When The Arizona Republic endorsed Ron Barber for Congress in 2012, it made this biting critique of his opponent Martha McSally, Barber deserves to retain job:
[McSally is] smart and full of energy, but her grasp of the specifics on issues is shallow. If she builds a base of knowledge and seeks some political experience, McSally will have a lot to offer.
Ouch! Now the lesson to be learned from this critique is to educate herself and to develop a base of knowledge on substantive policy issues in order to be taken seriously as a credible candidate, instead of being a vacuous lightweight who is just “the GOP alternative” (an extremely low threshold).
In the past two years, has Martha McSally learned this lesson? The answer is an unqualified “no.” She has made no effort at all. The Barber campaign provides a handy-dandy backgrounder of media coverage of the CD 2 race to date:
POLITICO: McSally “…declined to say whether she would’ve voted for the deal to reopen the government (“I’m against shutting down the government,” she said) or whether she supported Wisconsin Rep. Paul Ryan’s much-criticized budget plan.” [6/9/14]
Washington Examiner: “…McSally doesn’t show much command of political issues. “I’m not an expert,” she said when asked by the Washington Examiner what she thought caused the financial crisis of 2008. Questioned about what she might present as her first piece of legislation if elected, McSally didn’t have an answer.” [4/4/14]
OZY: “Wasn’t Comfortable Talking Policy” and “Avoid[ed] Stating A Firm Position” on Immigration Reform. [2/5/14]
Arizona Capitol Times: McSally Has Been “Reluctant to Take Solid Stances on Current Issues.” [11/26/13]
Tucson Weekly: McSally is “Getting a Rap in the Press as Someone Who Isn’t Forthright About Her Positions.” [11/21/13]
Roll Call: McSally: “Refused to Give a Clear Answer” on Government Shutdown and Instead Provided “A Lot of Baloney.” [11/4/13]
Arizona Republic: Facing Questions About the Government Shutdown, McSally “Wouldn’t Take a Stand Despite Multiple Requests.” [10/7/13]
Jim Nintzel of the Tucson Weekly makes an astute observation today in discussing the House Majority PAC poll released by the Barber campaign this week, in which Barber holds a 45 to 37 percent lead. Poll Dancing:
On the personal level, Barber’s favorability level was 49 percent and his unfavorable was 28 percent. [Note: this number includes liberals/progressives who express dissatisfaction, but who will nonetheless vote for Barber.] McSally’s personal favorability was down at 32 percent, while 28 percent of those survey viewed her unfavorably.
The poll has a different result than a McSally-backed survey released in April, which showed 45 percent of voters supporting McSally and just 43 percent supporting Barber. [That poll was conducted by GOP polling firm OnMessage.] The McSally campaign did not release all the details of its methodology for the April poll, which also talked to 400 likely voters and had a margin of error of plus or minus 4.9 percent.
But it did show that voters have reservations about McSally. A full 51 percent said they thought it was time to “give someone else a chance,” compared to the 36 percent who wanted to give Barber another term. But with McSally only getting the support of 45 percent of those surveyed, it appeared that some respondents had reservations about about that “someone else” being McSally.
To summarize, McSally is viewed as a shallow candidate with low favorability, and is vulnerable in a GOP primary to voters who want to “give someone else a chance” (she is a two time loser).
So why are McSally’s GOP primary opponents, Chuck Wooten and Shelly Kais, being so passive with their campaigns?
I have been working in campaigns for more than 30 years with more victories than losses, so far be it from me to provide free political advice to a Republican candidate, but guys — why are you not sending out daily press releases to the local media saying that you will debate Martha McSally anytime, anywhere in front of any group and any moderator of her choosing? Use one of those counter clocks on your web site to indicate that “it has been ___ days since I challenged Martha McSally to a debate, and she has refused to come out of hiding in her chicken bunker to debate me.” Rent a chicken costume from a local costume shop and have someone parade in front of the McSally headquarters with a sign that says “McSally is chicken to debate!” (Make sure you get photos and video and post it to your social media, and send it to the media).
And why are you allowing the local media to anoint Martha McSally, and to get away without having to debate you? Your media person should be harassing the Arizona Daily Star, Inside Tucson Business, the Tucson Weekly, the Chamber of Commerce, the League of Women Voters, etc. to sponsor a series of CD 2 GOP primary debates. It’s time for the corporate media to step up and to demonstrate its civic duty by sponsoring debates — like the media does up in Phoenix.
As for you, Ms. McSally, you owe the voters an explanation of your positions on the issues, and to debate your GOP primary opponents. It’s time for you to come out of hiding in your chicken bunker.
UPDATE: It’s a start, but demand a series of debates. Just one is what McSally is hoping for. 3 GOP candidates in CD2 race agree to debate:
There will be a Republican primary debate in Congressional District 2, although the three candidates have not settled on a date or a place.
Martha McSally, a retired Air Force colonel, agreed in principle to participate in a debate with the other two Republican candidates before the Aug. 26 primary, campaign spokesman Patrick Ptak confirmed on Thursday.
Chuck Wooten, a retired Air Force chief master sergeant, and small-business owner Shelley Kais had been calling for a debate in CD2, with Kais making an open invitation to both candidates on June 14.
Discover more from Blog for Arizona
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.