The Goldwater Institute has been the single most destructive influence in Arizona politics since its founding. It produces more "bad government" ideas, in partnership with affiliated partners like ALEC, than any other organization in Arizona. It's goal is not good governance but to destroy government. The latest "bad government" idea comes from … Read more
The Arizona Legislature: Tackling the really important issues
February 17, 2012
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Every year our Arizona legislature wastes an ungodly amount of time on trivial bills that matter only to a lobbyist, or a small number of people, or an individual who has the ear of a legislator. Committee chairmen have the ability to make these bills disappear, but sometimes they are the sponsors, or they owe a legislator a favor, or they owe a lobbyist for those sweet campaign contributions.
Just this week the legislature has wasted time on this Arizona bill takes aim at airbrushed women in ads:
House Bill 2793, proposed by Rep. Katie Hobbs, D-Phoenix, would require advertisers who alter or enhance a photo to put a disclaimer on that ad alerting customers that "Postproduction techniques were made to alter the appearance in this advertisement. When using this product, similar results may not be achieved."
The bill has little to no chance of success. But Hobbs said that's OK.
"We just wanted to bring it to the table and start a discussion," she said. "We need to bring attention to these body-image issues, especially with young girls. Girls need to know that they don't have to look perfect."
Arizona appears to be the first state in the nation to consider such a bill.
I'll bet it is. I have just one question: Will this bill apply to the heavily retouched air-brushed photo that Jan Brewer has been using since 2010 to make her look 30 years younger? Because that photo is seriously misleading. Embrace your age, Jan.
And there is this bill sponsored by "Fast Eddy" Farnsworth on behalf of a teabagger whiner who wants to engage in electioneering inside her polling location. Arizona bill would allow political apparel at polls:
A state House committee has approved a bill overturning a ban on political apparel and other materials such as buttons and signs within 75 feet of polling places.
State law considers any display of support or opposition for a candidate, ballot proposal or political party to be electioneering, which is prohibited. Civil liberties organizations have complained it violates First Amendment Rights.
And they are what I like to call "wrong."
In Case You Missed It: Martha McSally To Attend Drinking Liberally Tucson This Sunday
February 17, 2012
Posted by Michael Bryan
At Drinking Liberally we love a good argument. Not the shouting, ranting non-sense that often passes for political dialogue these days, but respectful, challenging, and meaningful discussion of political and philosophical differences.
Republican politicos have joined the liberals at Drinking Liberally for such discussions in the past: Frank Antenori, Vic Williams, Jon Paton, Ray Carroll, and several others have been guests at Tucson's Drinking Liberally.
Martha McSally will be joining that list of conservatives this Sunday at the Shanty starting at 6pm. Martha has recently thrown her hat in the ring for both the CD8 specials and CD8 regular elections. Whether you're a D, a R, or an I, come on down, meet the candidate, discuss the issues, and share a drink.
Click through for more about Martha McSally…




