Brewer’s “Performance Funding” plan: How to make it more equitable

January 27, 2013

by David Safier

The Performance Funding plan proposed in Brewer's budget is inherently inequitable, rewarding every school with high income students with significant extra funding while making it far more difficult for schools with low income students to receive a similar cash award. I described the inequities in two earlier posts — the first going over the theory and the second using three different schools as examples demonstrating the basic inequity of Brewer's Performance Funding system.

Personally, I don't like the concept of Performance Funding. It punishes schools with low achievement scores by lowering their funding instead of helping them to be more successful by offering expert help coupled with extra funding. (In most industrialized nations, lower performing schools are given extra resources to help them improve.) But if Arizona decides to go with some form of Performance Funding, Brewer's model needs to be changed to eliminate its inherent bias against schools with low income students.

Here's one possible Performance Funding model that would minimize or eliminate the inequities:

  1. Set an equalized base funding for all schools that will meet the educational needs of their students. Performance Funding should not be a "rob Peter to pay Paul" system where necessary funding is taken away from one school and given to another.
  2. Give extra funding to schools that exceed the reasonable expectations for student achievement, factoring in the family income of the students.
  3. Give extra funding to schools that show improvement over their previous years' student achievement.

Part 1 — giving all schools a reasonable base funding — makes sense to anyone who isn't a punish-the-poor, end-public-schooling-as-we-know-it conservative, so it needs no further explanation. Part 3 is essentially a continuation of the improvement component of Brewer's proposed formula, so it's not really a change. Part 2, however, is significantly different from Brewer's proposed formula and needs to be defined and explained.

Steller: Deseg order is bad for TUSD because . . . Why, exactly?

January 27, 2013

by David Safier

I'm confused. I've read Tim Steller's column, Deseg order is holding TUSD back, a few times this morning, trying to figure out how the deseg order is holding TUSD back. For the life of me, I can't find the proof, or even much in the way of persuasive arguments.

Let's see. TUSD gets an extra $60 million a year because it's under the deseg court order. That's bad because . . . Why, exactly?

TUSD has lost 16% of its enrollment over the past 10 years. It's more Hispanic now, and its students are poorer. Did the deseg order chase students away and bring down the size of TUSD's more affluent Anglo population, or is that a demographic trend that's happening in urban districts across the nation? If Steller showed something like causation, it might be an important point, but all he does is say the changes happened while the deseg order was in effect. I'm sure we have more Walmarts in the Tucson area than we did 10 years ago, but that doesn't mean Walmart has caused changes in the District's student population. Correlation and causation are two very different animals.

NY Times: What We Don’t Know Is Killing Us

January 27, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

The New York Times in an editorial opinion today makes the point that What We Don’t Know Is Killing Us:

In one of the 23 executive orders on gun control signed this month, President Obama instructed the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and other federal science agencies to conduct research into the causes and prevention of gun violence. He called on Congress to aid that effort by providing $10 million for the C.D.C. in the next budget round and $20 million to expand the federal reporting system on violent deaths to all 50 states, from the current 18.

That Mr. Obama had to make such a decree at all is a measure of the power of the gun lobby, which has effectively shut down government-financed research on gun violence for 17 years. Research on guns is crucial to any long-term effort to reduce death from guns. In other words, treat gun violence as a public health issue.

But that is precisely what the National Rifle Association and other opponents of firearms regulation do not want. In the absence of reliable data and data-driven policy recommendations, talk about guns inevitably lurches into the unknown, allowing abstractions, propaganda and ideology to fill the void and thwart change.

Paranoid gun worshipers jeopardizing public health

January 27, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie:

Ask any cop or medical professional and they will tell you that gun violence is a health care epidemic in this country. And it is not just suicides, accidental shootings and intentional shootings, but the use of guns to threaten and intimidate in cases of domestic violence, and other instances of assault and battery.

The NRA convinced members of Congress to prohibit any federally funded research into gun violence as a health care issue back in the 1990s. Willful ignorance allows the NRA and the weapons manufacturers it represents in Congress to argue in the abstract because they have prevented the collection of any hard scientific data for this health care epidemic. It is easy to argue that "there is no evidence" when one has prevented scientific research into the empirical evidence.

When President Obama announced his gun violence policies recently Gun Violence Fact Sheet (.pdf), it included this provision:

PRESERVE THE RIGHTS OF DOCTORS TO PROTECT THEIR PATIENTS AND COMMUNITIES FROM GUN VIOLENCE: Doctors and other mental health professionals play an important role in protecting the safety of their patients and the broader community. The administration is clarifying that no federal law in any way prohibits doctors or other health care providers from reporting their patients' threats of violence to the authorities, and issuing guidance making clear that the Affordable Care Act does not prevent doctors from talking to patients about gun safety.

3rd Annual Celebration of International Women’s Day

January 27, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie: Announcement from CWA Local 7000:

Cochise County Democratic Party 2013 Annual High Desert Dinner

January 27, 2013

Posted by AzBlueMeanie: Announcement from the Cochise County Democratic Party:

Saguaro Eastside Democrats 9th Annual ‘I Love Liberty’ Party

January 27, 2013

Posted  by AzBlueMeanie: Announcement from the Saguaro Eastside Democrats. For more information please contact Steve Gall at stevejgall@hotmail.com or (520) 777-3000.

Tom Harkin Retires

January 26, 2013

Posted by Bob Lord Huff Po is reporting that Tom Harkin has announced he will not seek re-election in 2014. His decision certainly is understandable, as he'd be over 80 at the conclusion of another term if he served one. He felt is was someone else's turn. It's too bad Senator McCrankypants here doesn't share Harkin's perspective. … Read more

Voted Arizona’s Best Political Blog
by the Washington Post and Google’s FeedSpot

Arizona Insight Podcast

latest Event from thedgt.ORG

Upcoming community Events

Bluesky

Last updated 10 minutes ago