As a last act of 2014, can we finally bury, once and for all, the absurd and offensive myth of “American Exceptionalism”?
It’s baffling how it became so engrained in our culture to begin with. After all, America is a country whose founding fathers declared it “self-evident” that all men are created equal, then adopted a constitution allowing human beings to be brutally captured, transported to its shores, and enslaved. Doesn’t exceptional require a departure from “all men being created equal”?
But what about the slavery part? Why did we exceptional Americans take so long to end slavery? Perhaps because the country’s economic might was built on slavery.
In a Portland Press Herald op-ed, Commentary: Slavery’s legacy resurfaces in today’s racial unrest, Anne Farrow explains:
In studying 18th-century ships’ logs linking Connecticut and the slave trade, I saw that when we made stolen black labor our national bedrock and created a system where inferiority was identifiable by color, we doomed ourselves to a nation where justice and parity for black people still have not been achieved.
The Connecticut seamen and commanders in these ships’ logs did not regard their suffering African cargo as human. When they shoved them onto the English Caribbean islands, where the captives suffered and died in an agricultural system infamous for its cruelty, notions of kidnap and murder did not cross their minds. These black men, women and children were not seen as innocent people; they were part of a supply-and-demand chain that separated an estimated 12.5 million Africans from their homes and changed a hemisphere.
Several hundred thousand in that involuntary migration came to the American colonies, and their palpable humanity didn’t really pose a problem for most settlers here, either. The most pressing exigency of this brave new world was labor, and these valuable workers were the key to America’s early success. Their stolen, uncompensated labor gave us our running start.
The best and most educated people owned slaves, promulgated its benefits and enjoyed the wealth slavery created – the keeper of my Connecticut logbooks was not an obscure mariner but a Saltonstall and the scion of an aristocratic family.
Fast forward to today. Practically everything you read should tell you that Americans are anything but exceptional.
We torture.
Our President, and recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize, issues assassination orders, usually on Tuesdays.
When white cops kill unarmed black citizens, we stand idly by while corrupt prosecutors tank the indictment process.
We are a country with 4% of the world’s population, but 25% of the world’s prison population.
Patrick L. Smith of Salon, sums it up in his recent piece, We are f***ing sadists: We are not decent, and we are not a democracy:
And as soon as I started thinking about the Senate’s torture report in the context of America’s conduct abroad, many other things seemed immediately of a piece. The string of police murders. The Surveillance State. The license granted corporations and the wealthy to purchase elections. No welfare for the poor but welfare for Wall Street. A minimum wage no one can live on. The bold-faced biases of our highest court—and when the judiciary goes, I learned during my years as a correspondent, all else is either gone already or on the way down.
The list goes on, of course. The reality in plain sight is that America is not the nation many of us think it is and we are not the people we think we are or claim to be. It follows: If we continue to act abroad as we have it will be to our loss and at our peril, given what we have just had our noses rubbed in, as Glenn Greenwald put it in the interview he gave Isquith.
Let’s look closely at why this is so. The core question in the foreign policy debate today, no matter what one’s stripe, is American exceptionalism. Are we exceptional, indispensable, or whatever the term du jour, or not? To put the torture report and all else just noted in the context of foreign policy is 1) to see how they are related and 2) to recognize that the exceptionalists have just sustained a critical blow — fatal, were logic to apply. And the task before us now is to make it apply.
Okay, we started out 238 years ago by embracing slavery, in the North as well as the South. Obviously unexceptional. Today, we torture. Similarly unexceptional.
Which raises the question: Have we always been unexceptional, such that American exceptionalism has been a myth and nothing more, or was there once a day when our claim to exceptionalism had merit?
How about the period equally distant in time from our beginnings as from the present, the 1890’s. That decade began 114 years after the Declaration of Independence and ended 114 years ago. Certainly, were we exceptional, there would be at least a trace of that exceptionalism at the mid-point of our history.
At about that time, however, the country whose people believe themselves exceptional was concluding its genocidal purge of the Native American population, with the massacre at Wounded Knee taking place in 1890. The robber barons were running roughshod over the rest of us, with 60% of the country living in poverty or close to it (remind you of anything?). And, for the trifecta, we took a huge step backwards from the emancipation of slaves. In 1896, the Supreme Court decided Plessy vs. Ferguson, which held that state “separate but equal” laws were constitutional.
No, there wasn’t a whiff of 1890s American exceptionalism in the air in the 1890’s either.
So there you have it. We weren’t exceptional when we started out; we aren’t exceptional now, and we weren’t exceptional in between.
Vladimir Putin is everyone’s punching bag today. but I like his statement on American exceptionalism, so I’ll quote him anyhow:
My working and personal relationship with President Obama is marked by growing trust. I appreciate this. I carefully studied his address to the nation on Tuesday. And I would rather disagree with a case he made on American exceptionalism, stating that the United States’ policy is “what makes America different. It’s what makes us exceptional.” It is extremely dangerous to encourage people to see themselves as exceptional, whatever the motivation. There are big countries and small countries, rich and poor, those with long democratic traditions and those still finding their way to democracy. Their policies differ, too. We are all different, but when we ask for the Lord’s blessings, we must not forget that God created us equal.
Was 2014 the last hurrah for the myth we’ve known as American exceptionalism? As Patrick Smith noted: “the exceptionalists have just sustained a critical blow — fatal, were logic to apply. And the task before us now is to make it apply.” Indeed. Let’s make logic apply and let the myth die its long overdue death.
Discover more from Blog for Arizona
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
The south owes all of it’s infrastructure that has survived since 1865 to slaves, I wonder if that even crosses their minds?
And Arizona had to be blackmailed by the NFL to pass the MLK day. Revenge was sworn thus they are trying to pass a no blackout law sponsored by U.S. Senator John McCain!
Logic rarely changes cultures and societies. Thomas Paine’s Common Sense changed society and spurred a revolution. Harriet Beecher Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin brought the nation’s escalating conflict over the abomination of slavery to a head, perhaps lighting the fuse that started what we know as the Civil War.
Perhaps someone will write a true and poignant history or an historical fiction novel about the dark threads of American history. That’s what I believe it will take to extinguish the false myth of American exceptionalism.
But I wholeheartedly agree that the myth must die.
That dark history to which you refer in your second paragraph, Steve, already has been written: The People’s History of the United States, by Howard Zinn.