Tea-Publicans in the Arizona legislature are willing to settle for a scaled-down school vouchers bill this year — oh, excuuuse me! An “empowerment scholarship accounts” bill — but rest assured, unless you elect Fred DuVal governor and elect more Democrats to the legislature this fall, the “Kochtopus Death Star,” the Goldwater Institute, and its school privatization storm troopers will be back next year to finish the job. Senate votes to expand voucher-like program for private school tuition:
On a voice vote Wednesday the Senate approved legislation to expand the voucher-like program, now geared for only certain students, to all children living in zip codes where the average household income is below 185 percent of the federal poverty level for a family of four. That currently computes out to $44,122 a year.
SB 1236, which still requires a final roll-call vote, does not make that an income limit for individual families. And Sen. Kimberly Yee, R-Phoenix, said those who earn much more also would qualify for the state-paid tuition as long as the average income of their neighbors, as defined by postal zip codes, is below that figure.
The original measure would have included all children who meet economic eligibility requirements for free or reduced-price lunch programs, which also is capped off at 185 percent of the federal poverty level. But Yee said that drew objections from officials at the Department of Education because it would have required them to get income data from individual families, data that now is not shared with the state.
Yee said the eligible areas are largely concentrated in south Tucson and Phoenix but said there are some other areas scattered throughout the state.
Rep. Debbie Lesko, R-Peoria, who is sponsoring the identical measure in the House, said far more children would have qualified using that individual test. Lesko, whose version is set for a House vote Thursday, said she believes the new scaled-back version will prove more politically acceptable.
* * *
Sen. Olivia Cajero Bedford, D-Tucson, said “I believe the goal is to eventually expand the program to the state’s more than one million public and charter school children,” she said. Cajero Bedford said the result will be diverting “desperately needed money” away from public schools.
Yee said that can’t happen, at least not under current laws. She pointed out that the program limits year-over-year increases in vouchers to one-half of 1 percent of students in public schools, a figure she put at about 5,400.
But that annual cap on what are called “empowerment scholarship accounts” goes away in 2020. And lawmakers always can repeal it before then.
They also remain free to make further eligibility expansions above and beyond the zip code income limits being approved this year.
Lesko has made no secret that she wants a much larger program, available to far more children. In fact she had crafted — and attempted to pass — a version that contained eligibility caps that would have opened the voucher program to about 850,000 of the 1.1 million youngsters now in public schools.
And those income limits would have increased annually to the point that every student in the state would be eligible for a voucher.
* * *
Senate Minority Leader Anna Tovar, D-Tolleson, said it makes no sense to expand the program until there is some hard and fast data to determine if it is a wise use of tax dollars.
“Where is the academic accountability?” she asked. Students who get the vouchers are not required to take the same standardized tests as those in public schools.
“How can we measure the program’s effectiveness if we have no yardstick?” Tovar asked.
The state of Arizona cannot even properly audit and account for the money being spent on the much smaller ESA program now. Department of Education says ESA spreadsheet contained errors:
An Arizona Department of Education spreadsheet showing millions in unspent funds in empowerment scholarship accounts contained a substantial number of errors, a department spokeswoman said Wednesday.
The spreadsheet was the basis of an Arizona Capitol Times story published online on Tuesday, headlined, “Millions remain unspent in school choice program.’’
Jennifer Liewer, a Department of Education spokeswoman, said it has confirmed the essence of the story – that many students have not spent all of their disbursements and have built significant carryovers. But she said many of the specifics of the spreadsheet have turned out to be inaccurate.
“The data was wrong,” she said.
She said the problem stems from an antiquated data system that required the manual transfer of data into the spreadsheet.
Liewer said the way the data system is programmed doesn’t allow for analysis.
“We look at every case, we audit every quarter by hand,” she said.
The department realized the spreadsheet was incorrect when a staffer went back to check the numbers after a Capitol Times reporter questioned why dozens of students appeared to have overspent their accounts, some by thousands of dollars.
The spreadsheet also indicated that parents with empowerment scholarship accounts have amassed roughly $2.5 million of unspent public money over three years.
The spreadsheet had been created at the request of Sen. Anna Tovar and showed how much had been disbursed to 1,495 students over the three years of the program. Tovar, who cited figures on the spreadsheet on the floor of the Senate as she argued against a bill that expands the program, said it took seven weeks for her to receive the spreadsheet.
“This underscores the need for stricter oversight and accountability,” Tovar said in a text message. “If that had been happening all along, we wouldn’t have to wait seven weeks for an inaccurate report.”
Parents are supposed to be audited and cannot spend the money on whatever they please, nor hang on to the money indefinitely. But every unspent dollar means public money earmarked for education is not being spent on education.
This ESA scam is starting to reek of the smell of the Alt-Fuels Scandal back in 2000, remember that?
The 2000 law was supposed to cost the state $10 million, but in the end costs topped $200 million.
The program gave tax breaks of up to $18,000 to Arizonans who bought an alternative-fuel vehicle.
But drivers were only required to have a few gallons of natural gas in a supplemental tank to get the windfall.
In the end, much of the money went to buy new SUVs that rarely ever ran on the propane.
Lawmakers who supported the bill later admitted they hadn’t actually read it.
The scandal cost House Speaker Jeff Groscost his job in the next election.
Why wait until scandal metastasizes? Sen. Kimberly Yee, R-Phoenix and Rep. Debbie Lesko, R-Peoria should be booted out of the legislature for this ESA scam. All of the Goldwater Institute school privatization storm troopers should be booted out of the Arizona legislature.
Discover more from Blog for Arizona
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
For the most part Special Education students receive better services in public schools, and have more opportunities to interact with mainstream students. After 20 years of charters and “choice,” the public education system in AZ has not made significant gains in student achievement. Charters and vouchers are false choices for quality education and a good way to waste money that should go to public schools.
I sure hope there are challengers for Yee and Lesko.
Don’t be silly. After three years, less than three of the 210 thousand students eligible are on the program. You don’t even need a cap.
Most of these are special ed students. The most difficult students to teach. In other states these parents go out and hire a lawyer and sue the beJesus out of their school district. In Arizona, they apply for a scholarship.
Pennsylvania districts had 65 level one special ed lawsuits. Arizona districts had two last year and none so far this year.
Since Az began school choice in 1993, our regular public schools have expanded by 280,000 students, 45%, second highest in the nation.
Not exactly withered. By comparison, Wyoming went from 89,000 in 93 to 80,000 today. That’s withering.
The problems with the one party dictatorship legislature are too numerous to mention. They should just finish the budget in the first month and go home. All other activities are nuisances at the least and total destruction of the State at the worst. The longer the Session the more destruction they do. Lesko is heading toward the worst, because she is a total lapdog of ALEC. Do any of the crazies actually represent anyone in their districts? They just seem to be lapdogs of extreme special interests. They don’t seem to. No citizen or school district is safe while the legislature is in session. Where are the Burton Barr’s of this State today?
I have told the legislators this will be the new alt fuels fiasco. The one party dictatorship in the legislature does not care. They don’t care if the program has any actual academic impact. It’s ideology and hatred of public school teachers, pure and simple, and tax subsidies and gifts to private schools and for profits.