Computers grading essays?
April 5, 2013
by
by David Safier
The NY Times has an article about essay grading software being given away free by EdX, a "nonprofit enterprise founded by Harvard and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology to offer courses on the Internet." I rebel at the thought. Computers are, as someone said to me long ago, lightning fast idiots. In the time since I heard that line, the idiots have become far more sophisticated. They play terrific chess. They answer questions on my phone. They do a pretty good job on Jeopardy. But grading higher level thinking and the quality of someone's prose? I'm very, very skeptical.
Here's what happens. A student writes an essay on a computer and submits it to the program. Faster than you can say "Have you graded my essay yet?" the results are back, with the essay scored and corrections made. A student can improve the essay on the spot and resubmit it for a better grade and more suggestions.
The problem is, the computer isn't actually "reading" the essay the way a human being does. People have submitted lofty sounding gobbledygook to these programs and gotten high scores, because the software scans for certain traits in the essay which it uses for evaluation. It can't take in the essay's totality — its overall logic and subtlety of thought.
On the other hand . . . This kind of "artificial intelligence" is part of our future. Meanwhile, teachers are assigning less writing as their class loads increase (If you grade essays for 160 students giving yourself 5 minutes per essay, you'll be finished in 13 hours and 20 minutes! Been there, done that.). The question is, can this kind of computer grading be put to good use by good teachers? I think so.
A moment of clarity: Tea-Publicans have no interest in governing responsibly
April 5, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
I have said before that I believe President Obama is terrible at negotiation. For a Harvard educated attorney, he frequently violates the first rule of negotiation: never negotiate against yourself. His opening bid is frequently where the other side would like to end up at the end, which only encourages the GOP to get greedy and to move the goal line where they want to end up at the end even farther to the right.
But there is a counter-intuitive argument that some have adopted to explain President Obama's negotiation style. They argue that he is Mr. Spock playing 11-dimensional chess, demonstrating that there is literally nothing he could offer Republicans — even things they themselves have said they want — to induce them to compromise. Even if this were true, I am left to ask "to what end?"
This tactic will not get the president the "grand bargain" he claims to desire. All the while it undermines the legitimacy of Democratic Party principles by playing this game on a field determined by the GOP — Mr. President, please stop using the GOP message framing and giving legitimacy to their arguments, which have no legitimacy in the real world of economics. Faith based supply-side "tricke down" GOP austerity economics is an unmitigated disaster, and has been entirely disproved and discredited. Allowing this to continue is no "bargain," it is insanity.
Yet that is where we find ourselves today. Greg Sargent writes, Why Obama wants a Grand Bargain:
The news of the morning is that President Obama will propose a budget next week that includes specific cuts in Social Security and Medicare along with new revenues — an effort to bring Republicans back to the table for a “Grand Bargain” to replace the sequester.
March jobs report suffers from Tea-Publican austerity measures
April 5, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
Following the "sequester" that everyone in Washington, D.C. said would never happen — ignoring the evil desires of the GOP to see it happen, and even giving the V-sign to claim victory when it did happen — and the GOP's renewal of its threat to take the country hostage again over the federal debt ceiling, Americans have lost faith in the ability of Congress to govern.
Remember that GOP talking point about "uncertainty" in the economy (in the context of taxes) affecting decisions to invest and hire more workers? Uncertainty is what we have right now with the Tea-Publican economic terrorists in Congress imposing their failed economic theory of austerity. So the March jobs report really should come as no surprise to anyone. Steve Benen reports, Job totals stumble to 10-month low:
The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported this morning that the U.S. economy created just 88,000 jobs in March, the worst in the last 10 months. As is usually the case, there was a gap between the two major sectors — America's private sector added 95,000 jobs last month, the public sector lost 7,000 jobs, though most of those totals were driven by Post Office layoffs.
The news is awful, but there was a silver lining: totals from January were revised up to 148,000 jobs (from 119,000), while February was revised up to 268,000 (from +236,000). The additional 61,000 jobs helped push the unemployment rate to 7.6%, its lowest point since December 2008.
Black helicopters day at the Arizona Lege
April 5, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
The Tea-Publican Birthers-Birchers-Secessionists in the Arizona lege held "black helicopters" day on Thursday to advance a couple of their wild conspiracy theory bills. Arizona is sovereign land, House tells US and UN:
If the federal government wants to lock up U.S. citizens without trial it should not count on Arizona to cooperate, the state House announced Thursday.
Lawmakers also voted to have the United Nations butt out of trying to affect Arizona laws and policies. And the House agreed to have the state take the first steps to recognize privately minted gold and silver coins as legal tender in anticipation of the collapse of the dollar.
Underlying all these actions is the argument that Arizona is a sovereign state, and the votes stake out a position to defend that sovereignty.
The first part of HB 2573 deals with two sections of the 2012 National Defense Authorization Act, which give [the] President Obama the authority "to use all necessary and appropriate force" to detain certain people without trial. That includes not only those who planned or aided in the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, but anyone who "substantially supported al-Qaida, the Taliban or associated forces."
[Actually a reauthorization of existing law, but Howie Fischer wants to feed the Obama Derangement Syndrome of the Tea-Publican Birthers-Birchers-Secessionists.]
It includes U.S. citizens and provides for military trials.
Postcard to Congress: Save Tucson’s Cherybell Mail Processing Center
April 5, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
You can bet the U.S. Postal Service will deliver this postcard. Here is a press release update on the effort to save Tucson's Cherybell Mail Processing Center from closure this year.
UPDATE: Dalessandro’s efforts to keep Cherrybell Mail Processing Center open continues to Congress
STATE CAPITOL, PHOENIX – Today Rep. Andrea Dalessandro, D-Sahuarita (District 2), announced that her effort to keep the Cherrybell Mail Processing Center open earned overwhelming support in the Arizona Senate and will now go to the United States Congress.
Dalessandro sponsored House Concurrent Memorial 2007, which asks Congress to take action against the closing of the Cherrybell Mail Processing Center in Tucson. A house concurrent memorial can be used by the State Legislature to make an official statement on an issue outside its jurisdiction.
“I am thrilled my concurrent memorial passed both the Arizona House and the Arizona Senate and is now on its way to U.S. House Speaker Boehner, U.S. Senate President Harry Reid and the entire Arizona congressional delegation. If the Cherrybell Mail Processing Center closes, nearly 300 Arizonans could lose their jobs. I hope they see the importance of keeping these Arizonans employed,” Dalessandro said. “The first step to job growth is to keep the jobs we already have.”
$15 Per Hour: It’s Australian For Minimum Wage, Mate
April 4, 2013
by
Posted by Bob Lord After spending a week in Melbourne, Australia visiting our daughter and son-in-law, I have to reconsider my views about wealth and income inequality. NOT Want a job paying $15 per hour? Just move to Australia and work for the minimum wage. Yes, the cost of living there is a bit … Read more
‘Kochtopus’ astroturf campaign against Gov. Jan Brewer’s Medicaid (AHCCCS) restoration plan
April 4, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
I have said it before, and I will say it again: how long are Arizonans going to tolerate the billionaire bastard Koch brothers dictating public policy in Arizona? It's time to tear up the "Kochtopus" network of astroturf far-right organizations in this state by the roots and salt the ground to make sure that they never grow back again.
The opposition to Gov. Jan Brewer's Medicaid (AHCCCS) restoration plan does not come from rank and file voters in this state, but rather an astroturf campaign by the "Kochtopus" far-right organizations, incuding the Tea Party groups. The Arizona Capitol Times (subscription required) calls them out. AFP, anti-Obamacare docs denounce Medicaid expansion:
A small group of conservative doctors gathered at the Capitol in opposition to Gov. Jan Brewer’s Medicaid expansion proposal, arguing that it will damage health care in Arizona and cause a host of problems at the federal level.
At a Tuesday afternoon press conference organized by the Arizona chapter of the conservative group Americans for Prosperity, three doctors urged the state to reject Brewer’s plan, which would expand Medicaid to cover anyone earning up to 133 percent of the federal poverty level. The doctors have been vocal opponents of the Affordable Care Act.
Tempe to debate joining Bisbee with civil unions ordinance
April 4, 2013
Posted by AzBlueMeanie:
OK, I thought the City of Tucson and/or Flagstaff would be the first to take up my challenge to lock arms with the city of Bisbee in enacting a civil unions ordinace to stick a finger in the eye of Mullah Cathi Herrod and her Christian Taliban at the Center for Arizona Policy and the self righteous Tom "banned for life by the SEC" Horne, but it appears that the city of Tempe will take up the challenge first. I tip my hat to you for stepping up to the plate to defend civil rights. Tempe to begin discussion on civil-union laws:
Tempe, a historically progressive city, is poised to become embroiled in the debate over equal rights for same-sex couples.
Today, the Tempe City Council will discuss civil-union laws in its private executive session. The discussion comes two days after residents of Bisbee watched their council approve a historic vote to legalize civil-union certificates, which provide same-sex partners with some of the same rights as married couples.
Tempe Councilman Kolby Granville called the Bisbee vote momentous. On Wednesday, Granville, a Democrat, told The Arizona Republic that he asked for the council executive session on civil unions. He wants Tempe to be the first Valley city to approve civil-union certificates for its residents.
If approved, the legal rights would apply to an estimated 165,000 Tempe residents compared with 5,600 or so in Bisbee.
“Tempe tends to be a leader in issues of civil rights,” Granville said. “And, to me, equality based on sexual orientation is one of those very same civil rights.”




