Think Like an Egyptian

No, the title here is not an allusion to a pop song from the ‘80s.

Rather, it’s a way perhaps to better understand the rise of fundamentalist Islam. You’re familiar with the horrors of ISIS. But if you’re like me you have trouble with the attempt by pundits on the right and left to explain ISIS in the abstract. ISIS, according to those pundits, is an entity onto itself, not shaped by any forces outside of it. There’s “something about Islam” that gives rise to ISIS, the pundits will tell you.

But there’s something unsatisfying to you about that analysis. After all, ISIS only replaced Al Qaeda as the terror threat du jour. Extinguish ISIS and there will be a terror threat to replace it.

So, how would things look for you through the eyes of an Egyptian?

Think like an Egyptian. For decades, you lived under the rule of Hosni Mubarak. Beginning in the 1990’s, Mubarak and his family systematically plundered your country, choking its economy in the process.

The United States stood in Mubarak’s corner all the way, providing him billions of dollars in weaponry.

Think like an Egyptian. In 2011, you and your fellow Egyptians rose up, in a remarkably nonviolent revolution. The United States stood by as Mubarak’s thugs tried to thwart the uprising. Only when it was a virtual certainty that Mubarak was done did the United States call for his removal.

Think like an Egyptian. Just two years later, the United States backed a military coup, removing from power the government you elected. The military to which the United States gave the go ahead then began a campaign to violently eradicate the leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood government it had deposed.

The United States continued to supply it with arms, ignoring its own rule not to provide military assistance to a government installed through a coup.

Think like an Egyptian. One year after the removal of your elected leaders, you watch as the U.S. backed junta that replaced them helps to facilitate the massacre of Palestinians by the Israeli military. You support the Palestinian cause. You know the government you elected would not have been complicit in their massacre had it not been removed from power.

And you know the United States is behind it all.

You wonder, did the United States orchestrate the removal of your elected leaders t to assist its ally, Israel?

You live poorly, as most Egyptians do.

You resent your country’s wealth being concentrated in the hands of a powerful few, while the many scrape out a meager existence.

Think like an Egyptian.

How do you and your 80 million odd countrymen feel about the United States?

Think like an Egyptian, and consider whether you and your 80 million odd countrymen can relate to this, from Salon’s Haroon Moghul in The Atlantic’s big Islam lie: What Muslims really believe about ISIS:

Imagine a group of people who rape.  Enslave.  Maim.  Murder.  Ethnically cleanse.  Extort.  Burn.  Behead.  But then imagine this—they don’t lie?  Can’t lie.  Won’t lie.  That’s what Graeme Wood’s recent Atlantic essay, “What ISIS Really Wants,” really wants us to believe.

That a movement that has earned the world’s nearly universal opprobrium for its grotesque violence and wickedness is nevertheless honest in describing why it does what it does.  I beg to differ.  The only Muslims who think ISIS represents Islam, or even Muslims, are ISIS themselves.

That’s the first thing everyone needs to know about “the Islamic State.”  And the second?  If you want to know why ISIS exists, don’t bother searching Islamic texts, or examining Islamic traditions.  The real reason ISIS happens is because of what keeps happening to Muslims.

Think like an Egyptian.


Discover more from Blog for Arizona

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

1 thought on “Think Like an Egyptian”

  1. I’m reading a great book called “Why We Lost” by retired General Daniel Bolger about the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. I come away thinking that the biggest mistake was the almost total destruction of the Sunni community by Paul Bremer in 2004. Ten years later, the Iranian supported Shia politicians continue to pay lip service to any kind of equitable treatment of the Sunnis.
    This is why the ISIS group has been able to take and hold so much territory in Iraq. I think that ultimately Iraq may end up in three parts, much as Joe Biden suggested years ago. The Sunnis will tire of ISIS at some point and rise up against them, like they did with Al Quaeda in 2007.

Comments are closed.