Featured Stories
Questions for Martha McSally: On what basis do you assert that Davis-Monthan AFB will close?
October 3, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Martha McSally told The Arizona Republic that her "top priority will be keeping the A-10 aircraft, which she flew as the first female airman in combat, from from being phased out at Davis-Monthan Air Force Base."
McSally also told the Sierra Vista Herald:
Noting the district includes two important military installations — the Air Force’s Davis-Monthan Air Force Base in Tucson and the Army’s Fort Huachuca in Serra Vista — she said both are in danger of being closed if actions are not taken to strengthen them with additional missions.
As for the air base, McSally, who served at Davis-Monthan, said the Air Force is on the verge of making a bad operational decision to eliminate the A-10, a close air support aircraft, a plane she flew over Afghanistan.
There is no other aircraft which can provide the close air support ground forces need, McSally said.
Back in January of 2012, the Air Force announced that it would begin phasing out the 40 year old A-10 aircraft — in 2028. This has led to fear mongering by local talk radio, see James T. Harris Flake drops A-10 bomb on constituents – Arizona Daily Independent (Flake confirmed for listeners of the James T. Harris radio show that one of their worst fears was true: the A-10 has been marked for elimination in the next 1 to 2 years), and by Martha McSally that Pentagon budget cuts (i.e., the GOP sequester) could lead to the retirement of the A-10 in the next couple of years, or with the next round of the Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) commission in 2015. See this KGUN 9 Tucson report (sourced entirely to Martha McSally).
All this gloom and doom Armageddon talk is entirely speculation at this point. I've lived in Tucson long enough to remember the previous half-dozen times or so that Chicken Littles predicted "the sky is falling" with the imminent closure of Davis-Monthan, and the base is still operational. Davis-Monthan is a fair weather air force base for flight training in unrestricted air space with access to the Goldwater Bombing Range, and its "boneyard" for spare parts is a vital resource. Davis-Monthan has other critical missions assigned to it besides the aging A-10, so it is not closing any time soon.
But, Its More Complicated Than That
October 3, 2013
By Tom Prezelski
Re-Posted from Rum, Romanism and Rebellion
Back in 1995, during the last government shutdown, prompted, as some might recall, by Speaker Newt Gingrich’s fit of bratty pique after a perceived snub by President Clinton, Arizona Governor J. Fife “Three Sticks” Symington pledged that he would take action to keep Grand Canyon National Park open during the crisis. He sent the Arizona National Guard in for this purpose. The Guard protected access to one road that ran from the park boundary to a single scenic overlook for a day or so. In other words, they did exactly enough to provide a show for the teevee and nothing else.
Yet, as late as 2007, I heard a member of the legislature brag about how the State showed how they could run the park better and cheaper than the federal government could, but it would be difficult for anyone to sincerely say that what the Guard was doing was the same as managing a 1900 square mile piece of land that receives over four million visitors a year.
Speaking of insincerity, in the wake of the phony umbrage which followed the lockout of veterans from the World War II Memorial, Republican National Committee Chairman Rence Priebus pledged $150,000 to pay a small staff of 5 security guards to keep the monument open for a month. Like Symington before him, Preibus, seems to be gleefully ignorant of what running a public park actually entails.
The GOP’s a la cart budget plan is a prequel to the ‘prioritized’ debt ceiling bomb
October 2, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
The latest GOP gimmick comes from Speaker of the House Sen. Ted "Calgary" Cruz, an interloper in the House, whose Plan E is an a la carte funding of government agencies that the GOP will be embarrassed by if the Tea Party "Suicide Caucus" Shutdown continues – for veterans’ programs, national
parks and museums, and services in Washington – and to punish government agencies it detests, like the EPA and the IRS.
On Tuesday night, Plan E failed, but the GOP will bring it back up for a vote on Wednesday because they are fresh out of gimmicks. House G.O.P. Pushes Piecemeal Approach as Democrats Stand Firm:
The Republicans suffered embarrassing losses on Tuesday night when three bills — to finance veterans’ programs, national parks and museums, and services in Washington — failed to get the two-thirds majority required to pass under fast-track procedures.
The list of federal programs being singled out for financing is expanding. Democrats criticized House Republicans on Tuesday for choosing national parks over cancer research at the National Institutes of Health. The response: a measure to finance the health institutes, too. Congress had already passed legislation to make sure active duty uniformed military forces would continue to be paid. Criticized for leaving out the National Guard and Reserves, Republicans added them to the favored list.
The White House has already threatened a veto.
“Consideration of appropriations bills in a piecemeal fashion is not a serious or responsible way to run the United States Government,” the White House budget office said. “Instead of opening up a few Government functions, the House of Representatives should reopen all of the Government.”
* * *
Democrats say they will not negotiate any changes to the health care law, nor will they reopen the government piece by piece. To do so, they said, would only encourage Republican brinkmanship.
What is reallly at stake: the principle of majority rule in a democracy
October 2, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Steve Benen has a must read post today that crystalizes what is reallly at stake in this Tea Party "Suicide Caucus" Shutdown: the principle of majority rule in a democracy. 'Defending the health of our democracy':
Kudos to James Downie for bring the Federalist Papers into the debate:
"If a faction consists of less than a majority," wrote James Madison in Federalist No. 10, "relief is supplied by the republican principle, which enables the majority to defeat its sinister views by regular vote. It may clog the administration, it may convulse the society; but it will be unable to execute and mask its violence under the forms of the Constitution." The idea that voting expresses the popular will, that elections' results have consequences, is fundamental to democracy. It is also an idea that Republicans are determined to ignore.
Quite right. Thomas Friedman is thinking along similar lines.
This time is different. What is at stake in this government shutdown forced by a radical Tea Party minority is nothing less than the principle upon which our democracy is based: majority rule. President Obama must not give in to this hostage taking — not just because Obamacare is at stake, but because the future of how we govern ourselves is at stake. […]
If democracy means anything, it means that, if you are outvoted, you accept the results and prepare for the next election. Republicans are refusing to do that. It shows contempt for the democratic process.
President Obama is not defending health care. He's defending the health of our democracy. Every American who cherishes that should stand with him.
It's fair to say that Friedman, love him or hate him, is not a partisan bomb-thrower or a reflexive ideologue. I don't imagine it was easy for him to write a column accusing Republican lawmakers of attacking democratic norms and abandoning the standards of the American tradition, which makes it all the more important that he did so anyway.
Questions for Martha McSally: ‘Why not?’ I’ll tell you why not
October 2, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
For several months now, this blog has posted a series of "Questions for Martha McSally" regarding her positions on current hot topics — I am not going to give her a free pass until after the GOP primary like our local media did in 2012. I had hoped this would encourage local media to be more aggressive in questioning McSally, instead of allowing McSally a free pass.
At least on day one of the "official" McSally campaign, my hopes were dashed. Wick Communications, which essentially controls small town newspapers in Southern Arizona, failed miserably in the coverage of Martha McSally's campaign kick-off — which also happened to fall on day one of the Tea Party "Suicide Caucus" Shutdown of the federal government.
The editors allowed McSally to simply spew empty platitudes, bumper sticker slogans, and ad hominem attacks on President Obama that she no doubt memorized at GOPAC candidate school, or was provided by "The Scarp," former Arizona Daily Star reporter Daniel Scarpinato from the RNCC.
In reading through the superficial reporting below, it is painfully obvious that Martha McSally is a vacuous candidate who does not know enough about any subject to offer a thoughtful and detailed explanation of her positions. So she continues to hide in the bunker and refuses to offer any detailed explanations of her positions. McSally is counting on our local media to give her a free pass again this time. At least on day one, McSally got exactly what she wanted from our local media.
The shutdown in the news — False Equivalency edition
October 2, 2013
by
by David Safier
There's what happens and what the media says happens. Sometimes they're pretty close to the same, other times, not so much. The most important thing to watch in the reporting of the shutdown isn't the purely factual reporting. That's reasonably straightforward. It's whether coverage follows the false equivalency viewpoint — a pox on all their houses for the shutdown, no matter who bears the brunt of the blame — or points out that the Republican party, led by its far right wing, has created the messwe're in.
My verdict based on coverage I'm seeing in the Star and a few other papers: false equivalency is still rearing its ugly head, but lots of the commentary, especially editorials, is getting it right.
The AP story the Star put on its front page is pure false equivalency. It actually lets the Republicans draw first blood, saying in the second paragraph, "Republicans said it was [Obama's] fault, not theirs, and embarked on a strategy — opposed by Democrats — of voting on bills to reopen individual agencies or programs."
But then you turn to the editorial, which tells the story correctly.
[T]here are times, as we have reached now, when a small number of elected officials — this time a fundamentalist subset of the Republican Party — can monkey-wrench the legislative process and hold the country hostage to their unreasonable demands.
The bottom line, to our mind, is one of practicality: One cannot reason with bullies. Any attempt to do so presupposes a position of good faith that we have yet to see in the tea-party Republicans who are putting their beliefs and political aspirations above the law of the land.
Crazy Talk
October 1, 2013
by
Posted by Bob Lord
Thsi is what happens when your efforts to appear "centrist" are over the top.
From Kyrsten Sinema, per Arizona Eagletarian:
A government shutdown is an abandonment of Congress' basic duty, and that’s shameful. Arizonans are angry and I don't blame them. I am angry. Time has run out and both parties are responsible. Every single effort by the House and Senate must be a step towards finding common sense and middle ground.
Both parties? Really?
Jimmy Kimmel demonstrates public ignorance about ‘ObamaCare’
October 1, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
These ignorant people make you want to cry for the future of our country. And these low information voters maybe will vote, if they remember its election day. the LA Times reports, Jimmy Kimmel: Do you prefer Obamacare or the Affordable Care Act?:
Jimmy Kimmel, the late-night talk show, has become known for his man-on-the-street interviews where he exposes people's ignorance on music, fashion, current events and other trends.
So on the eve of the Affordable Health Care Act rollout, he dispatched a camera crew to ask people in Hollywood: Which is better — The Affordable Care Act or Obamacare?
Hilarity quickly ensues.
BTW, Republican support of President Obama’s healthcare legislation rose by eight percentage points when identified as the Affordable Care Act instead of “Obamacare,” in a new Fox News poll.




