The editors of The Arizona Republic are having an existential crisis in faith now that Governor Jan Brewer’s so-called “Arizona Comeback” has turned into “Arizona’s Nightmare.” State’s financial picture dims: “Revenue projections provided Tuesday to the Legislature’s Finance Advisory Committee show the state will end this budget year with a $520 million deficit and up to $1 billion deficit in the coming fiscal 2016.”
The Republic editors have always supported Republicans for political office and have been devoted believers in faith based supply-side “trickle down” GOP economics. This is a problem of which The Republic and its editors share much of the blame for influencing the public to support such fantasy nonsense.
The Republic takes issue with the candidates for governor. Ducey, DuVal: How about some straight budget talk?:
The two leading candidates to be Arizona’s next governor are running classically smart campaigns. They speak in vague generalities, inspiring hope and optimism. They avoid specifics, especially about tough topics. Those can only get a candidate in trouble.
Especially when the topic is the state budget, projected to be $520 million out of balance this year and $1 billion in the red for the first budget the new governor will propose.
How would Democrat Fred DuVal or Republican Doug Ducey balance it? The safe ideas they have offered in their campaigns amount to looking for coins in the sofa cushions. DuVal wants to change the way the state buys stuff. Ducey wants to streamline the bureaucracy. Both count on economic vitalization that will take years.
Here’s the hard truth. There are two ways to balance a budget this far out of balance: Raise taxes. Slash programs. Neither is popular, and so neither candidate will talk about them.
Republic columnist Joanna Allhands can barely bring herself to say the word. Is it time to talk the “T” word? “[W]e’re facing another billion-dollar deficit next year, and already, lawmakers are talking about “pull(ing) out the old tool kit” to solve it. That means mostly cuts, we’re told, because taxes are absolutely off the table. But what are they going to cut?”
Republic Columnist Robert Robb, the man most responsible for promoting fiscally reckless and irresponsible GOP economics in Arizona dating back to his days of flacking for the Goldwater Institute and the Arizona Chamber of Commerce, gets all huffy today. Balance the damn budget : ” It’s time for everyone in state government to put on their big boy pants. Either increase taxes to pay for the government we have or want. Or cut state programs sufficiently that they can be sustained with existing tax sources.” As always, Robb picks door number 2, opting to cut programs.
This is a fiscal crisis 22 years in the making which has finally metastasized into a malignant cancer that is eating away at Arizona. We were able to cover up the flaws with rapid population growth over much of that time that masked the symptoms, but now that Arizona has a stable population, the old cure no longer works and the cancer lesions have become obvious.
All of the Republic editors are being dishonest by failing to tell voters the cold hard truth: Arizona’s structural tax revenue deficit, directly resulting from 22 years of GOP tax cuts, cannot be undone by a simple majority vote of the Arizona legislature thanks to Prop. 108 (1992), Ariz. Const. Article IX, which requires a two-thirds vote of the legislature for passage and three-fourths vote to override a governor’s veto of any legislation that would provide a net increase in state revenues through certain changes in taxes, tax rates, tax deductions, fees or assessments, or that results in a reduction or elimination of a tax deduction, exemption, exclusion, credit or other tax exemption feature in computing tax liability.
The cornerstone to any meaningful tax reform and restoring sanity to our fiscal policy in Arizona is the repeal of Prop. 108 (1992), Ariz. Const. Article IX. As Rahm Emanuel is purported to have once said, “never let a crisis go to waste.” Arizona’s budget crisis presents the perfect timing to refer the repeal of Prop. 108 to the voters. Strike while the iron is hot.
It is time to restore democratic government to Arizona: simple majority rule on tax matters. The anti-democratic Prop. 108 only empowers a tyranny of a minority of anti-tax zealots, backed by the lawyers of the Goldwater Institute which strenuously defends Prop. 108, to hold the citizens of Arizona hostage to their extremist demands to always cut more from the budget (while simultaneously handing out more corporate welfare tax cuts to their friends).
If the editors of The Republic are serious about solving Arizona’s fiscal crisis, I urge them to join me in this crusade to repeal Prop. 108, and to restore democratic government — simple majority rule — to Arizona.
Discover more from Blog for Arizona
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
I can’t tell if they are willfully misleading us or simply ignorant when they constantly press the Governor candidates about the budget. The Governor of Arizona has very little discretionary spending and cannot raise revenue by fiat. The time spent wanking over the budget and deficits with DuVal and Ducey is time taken away from asking them about things that are really in their control, such as whether they’ll sign or veto the terrible bills that embarrass our state and lead to us getting boycotted. But of course that might mean DuVal gets elected which terrifies the media here, for some reason.