Tammy and I took our two youngest to see Selma last night.
I had wanted to go Friday night, but Tammy was concerned about having to fight the crowds on opening night.
Turned out I was right. The theatre was 12% full for a 7:00 p.m. Saturday showing. I asked the cashier how crowded it was on opening night and she said about the same. The reports on box office receipts confirm that national ticket sales thus far are underwhelming.
That’s not to say the film itself was underwhelming. Indeed, it was one of the best I’ve seen; fantastic casting, exceptional acting, and superb content.
This is a movie that any responsible parent with the financial means should be taking a child between the ages of 12 and 18 to see, and one that any other adult should have the intellectual curiosity to attend.
Selma stirred many thoughts for me. I’ll focus on two of them. First, there was the ugliness of white Southerners, an ugliness that is alive and well today. There’s a logical explanation why the white South appeared so unified in its ugliness. If you speak to someone who left the Old South or had a parent who did, you’re likely to hear that there was pressure in the white community to take part in the ugliness. If that was distasteful, you could speak up, which would be brave, but suicidal, or you could leave, which many chose to do. The white population that remained, therefore, was disproportionately racist. This same phenomenon, by the way, may be taking place in Israel today, as the country’s rabid racism causes left-leaning Israelis to seek saner domiciles.
Second, it occurred to me how relatively easy it is to connect the dots from Selma in 1965 to Ferguson, New York, and other aspects of America today, such as voter ID laws and our huge and disproportionately black prison population. In this regard, it’s stunning how quickly the momentum of the civil rights era was reversed and the advances largely neutralized.
George Wallace, a Democrat and then Governor of Alabama, was one of the villains in the Selma story. If the movie is at all accurate, the enmity between him and Lyndon Johnson was intense. So, just three years later, Wallace runs as a third-party candidate in the 1968 presidential election, a move that obviously benefitted the Republicans and Nixon. Hubert Humphrey, the 1968 Democratic candidate (and Johnson’s VP) had been one of the first white Democrats to get on board the civil rights movement.
And so commenced the Republicans’ southern strategy.
After a brief pause induced by Watergate, the transformation lurched forward in 1980, when Reagan opened his campaign in Philadelphia, Mississippi, infamous for the murders of three young civil rights workers, with a speech focused on states rights, a dog whistle of historic proportion.
From there, we moved to “welfare queens”, “strapping young bucks”, and Willie Horton.
Then there was welfare reform.
And over the years, the Supreme Court shifted dramatically. Just as the Supreme Court of the late 1800’s was complicit in the reversal of post-Civil War advances, today’s Supreme Court has been complicit in the reversal the advances of the civil rights movement, particularly the Voting Rights Act. And the vehicle through which the Supreme Court has delivered those reversals? Essentially, “states rights.” Yep, what Reagan promised in Philadelphia, Mississippi the Supreme Court ultimately delivered, with Reagan’s appointee, Antonin Scalia, leading the charge.
So here we are today. Black wealth is at its lowest level in decades. Blacks are harassed on the streets of our cities. Black voting power is diluted through a combination of felony convictions, voter ID laws, and gerrymandering. And each and every U.S. Senate seat in the South is in Republican hands, creating an all-powerful voting block entirely beholden to a racist white population.
I wonder. Maybe this is what the majority of White America wants. Which would explain why interest in Selma is so low.
Discover more from Blog for Arizona
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
I saw the movie Friday and it was like time hasn’t moved in 50 years. I really thought the movie was well done.
If you genuinely believe that nothing has changed since the march on Selma, then you are living in a fantasy world, or you are very young and have no memory of what it was like back then. Things have changed for the better IMMENSELY since then. There is still more that can be done, but a lot of progress has been made.
The screenwriter and director of the film both stated that they tried to make the film as historically correct as they could, but much of the source material, including all of Dr. King’s speech’s, are owned by Steven Spielberg, and he refused to let them use it. That could mean Spielburg untends to do a film in the future…who knows. But you should be careful taking it as accurate history. Having said that, I think they did a credible and realistic job portraying an important part of modern history.
As to the disproportionate number of blacks in jail, it is hard to get around the simple fact they commit more crime. It is unfortunate and sad, but the reason is pretty straightforward, even if it is frowned upon to say out loud.
I would take great exception to your last paragraph. You repeat this as fact, when in fact you have fallen prey to the propaganda.
http://www.alternet.org/books/white-people-commit-most-heinous-crimes-so-why-america-terrified-black-men
The black men that populate jails and prisons are primarily in there for drug offenses and need to be set free. And then there’s #crimingwhilewhite
http://thinkprogress.org/justice/2014/12/04/3599492/criming-while-white/
And then there’s this… ( I’m certain he’s not the only one)
http://thegrio.com/2015/01/10/man-exonerated-framed-by-police/
Stop perpetuating a lie.
One example of a bad cop, or even a hundred examples, is statistically insignificant in a system that handles millions over the years. They are important and tragic issues that must be addressed when they are discovered, but they don’t really effect the subject that we are discussing.
And I am not perpetuating a lie. I am speaking the politically incorrect, and I am offending you (which I dislike doing; really I do), but it is not a lie or even a distortion.
Oh, Cheri…”alternet” and “Thinkprogress”…those are left wing extremist rags that can’t be trusted. Their best use is for a bird cage liner. They certainly are not like the Washington Times. ;o)
Someone has fallen for the propaganda, but it isn’t me. I read your articles and both of them showed how difficult it can be getting statistics on the subject of blacks and crime. Using the most commonly used statistics – the FBIs – if you strip out the drug incarcerations, blacks are still a disproportionately large portion of prisoners. The left tries desperately to explain this by any other way than to say that blacks commit more crime, but at its heart, committing more crime is why they are there. It isn’t because of some vague, unidentifiable institutional bias on the part of the Police and the Prosecutors that is so often ascribed to the system by the left. It is because blacks commit crimes at a higher rate. That is politically incorrect to state, but like so many things that are politically incorrect, it happens to be true.
Steve, you’re just wrong on your second paragraph. One example: Blacks and whites use pot at the same rates, yet Blacks are something like three times as likely to be charged and convicted of marijuana possession.
I am certain that if you break the statistics down by specific crime, there will be examples of disproportionality, but study after study invariably shows that blacks commit far more crimes than their share of the population would indicate should be the case. To quote the Washington Times from July 21, 2014:
“Today blacks are about 13 percent of the population and continue to be responsible for an inordinate amount of crime. Between 1976 and 2005 blacks committed more than half of all murders in the United States. The black arrest rate for most offenses — including robbery, aggravated assault and property crimes — is still typically two to three times their representation in the population. Blacks as a group are also overrepresented among persons arrested for so-called white-collar crimes such as counterfeiting, fraud and embezzlement. And blaming this decades-long, well-documented trend on racist cops, prosecutors, judges, sentencing guidelines and drug laws doesn’t cut it as a plausible explanation.”
Read more: http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/jul/21/family-secret-what-the-left-wont-tell-you-about-bl/#ixzz3OgCQsZl3
Follow us: @washtimes on Twitter
The far, far right moonie owned Washington Times? Stop. You’re killing me. The Washington Times is a bird cage liner, nothing more. You still have nothing.
I understand, Cheri. The Washington Times is not a left wing source of information so you have to ignore it, or, when confronted with it, denigrate it. When you can’t refute the information then fall back on good ol’ name calling.
“I am certain that if you break the statistics down by specific crime, there will be examples of disproportionality”
That settles the debate, Steve. There are certain crimes, particularly drug crimes, that explain an overwhelming majority of the prison population. We have over 2 million people behind bars in the US, Steve. Very few of them are there for serious crimes.
Moreover, Steve, the fact that Blacks are convicted at a higher rate does not mean they commit more crimes. That’s the case with drug crimes. And look at what you quoted:
“The black arrest rate for most offenses — including robbery, aggravated assault and property crimes — is still typically two to three times their representation in the population.”
THE ARREST RATE? I think that’s the point. The arrest rate is not the same as the commission rate.
I think you have your head in the sand, my friend.
You know, Bob, arguing with you is very difficult. You have a flair for words (no doubt due in some measure to your profession) and a way of presenting your position so that arguing against it makes me feel sort of stupid. But my gut tells me there is more to the story than what you presenting.
I agree that an inordinate amount of prisoners are in prison for drug crimes and not for violence or property violations. I wish we would find another better way to deal with drug violations, but that is a discussion for another time. Even when you strip away drug violations, blacks still represent a disproportionately high number of prisoners. Carrying it back further in the system, that means a disproportionately high number of blacks are arrested. You made a point that arrests rate does not necessarily mean they committed the crime. The Police and Prosecutors do make mistakes but it is highly unlikely they make mistakes to the degree you imply.
And this where you and I REALLY disagree. I have faith that the system works and there is minimal bias and error. I believe you think there is a great deal of bias and error in the system. I think the reason for the high number of blacks in prison is because of the high number of crimes they commit. I believe you think the reason for the large number of black in prison is institutional bias and racism. In looking through studies on the subject, there are some that show I am correct and some that support your position. I don’t know what that indicates about the studies, but I suspect it means the statistics are rather fluid and are open to interpretation. In any event, I am going with my gut on this…
I appreciate the review. I’ll try to view the movie this week.
I understand the dislike of “white” saviors in the black community today, and lbj, was no saint so it is ok to down play his role ;but it is not ok to alter it. I saw a pbs show on the history of slavery before the civil war and after watching it you would think only black people were involved in abolition of slavery even that is ok leave them out ;but don’t change what they did.