Happy New Year BfAZ readers!
The silver lining of no longer participating in the New Year’s Eve revelry is no longer nursing a New Year’s Day hangover. Which allowed me to uncover this gem by David Masciotra from a few days ago: “No civilization would tolerate what America has done”.
Masciotra explains that the responsibility for Ferguson and New York and our general indifference to the suffering of those without power in America lies in our society at large. Those who protest oppression in America are, and always have been, the sane minority.
More optimistic liberals will identify the masses of protestors filling the streets with rage and disgust over the state-sanctioned murder of two unarmed black men, but the thousands of people protesting in major cities are only the sane minority. The sane minority fights against the “silent majority” of Richard Nixon’s delight. The disgraced president was right in 1969 when he pointed out that the majority of Americans were not part of anti-war demonstrations or countercultural movements; they were his voters, and their children became Reagan’s voters. From beyond the grave, he is still right.
Few, however, are willing to take the “silent majority” in America to task for their complicity. As Masciotra points out, the elephants in the room regarding Ferguson and New York are the jurors who vote not to indict:
In all of the attacks on the “system” for endorsing the behavior of murderous cops, few critics actually condemn those most responsible for the decisions not to press charges: the jurors. No one reasonable can doubt that the county prosecutor, Robet McCulloch, in Ferguson, did his best to corrupt the process, but clearly no one marching in solidarity with Michael Brown’s family would have let Darren Wilson live comfortably with the $1 million his supporters raised to assist him through his financial difficulties. A large part of the problem lies with the jurors who accepted their roles as McCulloch’s toys and Wilson’s collective shield.
There is no imaginable defense of the jury in the Eric Garner case. They had visual evidence of the police murdering a man begging for his life. They, like the police they protect, are average Americans. They are not cyborgs. They are your neighbors.
Twelve more Americans in Texas felt no horror or sympathy when watching two police officers beat Keyarika Diggles in a police station. Perhaps they viewed it with the same amusement we when watching the destruction of lives on reality television. One thing that is for certain is that they did not watch as decent human beings.
The silent majority Masciotra identifies is connected of course to the “illiterate majority” to which Chris Hedges often refers.
These “systems,” however, are not giant computers. They are institutions run and powered by people. The people are the face of America. Darren Wilson, Robert McCulloch and the jurors who failed to punish police officers for killing, are part of the silent majority. They are the same silent majority of voters responsible for the election of officials who dismiss poverty as an unimportant issue, who assault public education, and who continually call for the enhancement of killing Muslims in the Middle East. They are the same silent majority, 66 percent according to polls, who support air strikes against Iraq, and they constitute the 40 percent, which will only grow if the propaganda campaign picks up again, that support a ground invasion.
For a particularly horrific glimpse into the creep show of American values of violence, consider that, according to a recent Pew Report, 51 percent of Americans believe that torture, such as rectal feeding, waterboarding and other gruesome methods described in the Senate Intelligence Committee report, is justified. Another 20 percent said that they have no opinion.
It seems the jurors in the Brown, Garner and Diggles cases were easy to deceive, and in the case of Ferguson, likely because they had little knowledge of American history or law. They are likely part of the 71 percent of Americans who never read a newspaper, the 80 percent of American families who bought no books last year, and the 70 percent who cannot name a single part of the Bill of Rights.
Unfortunately, it’s the silent, illiterate majority who stand in the way of real progress. Masciotra’s conclusion is as compelling as it is depressing:
The sane minority might ostensibly protest the racism of the criminal justice system, but they are actually demanding that America become a civilized society. No civilization would tolerate what America has recently done, but it is that very concept —the idea of civilization—that the silent majority so fiercely seems to hate and reject.
Finally, here’s my spin: Masciotra identifies well why real change never will be effected at the ballot box. Elected officials and candidates always will pander to the silent, illiterate majority, whose views are determined by what their plutocratic masters feed them in the form of television commercials and fake news. Real change only will come when the sane minority grows large enough and noisy enough that the majority has no choice but to listen.
Discover more from Blog for Arizona
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Masciotra is right to blame our social and political system for the miscarriages of justice by the grand juries in the Garner and Jackson cases, and for other miscarriages of justice. However, he loses his point about our problematic social system when he goes off on an ad hominem rant against the grand jurors. Moreover, he offers no evidence to support his assertions that the particular grand jurors involved were illiterate, uninformed, or cruel. I doubt that the jurors were unable to read or write.
Had Masciotra stayed with his critique of the larger social system qua system, he would have found much to criticize and blame in the institution of the grand jury system itself. We learned from the Ferguson and Staten Island cases, for example, that witnesses were not cross-examined, and that there wasn’t any sort of adversarial hearing of the evidence; that no one was there to represent aggrieved family members. And the prosecutors did not really play a prosecutorial role, nor did the police officers involved have a defense attorney.
If one searches “grand juries in the United States” in Wikipedia, he/she will learn that the U.S. “is virtually the only common law jurisdiction the world that continues to use a grand jury to screen for criminal indictments,” and that only about half of the states … employ them.” “The modern trend is to use an adversarial preliminary hearing before a trial court judge, rather than grand jury, in the screening role of determining whether there is evidence establishing probable cause that a defendant committed a serious felony before that defendant is required to go to trial and risk a conviction on those charges.” Obviously, Missouri and New York are not part of this modern trend. Arizona has “a form of the grand jury.”
Bob, your article got me thinking. If you decided to move to abother country, which one would it be and why? I’m not looking to criticize or to argue about how wonderful the United States is, I am just curious. I imagine you might have given this some thought in the past – even if only for a mental exercize – and I was hoping you might share it with us.
It’s an interesting question, Steve. Personally, I’m not in a position to seriously consider a move, although it certainly is a subject of idle curiosity. Ultimately, it’s an impossible question to answer intelligently (for most of us). It’s sort of the flip side of when someone asserts with supreme certainty that “America is the best country in the world to live in” and you respond “well, what other countries have you lived in as a basis for comparison?” The answer, almost always, is zero. Funny thing is, that only undermines their certainty some the time.
My objectivity is clouded because I have a daughter in Melbourne, so I have a comfort level moving there I don’t have with other countries.
Ultimately, however, I think we’re in the midst of a re-ordering of the world the outcome of which is impossible to predict. The US empire could dissolve as Rome did, or it may simply pull back, as Britain did, in which case it could be a fine place to live. There are South American countries with incredible potential, but not without significant risk. And there’s Scandinavia, for a safer bet.
The best choice, by the way, depends in part on your age. There are countries that would welcome a youngster, but wouldn’t be much interested in an old fart like me.
But we likely only have a few decades before the planet burns, so why obsess over where to live. Best just to enjoy the days you have.
If the people will lead the leaders will eventually follow. Street lefties have been demonstrating in the streets of phoenix as well as other cities. Have anyone here joined in the demonstrations? Street democrats are arizona democratic partys true leaders not the elitists old whites who run the party. Along with young latinos street democrats are the partys future. I have written a screenplay that I hope to make into a movie about this.
Good luck with your screenplay! (Seriously, no sarcasm intended)
Your article refers to those who think like you as the “sane minority” and the balance of us as the “silent, illiterate majority”. You also imply that until everyone listens to the sane minority, we are doomed to continue as a nation “by and for” the illiterate and uninformed.
Are you claiming the mantle of “exceptionalism” for those who think as you do? I seem to recall your quoting Putin that anytime a people claim they are exceptional, it is a dangerous thing.
Neither of us knows what went on inside the Grand Juries of either case. We can guess, we can speculate, we can infur, we can discuss, but we can’t know. However, the tone of the author you quote makes it clear that the Grand Juries did not arrive at the verdicts he wanted, therefore the verdicts are flawed decision handed down by ill informed dunces. I believe that is why we have Grand Juries and Juries: To keep decisions on the fate of the accused out of the hands of those exceptional members of society who would judge without all the facts and without ever allowing the accused to present their side of the story.
You speak of civilization as if civilization exists only when people do that which you feel they should do. We ARE a civilized people…we are NOT a perfect people. We make mistakes, but then we proceed to tear ourselves apart in concious agony over errors we make. We WANT to be perfect, but we aren’t. And, Bob, I hate to say this to you, but you are likely to find that the author who has the answers to make us a civilized people – as you and he would define it – very likely is as flawed as the rest of us. It is always easier to stand on the sidelines and criticise than to lead because it is during the process of leadership that flaws become apparent.
Steve, you aren’t part of a silent majority. You are part of the minority of loud conservative whiners squawking about whatever imaginary outrage has your panties in a bunch at any given moment. I was at an Albertons recently when there was this (of course) older white man standing at the magazine rack by the cash register bellowing to the cashier and to all who could hear him how Obama was a Muslim and not legally President. I have never encountered people who felt more entitled to air their views, loudly, in whatever environment they are in than white conservatives.
“Neither of us knows what went on inside the Grand Juries of either case. ”
No, you haven’t bothered to learn anything. Here: http://www.thesmokinggun.com/documents/unmasking-Ferguson-witness-40-496236
Steve, consider history. In the Old South, white juries routinely convicted innocent Blacks and acquitted guilty whites. Remember To Kill a Mockingbird? Just 20 or so years ago, a white jury acquitted the cops who beat the crap out of Rodney King. The same arguments you made in your comment could have been made in the Old South, or in the Rodney King case, or even in the fictional setting of To Kill a Mockingbird. But making those arguments in those contexts would now be seen for what it is — insane. So, on which side of history do you think your comment will fall when folks look back on this sad chapter 50 years from now?
Conflating this post with the one I wrote on American exceptionalism is absurd. Identifying a group as wrong, or illiterate, is not equivalent to claiming to be exceptional. Indeed, it’s the opposite. If the author felt the group to which he belonged was exceptional, there would be no need to point out the illiteracy of the majority. Rather, he pointed to the illiteracy as an explanation as to why they were getting it so wrong.
I’m really pretty done with Steve’s willfully ignorant, concern trolling ass. Same goes for that Sarah who pops up all the time to lecture liberals on what we’re doing wrong. They add nothing constructive to any discussion here.
Not me. I’m happy to engage in the debate. I even went back and forth with our friend Thucky for 8 months before figuring out who he was. Steve brings life experiences to the table I don’t have, so once in a while I should be able to learn something from his comments.
And, who knows, maybe he’ll actually learn something from me.
I already have learned from you, Bob. You quietly led me down the path until one day I was forced to agree that taxing the rich is NOT an evil thing. You demonstrated to me that the gulf between poor and rich was obscene and the rationale was there for higher taxes.
Believe me, that was no small thing.
Well, hopefully. He doesn’t seem to want to learn from liberal women. I’ve learned from him that our likes should be busier pondering how very, very bad abortion is.
I’ve a feeling I’ll be proven right about him. Concern troll. Watch for my next post.
Bob, I envy you. Your way with words is so much better than the feeble reponses with which I respond.
I don’t know what people will think of what I say 50 years from now. I suspect they will say I was simply a man of my time. Nothing especially insightful, well intentioned but torn by the sense that they should be better than they are. And that is what I am: Just an average guy who, along with his Wife of 37 years, did the best they could to raise a family of three children (a Doctor, an FBI Agent and a Veterinarian), served his Country in two different wars and survived the much too early death of his Wife just as they were preparing to enjoy retirement. I doubt they will think I was insane, or cruel, or even unusual. I am just an Everyman hoping to leave the world a better place than when I entered it.
Perhaps that is because I don’t see this Nation in as bad a condition as you do. We do have wrongs that need to be corrected (but not nearly as many as this blog would indicate); We do need to be more careful about foreign entanglements (to loosely quote Jefferson)“; There is institutional racism that needs to be weeded out (but it is not just “white” racism); and we need to do something to rectify this financial gulf between the haves and the have nots (something I learned from you when you showed me the facts).
In the meantime, I will continue to move forward, keep my employees working, taking delight in my children and grandchildren, and generally living my life as best I can. This is a good country, but there are several good countries on earth. I think our future is bright (whether or not your enlightened brethren run things or not. ;o)