(Update) The GOP Clown Car Primary for Governor

ClownCarThe Arizona Republic fna The Arizona Republican has an editorial opinion today which makes this unbelievable assertion: Ariz. voters treated with strong field in governor’s race.

Cue stand-up comedian Lewis Black shaking his head in disbelief and wildly gesticulating while asking “WTF?” Only a partisan editorial board would make such a ridiculous assertion that this GOP Clown Car Primary is a “strong field.”

Let’s start with the guy who is currently in line of succession to Governor Jan Brewer, Secretary of State Ken “Birther” Bennett. This is the guy who has been so terrible at his current job, that he believes he is entitled to a job promotion. Remember headlines like this from November 2012? Why Is Arizona Still Counting Votes?, and What Took So Long? Explaining Arizona’s Ballot Count Fiasco.

If you thought 2012 was a fiasco, you are going to love 2014. Bennett is pursuing Arizona’s Prop. 200 proof-of-citizenship for voter registration in court, Kobach v. U.S. Election Assistance Commission, which disenfranchises U.S. citizens who do not possess the forms of ID required by the state Arizona. Bennet is proceeding with a dual election system in this year’s election in which voters who registered to vote using the federal National Voter Registration Form will not be permitted to vote for any candidates other than for federal offices (Congress), disenfranchising several thousand Arizona voters from voting for state offices.

Ken “Birther” Bennett earned his moniker when  he demanded that Presi­dent Barack Obama’s campaign provide proof of citizenship before he would list the president on the 2012 ballot. Last year Bennett supported the GOP Voter Suppression Act, HB 2305, which has since been repealed by a legislature that was terrified of a citizens referendum (“citizens veto”) on this year’s ballot.

So what’s Bennett’s big idea running for governor? He wants to repeal the state personal and corporate income tax, and replace it with  a regressive sales tax that  imposes the levy on services and other transactions not currently taxed. He does not say how he intends to get around Prop. 108 (1992) requiring a super-majority of both chamber of the legislature to impose any “new” taxes, or to eliminate tax exemptions or credits.

This is more of the same faith based supply-side “Trickle down” economics that has been entirely disproved and discredited.

Arizona cannot afford any more magical thinking. Bennett is disqualified from consideration as a serious candidate.

Next up, the candidate from the Center for Arizona Policy (CAP), “Cathi’s Clown” Doug Ducey, currently State Treasurer. If you want to put Cathi Herrod directly in the governor’s office in charge of public policy, this is your guy. Ducey is also supported by the bag man for “Kochtopus” dark money campaign money laundering, Sean Noble,who was at the center of the largest “campaign money-laundering [scheme] in California history.” Dark Money Groups Pay $1 Million in Fines in California Case. Ducey’s dicey associates should scare the hell out of you.

And why are the “Kochtopus” dark money organizations supporting Ducey? This is why: “As governor, I will submit legislation to reduce taxes every year, with the eventual goal of pushing the income tax rates – both personal as well as corporate – as close to zero as possible.”

Again, more of the same faith based supply-side “Trickle down” economics that has been entirely disproved and discredited.

Arizona cannot afford any more magical thinking. Ducey is disqualified from consideration as a serious candidate.

Then there’s termed-out state senator Cap’n “Atomic Al” Melvin — oh Al, if you did not exist we would have to invent you. This guy is comedy gold that writes itself, and frequently is the source of jokes of late night comedians.  Cap’n Al is an acolyte of disgraced and recalled former state senator Russell Pearce and Crazy Uncle Joe Arpaio — he wants to deport all “Mescans.” He also wants to build more nuclear power plants in Arizona, but does not want the inevitable nuclear waste stored in his his own backyard in Saddlebrooke. And Cap’n Al is a big supporter of privatization of “government” schools, wanting to create a system of school vouchers for private and parochial schools.

Like the other GOP Clown Car Primary candidates, Cap’n Al also wants to “phase out both the corporate and individual income tax.”

Once again, Cap’n Al believes in the same faith based supply-side “Trickle down” economics that has been entirely disproved and discredited.

Arizona cannot afford any more magical thinking — or the next Ev Mecham. Cap’n Al is disqualified from consideration as a serious candidate.

The sleeper candidate the media villagers have dismissed, only because they do not know how the Christian Reconstructionists and Dominionists organize their campaigns, is disgraced and disbarred former Maricopa County Attorney “Saint” Andrew Thomas, a crusader persecuted for his conservative beliefs. Actually he was disbarred for abusing the power of his office to engage in a political witch hunt against his political opponents and those of his ally, Crazy Uncle Joe Arpaio.

Which explains his recent statement: “As Governor, I intend to finish the fight by sealing the border, stopping illegal immigration once and for all, and driving the drug and human trafficking cartels back into Mexico. And frankly, I don’t much care how various ‘communities’ respond to these efforts.” Okay then . . .

The media has made little note of the fact that “Saint” Andrew Thomas does not appear to be participating in many public forums (so there are few public statements on his positions). This is because the Christian Reconstructionists and Dominionists organize through their churches and social networks, not political party organizations. “Saint Andy” is running an asymmetrical campaign — with seven candidates splitting the vote, a candidate can win the primary with less than 20% of the total vote — which in a primary is miniscule. “Saint Andy” is banking on the voters of “God’s Own Party” to carry him to victory.

A corrupt and disgraced politician is disqualified from consideration as a serious candidate.

Former Mesa Mayor Scott Smith is “a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma,” to paraphrase Winston Churchill. Smith supported Governor Jan Brewer’s Medicaid expansion plan, but in the same breath says he is opposed to “Obamacare” which created the program. “Wha?” Smith also supports Gov. Jan Brewer’s “Arizona’s College and Career Ready Standards” aka “Common Core” standards, but in the same breath says “There should be local control in adapting the curriculum.” Uh-huh. This issue has become a litmus test for the radical right, so good luck with that Scotty.

Smith has said that he will “make recommendations for sweeping [tax] reform,” but like Ken “Birther” Bennett,” he does not say how he intends to get around Prop. 108 (1992) requiring a super-majority of both chamber of the legislature to impose any “new” taxes, or to eliminate tax exemptions or credits.

The media villagers want to portray Smith as the “mythical moderate Republican” in this race, but his views are not really all that different from the other conservatives in this GOP Clown Car Primary. The media is actually harming Smith by tagging him with the “moderate” label in the GOP primary. The media villagers refuse to accept the fact that this is not your father’s GOP — this is a radicalized, reactionary, and extremist party — especially the rarefied electorate in a GOP primary.

Next we have the “GoDaddy Girl,” Christine Jones, who has already been tripped up with some questionable résumé inflation and embellishment. Gubernatorial candidate Jones’ work history questioned. Jones has used the typical wingnut talking points on a variety of issues, but as I have said before, she provided the most succinct and accurate response on taxes I have seen so far:

“The top marginal state income tax rate is 4.54 percent, down from more than 7 percent 20 years ago. Income taxes generate $3.5 billion annually to the general fund, nearly one-third of our total net revenues supporting education, law enforcement and other priorities. Even assuming robust growth, there’s no way to replace $3.5 billion without significant new taxes, so those proposing income-tax elimination must tell the public what those will be. Anything else is just the same old politics as usual coming from the same old political animals.”

I have to wonder whether someone who does not accept as a matter of faith the faith based supply-side “trickle down” economics of the GOP has any chance in a GOP primary. This is like questioning their faith in Ronaldus Magnus or God Almighty. Too bad, because we need more of this clear-eyed rational economics from Republicans. The other wingnut stuff that Jones says — she has demonstrated some serious love for Crazy Uncle Joe Arpaio — meh, not so much.

Finally, there is former California congressman Frank Riggs. That’s OK, he has never heard of you either. His gimmick is the “flat tax.” Frank “Flat Tax” Riggs says “Taxes should be as low, flat and fair as possible, and tax policy should promote savings and investment and tax consumption. I favor a flat tax on income with an exemption for the first $12,000 of income. I would eliminate the sales tax or ‘Transaction Privilege Tax’ in favor of a broad-based consumption tax with an exemption for prescription medicine and a low-income refundable tax credit.”

Someone should explain to Riggs that GOP candidates tried to float versions of the flat tax several years ago, and when it was explained to Arizonan’s that the vast majority of them would be paying more in taxes so that the wealthy few could pay less, public opinion quickly turned sour on the flat tax.

Lattie Coor, chairman of the Center for the Future of Arizona, kicked off the recent gubernatorial forum co-hosted by The Arizona Republic by saying the next Arizona governor must “change the image of Arizona on late-night television.”

None of  the GOP candidates can hope to accomplish this, despite the partisan wishful thinking of The Republic’s editors.

If this state is going to break from the morass we have been in for years, we need to go a new direction — someone sane, rational and reasonable. The only candidate in the race who fits this description  is Democrat Fred DuVal.


Discover more from Blog for Arizona

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.