Featured Stories
Diane Ravitch on TPM Book Club
December 10, 2013
by
by David Safier Talking Points Memo's regular Book Club feature has a piece by Diane Ravitch: Stop Doing The Wrong Things In Education. It's a short adaptation of the basic concepts in her new book, Reign of Error. She begins by discussing the conservative "education reform" narrative which has been taken up by most of … Read more
Winds of Change?
December 9, 2013
by
Posted by Bob Lord
I'm more optimistic right now about our future than I've been since Occupy.
Inequality is the defining issue of our time. And I have this feeling we're living through a dramatic quickening in the movement against inequality.
Consider what we've seen in just the past few months:
First, the development of real movements in support of fast food workers and Walmart workers, with no signs of dissipation.
Then, a dramatic progressive victory in the 2013 elections. Yes, Chris Christie won re-election against a virtually unknown and woefully underfunded challenger, but, as The Nation magazine noted, that was not the real story. The real story was Bill deBlasio's landslide victory and the SeaTac ballot initiative creating a $15 minimum wage.
Then, noises about a potential Elizabeth Warren candidacy in 2016.
Then, a message from the Pope about the immorality of inequality and, in that message, a blistering attack on trickle down economics. The Pope was not alone. The Dalai Lama issued a similar statement just a few days ago. And of course President Obama has chimed in as well, stating, unequivocally, that inequality is the defining issue of our time.
Last, there's a significant development that most Americans didn't notice. But BlueMeanie did in his post, The Democratic wing of the Democratic Party fights back against the corporatist Third Way, and Paul Krugman did in his post, Badge of Seriousness Watch. The Third Way, a "centrist" Democratic Party establishment think tank, launched an unprovoked attack against Elizabeth Warren and Bill deBlasio, which backfired badly.
Questions for Martha McSally: Jim Nintzel doesn’t get an answer either – again
December 9, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
In this new series, "Questions for Martha McSally," we pose questions to the McSally campaign about her positions on current hot topics — I am not going to give her a free pass until after the GOP primary like our local media did in 2012.
Jim Nintzel of the Tucson Weekly and host of the Arizona Illustrated political roundtable tried to get Martha McSally to take a position on the current hot topic of gay marriage and "ObamaCare" and – suprise! – McSally is still hiding in the bunker with no ready answer to substantive questions. This is one incredibly ill-informed and ill-prepared candidate for someone who has been running for office since 2010. In Sickness and in Health:
What about gay marriage? Are you evolving on that at all?
Am I evolving on that?
A lot of people seem to be evolving on that. You said last time out that you supported a constitutional amendment to limit marriage to one man and one woman. Now we have it in all these states.
I believe it's primarily a state issue. When you're answering these surveys, sometimes it's a "yes/no" question when really it should be an essay answer that's appropriate.
The policy shift that is remaking China
December 8, 2013
By Karl Reiner
China has come a long way since Mao Zedong and the Communists came to power in 1949. China's recent successful development has not come easy, its architects had learned from watching the consequences of failing policies. After the chaos of the Great Leap Forward, Mao launched the Cultural Revolution to control the reformist tendencies he disliked. The situation spiraled out of control because the turmoil of the Cultural Revolution led to a 12% decline in industrial production, increasing illiteracy as schools were closed down and at least three million deaths.
Zhou Enlai started the process of reversing Mao's costly and failed policies. Deng Xiaoping, who had been purged twice, came to power in 1978. Deng allowed Mao-era rhetoric to continue while he ushered in more changes, the decentralization of decision making, economic reform and a focus on exports. The Chinese Communist Party's decision in 1992 to create what it called a socialist market economy, increased privatization. Deng's policies helped move China to a market economy that lifted 400 million people out of poverty.
Another perspective on the recent international PISA scores
December 8, 2013
by
by David Safier Who said this? "The biggest criticism is that China's education has sacrificed everything else for test scores, such as life skills, character building, mental health, and physical health." It wasn't some anti-test radical educator in the U.S. The speaker was Xiong Bingqi, a Shanghai-based scholar on education. Shanghai's students got the highest … Read more
Steller’s informative primer on charter school funding
December 8, 2013
by
by David Safier
On Friday, Ann-Eve Pedersen and I recorded a story about the latest charter school funding controversy for our cable TV show, Education: The Rest of the Story. It hasn't aired yet, but in the meanwhile, Tim Steller has done a first rate job of covering similar material. He's got most of the information — and got it right — in his Sunday column, More money for charter schools should mean higher expectations.
Steller isn't a charter school basher. He has kids in a charter, a choice I respect. When parents find schools they believe are best suited for their children, that's where they should send their children. But Steller is clear-eyed about the funding issue, offering a lucid discussion of most of the important issues.
I've tried my damndest to understand the issue of equitable funding of charters and school district schools, and I've never come up with a go-to-the-bank answer. For me, the best question to ask if you want to make an apples-to-apples comparison is, how much money goes to educate the child without special needs sitting in a classroom? If the figures are similar for charters and district schools, then the system is reasonably equitable.
Interestingly, the best answer I've received is from Chris Ackerley, a physics teacher at Amphi High and a Republican who ran for state legislature. Chris and I disagree on lots of issues, but he's a smart guy who's better with numbers than I am, and he took an objective look at school funding. His takeaway was, when looking at the money that goes for students' educations — the money that goes to that median student sitting in a classroom — some schools get a bit more, some a bit less, but it doesn't break down into a charter/district school dichotomy. On the whole, they receive similar funding.
An Evening with David Fitzsimmons
December 8, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Announcement from the Democratic Club of the Santa Rita Area:




